现有临床试验报告指南并非完全适用于植入式医疗器械:一项系统综述
本研究由专家组基于参考文献确定评价植入式医疗器械(IMD)最相关的报告条目,并对MEDLINE收录文献及EQUATOR网络报告指南库进行系统综述,筛选包含这些条目的指南。结果选出7个相关条目(涉及随机化、学习曲线、手术环境和器械信息),共识别348部指南、26部符合纳入标准,但无一部同时包含全部7个条目;最常报告的条目为随机化时机(65%),器械信息与学习曲线效应报告不足。
要点
- 专家组选出7个与植入式医疗器械相关的报告条目,涉及随机化、学习曲线、手术环境和器械信息四方面。
- 共识别348部报告指南,26部符合纳入标准,但无一部同时包含全部7个条目。
- 最常报告的条目为随机化时机(65%),器械信息与学习曲线效应报告不足。
核心结论
- 据作者所知,本研究首次识别临床试验报告指南中与植入式医疗器械相关的特定条目,并显示现有报告指南均不完全适用于此类器械。
研究设计与样本
- 由专家组基于参考文献确定评价植入式医疗器械最相关的报告条目,并对MEDLINE收录文献进行系统综述,从EQUATOR网络健康研究报告指南库检索报告指南,再筛选使用该组条目的指南。
主要发现
- 选出7个相关报告条目,涉及随机化、学习曲线、手术环境和器械信息四个主题。
- 共识别348部报告指南,其中26部符合纳入标准,但无一部同时呈现全部7个条目。
- 最常报告的条目为随机化时机(65%),而器械信息与学习曲线效应报告不足。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to determine relevant items for reporting clinical trials on implantable medical devices (IMDs) and to identify reporting guidelines which include these items. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A panel of experts identified the most relevant items for evaluating IMDs from an initial list based on reference papers. We then conducted a systematic review of articles indexed in MEDLINE. We retrieved reporting guidelines from the EQUATOR network's library for health research reporting. Finally, we screened these reporting guidelines to find those using our set of reporting items. RESULTS: Seven relevant reporting items were selected that related to four topics: randomization, learning curve, surgical setting, and device information. A total of 348 reporting guidelines were identified, among which 26 met our inclusion criteria. However, none of the 26 reporting guidelines presented all seven items together. The most frequently reported item was timing of randomization (65%). On the contrary, device information and learning curve effects were poorly specified. CONCLUSION: To our knowledge, this study is the first to identify specific items related to IMDs in reporting guidelines for clinical trials. We have shown that no existing reporting guideline is totally suitable for these devices.
引用
- Motte AF, Diallo S, van den Brink H, et al. Existing reporting guidelines for clinical trials are not completely relevant for implantable medical devices: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28728922. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.07.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。