初级保健中转诊至减重项目的延长与标准时长对比(WRAP):一项随机对照试验
这项在英格兰23家初级保健机构开展的非盲平行组随机对照试验纳入1269名BMI≥28 kg/m²的成人,比较简短建议与自助材料、12周或52周开放团体体重管理项目(Weight Watchers)。1年时52周项目减重优于12周项目,后者优于简短建议;52周项目在25年模型下具有成本效益。
要点
- 转诊至开放团体行为减重项目至少12周比简短建议加自助材料更有效。
- 52周项目比12周项目产生更大减重和其他临床获益,但费用更高。
- 模型显示52周项目在较长期内具有成本效益。
核心结论
- 对于超重或肥胖成人,转诊至该开放团体行为减重项目至少12周比简短建议和自助材料更有效。
- 52周项目比12周项目产生更大减重和其他临床获益,虽费用更高,但模型显示52周项目在较长期内具有成本效益。
研究设计与样本
- 非盲平行组随机对照试验,从英格兰23家初级保健机构招募18岁及以上、BMI≥28 kg/m²的参与者。
- 参与者按2:5:5随机分配至简短建议和自助材料组、12周体重管理项目(Weight Watchers)组或52周同一项目组,随访2年。
- 主要结局为1年随访时体重,按意向性治疗原则用混合效应模型分析并校正中心和基线体重;采用分层封闭检验程序先比较合并行为项目组与简短干预组,再比较12周项目与52周项目。
- 试验内成本效益分析使用个体水平数据,并用微观模拟模型化25年时间跨度结局;试验注册号ISRCTN82857232。
主要发现
- 2012年10月18日至2014年2月10日共纳入1269名参与者,1267名合格参与者随机分配至简短干预组(n=211)、12周项目组(n=528)和52周项目组(n=528)。
- 12周项目组2名参与者在随机化后不久发现不符合条件,被排除分析;1267名参与者中823名(65%)完成1年评估,856名(68%)完成2年评估;所有合格参与者均纳入分析。
- 1年时平均体重变化:简短干预组-3.26 kg,12周项目组-4.75 kg,52周项目组-6.76 kg。
- 行为项目组比简短干预组减重更多(校正差值-2.71 kg,95%CI -3.86至-1.55;p<0.0001);52周项目比12周项目更有效(-2.14 kg,-3.05至-1.22;p<0.0001);组间差异在2年时仍显著。
- 未报告与干预相关的不良事件;2年内与简短干预相比,52周项目每减1 kg的增量成本效果比(ICER)为159英镑,12周项目为91英镑;基线后25年模型显示,12周项目与简短干预相比为优势方案,52周项目与简短干预相比(每质量调整生命年[QALY] 2394英镑)及与12周项目相比(每QALY 3804英镑)具有成本效益。
临床怎么用
- 作者结论认为,对于超重或肥胖成人,转诊至该开放团体行为减重项目至少12周比简短建议和自助材料更有效。
- 作者结论认为,52周项目比12周项目产生更大减重和其他临床获益,且虽费用更高,但模型显示52周项目在较长期内具有成本效益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Evidence exist that primary care referral to an open-group behavioural programme is an effective strategy for management of obesity, but little evidence on optimal intervention duration is available. We aimed to establish whether 52-week referral to an open-group weight-management programme would achieve greater weight loss and improvements in a range of health outcomes and be more cost-effective than the current practice of 12-week referrals. METHODS: In this non-blinded, parallel-group, randomised controlled trial, we recruited participants who were aged 18 years or older and had body-mass index (BMI) of 28 kg/m2 or higher from 23 primary care practices in England. Participants were randomly assigned (2:5:5) to brief advice and self-help materials, a weight-management programme (Weight Watchers) for 12 weeks, or the same weight-management programme for 52 weeks. We followed-up participants over 2 years. The primary outcome was weight at 1 year of follow-up, analysed with mixed-effects models according to intention-to-treat principles and adjusted for centre and baseline weight. In a hierarchical closed-testing procedure, we compared combined behavioural programme arms with brief intervention, then compared the 12-week programme and 52-week programme. We did a within-trial cost-effectiveness analysis using person-level data and modelled outcomes over a 25-year time horizon using microsimulation. This study is registered with Current Controlled Trials, number ISRCTN82857232. FINDINGS: Between Oct 18, 2012, and Feb 10, 2014, we enrolled 1269 participants. 1267 eligible participants were randomly assigned to the brief intervention (n=211), the 12-week programme (n=528), and the 52-week programme (n=528). Two participants in the 12-week programme had been found to be ineligible shortly after randomisation and were excluded from the analysis. 823 (65%) of 1267 participants completed an assessment at 1 year and 856 (68%) participants at 2 years. All eligible participants were included in the analyses. At 1 year, mean weight changes in the groups were -3·26 kg (brief intervention), -4·75 kg (12-week programme), and -6·76 kg (52-week programme). Participants in the behavioural programme lost more weight than those in the brief intervention (adjusted difference -2·71 kg, 95% CI -3·86 to -1·55; p<0·0001). The 52-week programme was more effective than the 12-week programme (-2·14 kg, -3·05 to -1·22; p<0·0001). Differences between groups were still significant at 2 years. No adverse events related to the intervention were reported. Over 2 years, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER; compared with brief intervention) was £159 per kg lost for the 52-week programme and £91 per kg for the 12-week programme. Modelled over 25 years after baseline, the ICER for the 12-week programme was dominant compared with the brief intervention. The ICER for the 52-week programme was cost-effective compared with the brief intervention (£2394 per quality-adjusted life-year [QALY]) and the 12-week programme (£3804 per QALY). INTERPRETATION: For adults with overweight or obesity, referral to this open-group behavioural weight-loss programme for at least 12 weeks is more effective than brief advice and self-help materials. A 52-week programme produces greater weight loss and other clinical benefits than a 12-week programme and, although it costs more, modelling suggests that the 52-week programme is cost-effective in the longer term. FUNDING: National Prevention Research Initiative, Weight Watchers International (as part of an UK Medical Research Council Industrial Collaboration Award).
引用
- Ahern AL, Wheeler GM, Aveyard P, et al. Extended and standard duration weight-loss programme referrals for adults in primary care (WRAP): a randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2017. PMID: 28478041. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30647-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。