测试简化检索策略用于更新系统评价的有效性
本研究基于本课题组已完成的9篇系统评价,比较简化检索策略(SSS)与全面检索在更新中的表现。全面检索共筛选55099条记录并最终纳入163项随机对照试验;SSS命中8239条,中位灵敏度83.3%,精确度和需阅读数均优于参照检索。临床聚焦主题的SSS中位灵敏度为100%,而较广泛主题为80%。
要点
- 临床聚焦主题的SSS中位灵敏度为100%,精确度和NNR均较参照检索优6倍。
- 较广泛主题的SSS灵敏度为80%,精确度和NNR较参照检索优5.4倍。
- 作者认为SSS对临床聚焦主题可作为常规全面检索的可行替代方案。
核心结论
- SSS对临床聚焦主题表现良好,中位灵敏度100%,在预算限制和新文献量大的情况下可能作为常规全面检索的可行替代方案。
- 对较广泛主题,80%灵敏度在多数情况下可能被认为对系统评价更新过低,但若更新范围综述或快速综述则可能可接受。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究识别了本课题组完成的9篇系统评价,这些评价均同时进行了全面检索更新和SSS更新。
- 研究估计了三个性能指标:灵敏度、精确度和需阅读数(NNR)。
主要发现
- 9篇系统评价的更新参照检索共识别55099条记录,经筛选最终纳入163项随机对照试验。
- 与参照检索相比,SSS命中8239条,中位灵敏度为83.3%,精确度和NNR均好4.5倍。
- 临床聚焦主题中,SSS中位灵敏度为100%,精确度和NNR较参照检索好6倍。
- 较广泛主题中,SSS灵敏度为80%,精确度和NNR较参照检索好5.4倍。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对临床聚焦主题的系统评价更新,SSS可考虑作为常规全面检索的可行替代方案,尤其考虑预算限制和新发表文献量。
- 作者认为,对较广泛主题,80%灵敏度在多数情况下可能被认为对系统评价更新过低,但若更新范围综述或快速综述则可能可接受。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of the study was to test the overall effectiveness of a simplified search strategy (SSS) for updating systematic reviews. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: We identified nine systematic reviews undertaken by our research group for which both comprehensive and SSS updates were performed. Three relevant performance measures were estimated, that is, sensitivity, precision, and number needed to read (NNR). RESULTS: The update reference searches for all nine included systematic reviews identified a total of 55,099 citations that were screened resulting in final inclusion of 163 randomized controlled trials. As compared with reference search, the SSS resulted in 8,239 hits and had a median sensitivity of 83.3%, while precision and NNR were 4.5 times better. During analysis, we found that the SSS performed better for clinically focused topics, with a median sensitivity of 100% and precision and NNR 6 times better than for the reference searches. For broader topics, the sensitivity of the SSS was 80% while precision and NNR were 5.4 times better compared with reference search. CONCLUSION: SSS performed well for clinically focused topics and, with a median sensitivity of 100%, could be a viable alternative to a conventional comprehensive search strategy for updating this type of systematic reviews particularly considering the budget constraints and the volume of new literature being published. For broader topics, 80% sensitivity is likely to be considered too low for a systematic review update in most cases, although it might be acceptable if updating a scoping or rapid review.
引用
- Rice M, Ali MU, Fitzpatrick-Lewis D, et al. Testing the effectiveness of simplified search strategies for updating systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28625563. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.06.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。