网络Meta分析中效应修饰报告的不足:一项元流行病学调查
该元流行病学调查系统检索2013年MEDLINE和Embase收录的网络Meta分析(NMA),评估效应修饰的报告与处理现状。共纳入77篇NMA,最常见效应修饰因素为患者特征(50.7%,39/77),最常见调整方法为敏感性分析(51.7%,30/58)。超过45%(35/77)未描述计划,近40%(30/77)未报告分析结果,约47%(36/77)报告不完整;期刊影响因子、随机对照试验与比较数之比及随机对照试验总数与报告完整性显著相关。
要点
- 77篇NMA中50.7%(39/77)识别并探索患者特征作为效应修饰因素。
- 51.7%(30/58)使用敏感性分析作为效应修饰调整方法。
- 近半NMA未探索或报告效应修饰,报告实践普遍不足。
核心结论
- 当前NMA对效应修饰的报告实践普遍不足,近半数已发表NMA未探索或报告效应修饰。
研究设计与样本
- 采用元流行病学调查,通过系统综述检索2013年MEDLINE和Embase数据库发表的网络Meta分析(NMA),共纳入77篇NMA。
主要发现
- 最常见的效应修饰因素为患者特征(50.7%,39/77)。
- 最常用的调整方法为敏感性分析(51.7%,30/58)。
- 超过45%(35/77)的研究未描述计划,近40%(30/77)未报告分析结果,约47%(36/77)报告不完整。
- 探索性单变量回归分析显示,期刊影响因子、随机对照试验与比较数之比、随机对照试验总数与报告完整性存在统计学显著关联。
关键数值与推荐
- 效应修饰因素识别率:患者特征50.7%(39/77)。
- 调整方法使用率:敏感性分析51.7%(30/58)。
- 报告缺陷率:未描述计划>45%(35/77),未报告结果近40%(30/77),报告不完整约47%(36/77)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objectives of this study were to evaluate the current state of reporting and handling of effect modification in network meta-analyses (NMAs) and perform exploratory analyses to identify variables that are potentially associated with incomplete reporting of effect modifiers in NMAs. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We conducted a meta-epidemiological survey using a systematic review of NMAs published in 2013 and identified through MEDLINE and Embase databases. RESULTS: The review identified 77 NMAs. The most common type of effect modifiers identified and explored were patient characteristics (50.7% or 39/77), and the most common adjustment method used was sensitivity analysis (51.7% or 30/58). Over 45% (35/77) of studies did not describe a plan, nearly 40% (30/77) did not report the results of analyses, and approximately 47% (36/77) of studies had incomplete reporting. Exploratory univariate regression analyses yielded a statistically significant association for the variables of journal impact factor, ratio of randomized controlled trials to number of comparisons, and total number of randomized controlled trials. CONCLUSION: Current reporting practices are largely deficient, given that almost half of identified published NMAs do not explore or report effect modification. Journal impact factor and amount of available information in a network were associated with completeness of reporting.
引用
- Kovic B, Zoratti MJ, Michalopoulos S, et al. Deficiencies in addressing effect modification in network meta-analyses: a meta-epidemiological survey. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28603010. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.06.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。