采用队列多重随机对照试验设计检验抑郁症干预措施的益处与挑战
本文报告了首个完成的采用队列多重随机对照试验(cmRCT)设计的试验——南约克郡抑郁症(DEPSY)试验的经验,该试验在约克郡健康研究大型人群队列中比较常规治疗(TAU)与TAU加提供干预措施。主要挑战为对照组交叉率高和拒绝治疗者问卷应答率较低,但该设计有助于高效完整招募被试并获得可分析且可推广的数据,失访率低于其他抑郁症试验。结论认为该设计带来多项重要益处,需进一步研究比较标准实用型RCT与cmRCT设计的可接受性和成本效果。
要点
- cmRCT设计利用现有大型人群队列,有助于高效完整地招募试验人群。
- 主要挑战是对照组交叉率高以及拒绝治疗提供者问卷应答率较低。
- 该试验失访率低于其他抑郁症试验报告中报告的失访率。
核心结论
- 首个采用cmRCT设计检验自我报告抑郁症干预措施的完整试验具有多项重要益处。
- 需要进一步研究比较标准实用型随机对照试验设计与cmRCT设计的可接受性和成本效果。
研究设计与样本
- 本文报告首个完成的采用队列多重随机对照试验(cmRCT)设计的随机对照试验——南约克郡抑郁症(DEPSY)试验的经验。
- 该试验在约克郡健康研究现有大型人群队列中,比较常规治疗(TAU)与TAU加提供干预措施对自我报告长期中重度抑郁症患者的效果。
- 试验注册:ISRCTN注册库ISRCTN02484593,注册日期2013年1月7日。
主要发现
- 使用cmRCT设计的主要挑战是对照组交叉率高以及拒绝治疗提供者问卷应答率较低。
- 该设计有助于高效完整地招募试验人群,并获得可分析且可推广至目标人群的数据。
- 该试验的失访率低于其他抑郁症试验报告中报告的失访率。
局限性
- 主要挑战是对照组交叉率高以及拒绝治疗提供者问卷应答率较低。
- 需要进一步研究比较标准实用型随机对照试验设计与cmRCT设计的可接受性和成本效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Trials which test the effectiveness of interventions compared with the status quo frequently encounter challenges. The cohort multiple randomised controlled trial (cmRCT) design is an innovative approach to the design and conduct of pragmatic trials which seeks to address some of these challenges. MAIN TEXT: In this article, we report our experiences with the first completed randomised controlled trial (RCT) using the cmRCT design. This trial-the Depression in South Yorkshire (DEPSY) trial-involved comparison of treatment as usual (TAU) with TAU plus the offer of an intervention for people with self-reported long-term moderate to severe depression. In the trial, we used an existing large population-based cohort: the Yorkshire Health Study. We discuss our experiences with recruitment, attrition, crossover, data analysis, generalisability of results, and cost. The main challenges in using the cmRCT design were the high crossover to the control group and the lower questionnaire response rate among patients who refused the offer of treatment. However, the design did help facilitate efficient and complete recruitment of the trial population as well as analysable data that were generalisable to the population of interest. Attrition rates were also smaller than those reported in other depression trials. CONCLUSION: This first completed full trial using the cmRCT design testing an intervention for self-reported depression was associated with a number of important benefits. Further research is required to compare the acceptability and cost effectiveness of standard pragmatic RCT design with the cmRCT design. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN registry: ISRCTN02484593 . Registered on 7 Jan 2013.
引用
- Viksveen P, Relton C, Nicholl J, et al. Benefits and challenges of using the cohort multiple randomised controlled trial design for testing an intervention for depression. Trials. 2017. PMID: 28683809. doi:10.1186/s13063-017-2059-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。