系列:实用性试验与真实世界证据:第8篇 数据收集与管理
GetReal联盟八篇系列文章的最后一篇讨论实用性试验中数据收集的操作与方法学挑战,指出尚无放之四海而皆准的建议,总体上应用现有常规数据收集系统似最适合实用性方法,但数据获取与隐私、收集时间点、数据详细程度及对数据收集过程缺乏清晰理解是使用常规收集数据的主要挑战。
要点
- 实用性数据收集需在高度准确完整的数据与尽量减少对临床实践干扰之间取得平衡。
- 总体上应用现有常规使用的数据收集系统似最适合实用性方法,但无放之四海而皆准的建议。
- 若需更详尽数据或更结构化随访,数据收集须量身定制,常用专用电子病例报告表(eCRF)的混合方法。
核心结论
- 无法为实用性试验的数据收集给出放之四海而皆准的建议,但总体上应用现有常规使用的数据收集系统似最适合实用性方法。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为GetReal联盟八篇系列文章的最后一篇,讨论实用性试验中数据收集的操作与方法学挑战,并在可能处提出潜在解决方案。
主要发现
- 数据获取与隐私、数据收集的时间点、数据的详细程度以及对数据收集过程缺乏清晰理解被确定为在实用性试验中使用常规收集数据的主要挑战。
- 当需要更精细或更详细的数据收集或更结构化的随访时,实用性试验的数据收集将不得不量身定制,常采用使用专用电子病例报告表(eCRF)的混合方法。
关键数值与推荐
- 第一步应是确定现有医疗保健数据库在多大程度上提供必要的研究数据并能容纳数据收集与管理。
- 在需使用专用eCRF时,eCRF应尽可能简单,以减少执业者的负担并尽量减少对常规临床实践的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Pragmatic trials can improve our understanding of how treatments will perform in routine practice. In a series of eight papers, the GetReal Consortium has evaluated the challenges in designing and conducting pragmatic trials and their specific methodological, operational, regulatory, and ethical implications. The present final paper of the series discusses the operational and methodological challenges of data collection in pragmatic trials. A more pragmatic data collection needs to balance the delivery of highly accurate and complete data with minimizing the level of interference that data entry and verification induce with clinical practice. Furthermore, it should allow for the involvement of a representative sample of practices, physicians, and patients who prescribe/receive treatment in routine care. This paper discusses challenges that are related to the different methods of data collection and presents potential solutions where possible. No one-size-fits-all recommendation can be given for the collection of data in pragmatic trials, although in general the application of existing routinely used data-collection systems and processes seems to best suit the pragmatic approach. However, data access and privacy, the time points of data collection, the level of detail in the data, and the lack of a clear understanding of the data-collection process were identified as main challenges for the usage of routinely collected data in pragmatic trials. A first step should be to determine to what extent existing health care databases provide the necessary study data and can accommodate data collection and management. When more elaborate or detailed data collection or more structured follow-up is required, data collection in a pragmatic trial will have to be tailor-made, often using a hybrid approach using a dedicated electronic case report form (eCRF). In this case, the eCRF should be kept as simple as possible to reduce the burden for practitioners and minimize influence on routine clinical practice.
引用
- Meinecke AK, Welsing P, Kafatos G, et al. Series: Pragmatic trials and real world evidence: Paper 8. Data collection and management. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28716504. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.07.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。