龋病学试验中对照选择限制了对龋病干预措施比较有效性结论的得出
该研究对预防/管理龋齿或龋损的随机对照试验进行系统综述,并按三个粒度层级对对照进行分类,采用社会网络分析评估试验网络。共检索到4774篇文章,纳入605项试验,发现侵入性对照最常被测试(对照数592),非侵入性对照次之(464),微侵入性对照再次(234);各层级网络均为多边形,预防试验与管理试验比较分离度高,多数试验在同类内比较而非跨类比较。结论认为对照选择由适应证驱动,限制了关于所有策略真实比较有效性的结论。
要点
- 共纳入605项预防/管理龋齿或龋损的随机对照试验,检索到4774篇文章。
- 侵入性对照最常被测试(对照数592),其次为非侵入性(464)和微侵入性(234)。
- 多数试验在同类内比较而非跨类比较,限制了对所有策略真实比较有效性的结论。
核心结论
- 龋病学试验中对照选择由适应证驱动,限制了对所有策略真实比较有效性的结论。
- 存在多种尚未互相比较但应互相比较的对照,应由未来试验解决。
- 需要识别试验者选择对照的影响因素。
研究设计与样本
- 对预防/管理龋齿或现有龋损的随机对照试验进行系统综述。
- 按三个粒度层级对对照分类:侵入程度(非侵入、微侵入、侵入)、具体方法、实际材料或技术。
- 采用社会网络分析评估试验网络。
- 检索电子数据库共获得4774篇文章,其中764篇相关,605篇纳入。
主要发现
- 所有层级的网络均为多边形。
- 预防试验与管理试验的比较分离度高。
- 侵入性对照最常被测试(对照数592),主要在管理试验中。
- 非侵入性对照次常被测试(对照数464),主要在龋病预防中。
- 微侵入性策略再次常被测试(对照数234),在预防和管理试验中均有。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Comparator choice has been found as one major factor impacting on the overall evidence supporting clinical interventions. We performed social network analysis (SNA) on trials on the prevention/management of caries/carious lesions, hypothesizing that certain comparators are proportionally overinvestigated, and others underinvestigated, and that comparisons within comparator classes are preferred over comparisons between classes. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials on the prevention/management of caries/existing carious lesions was carried out. All comparators were classified at each of three levels of granularity, becoming more detailed with each level: (1) degree of invasiveness (noninvasive, microinvasive, or invasive), (2) the specific noninvasive, microinvasive, or invasive approach, and (3) the actual material or technique used. SNA was used to evaluate trial networks. RESULTS: Searching electronic databases found 4,774 articles; of which, 764 were relevant and 605 were included. The networks for all levels were polygonal. There was a high degree of separation of comparisons in prevention vs. management trials. Invasive comparators were tested most frequently (number of comparators: 592), mainly in management trials. Noninvasive comparators were tested next often (464), mainly in caries prevention. Microinvasive strategies were tested next often (234), in both prevention and management trials. On more granular levels, few interventions dominated the networks. Regardless of the level, most trials compared within and not between classes. Prevention trials were mainly conducted in children (number of trials in adults/children/both: 37/240/11), whereas those on managing lesions were conducted in both children and adults (117/176/21). CONCLUSION: Comparator choice in cariology trials is driven by indication and limits conclusions on the true comparative effectiveness of all strategies. There are a variety of comparators that have not been, but should be, compared with one another, which should be addressed by future trials. Factors underlying trialists' comparator choice need to be identified.
引用
- Schwendicke F, Innes N, Levey C, et al. Comparator choice in cariology trials limits conclusions on the comparative effectiveness of caries interventions. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28652063. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.05.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。