通过全国性和针对性膳食政策减轻美国心血管疾病负担与差异:一项建模研究
该建模研究利用美国IMPACT食品政策模型和概率敏感性分析,评估2015至2030年间多种膳食政策对心血管疾病死亡及社会经济差异的潜在影响。针对SNAP参与者的30%水果蔬菜补贴最能缩小差异(约8%);组合政策对死亡和差异影响最大。
要点
- 全国性10%水果蔬菜补贴预计至2030年避免或推迟约150,500例心血管死亡,为单项政策中最优。
- 针对SNAP参与者的30%水果蔬菜补贴可能缩小SNAP参与者与非符合条件者间心血管差异约8%。
- 组合政策预计避免或推迟约230,000例心血管死亡,并显著缩小差异约6%。
核心结论
- 针对膳食的财政策略可能大幅减轻心血管疾病负担,全国性10%水果蔬菜补贴挽救生命最多,针对SNAP参与者的30%水果蔬菜补贴最能缩小社会经济差异,组合政策对死亡和差异总体影响最大。
研究设计与样本
- 使用美国IMPACT食品政策模型和概率敏感性分析,评估2015至2030年间特定膳食政策情景对美国人群心血管死亡和社会经济差异的潜在影响,数据来源包括监测、流行病学和最终结果项目、国家生命统计系统、国家健康与营养检查调查及已发表meta分析。
主要发现
- 全国性10%水果蔬菜补贴预计至2030年避免或推迟约150,500例心血管死亡(95%不确定性区间141,400-158,500)。
- 针对SNAP参与者的30%水果蔬菜补贴预计避免或推迟约35,100例心血管死亡(95%不确定性区间31,700-37,500)。
- 为期1年的全国大众媒体宣传预计避免或推迟约25,800例心血管死亡(95%不确定性区间24,300-28,500)。
- 全国性10%含糖饮料税预计避免或推迟约31,000例心血管死亡(95%不确定性区间26,800-35,300)。
- 大众媒体宣传或单项全国性经济政策均未显著缩小心血管社会经济差异;针对SNAP的干预可能缩小SNAP参与者与非符合条件者间差异约8%(每10万人10例避免或推迟死亡)。
局限性
- 模型中的效应估计使用干预性和前瞻性观察性研究(不 exclusively 随机对照试验),因此不完美,应解释为最佳可用证据。
- 仅考虑心血管结局,所探索政策无疑会对其他疾病产生额外有益影响。
- 未建模或比较每种拟议政策的成本效益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Large socio-economic disparities exist in US dietary habits and cardiovascular disease (CVD) mortality. While economic incentives have demonstrated success in improving dietary choices, the quantitative impact of different dietary policies on CVD disparities is not well established. We aimed to quantify and compare the potential effects on total CVD mortality and disparities of specific dietary policies to increase fruit and vegetable (F&V) consumption and reduce sugar-sweetened beverage (SSB) consumption in the US. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Using the US IMPACT Food Policy Model and probabilistic sensitivity analyses, we estimated and compared the reductions in CVD mortality and socio-economic disparities in the US population potentially achievable from 2015 to 2030 with specific dietary policy scenarios: (a) a national mass media campaign (MMC) aimed to increase consumption of F&Vs and reduce consumption of SSBs, (b) a national fiscal policy to tax SSBs to increase prices by 10%, (c) a national fiscal policy to subsidise F&Vs to reduce prices by 10%, and (d) a targeted policy to subsidise F&Vs to reduce prices by 30% among Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) participants only. We also evaluated a combined policy approach, combining all of the above policies. Data sources included the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program, National Vital Statistics System, National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, and published meta-analyses. Among the individual policy scenarios, a national 10% F&V subsidy was projected to be most beneficial, potentially resulting in approximately 150,500 (95% uncertainty interval [UI] 141,400-158,500) CVD deaths prevented or postponed (DPPs) by 2030 in the US. This far exceeds the approximately 35,100 (95% UI 31,700-37,500) DPPs potentially attributable to a 30% F&V subsidy targeting SNAP participants, the approximately 25,800 (95% UI 24,300-28,500) DPPs for a 1-y MMC, or the approximately 31,000 (95% UI 26,800-35,300) DPPs for a 10% SSB tax. Neither the MMC nor the individual national economic policies would significantly reduce CVD socio-economic disparities. However, the SNAP-targeted intervention might potentially reduce CVD disparities between SNAP participants and SNAP-ineligible individuals, by approximately 8% (10 DPPs per 100,000 population). The combined policy approach might save more lives than any single policy studied (approximately 230,000 DPPs by 2030) while also significantly reducing disparities, by approximately 6% (7 DPPs per 100,000 population). Limitations include our effect estimates in the model; these estimates use interventional and prospective observational studies (not exclusively randomised controlled trials). They are thus imperfect and should be interpreted as the best available evidence. Another key limitation is that we considered only CVD outcomes; the policies we explored would undoubtedly have additional beneficial effects upon other diseases. Further, we did not model or compare the cost-effectiveness of each proposed policy. CONCLUSIONS: Fiscal strategies targeting diet might substantially reduce CVD burdens. A national 10% F&V subsidy would save by far the most lives, while a 30% F&V subsidy targeting SNAP participants would most reduce socio-economic disparities. A combined policy would have the greatest overall impact on both mortality and socio-economic disparities.
引用
- Pearson-Stuttard J, Bandosz P, Rehm CD, et al. Reducing US cardiovascular disease burden and disparities through national and targeted dietary policies: A modelling study. PLoS Med. 2017. PMID: 28586351. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002311
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。