Cochrane系统评价中未清晰报告的研究结局纳入标准调查
该研究调查了近期Cochrane系统评价如何定义结局并将其用于研究纳入,并与预防结局报告偏倚的指南进行比较。共纳入52篇系统评价,平均每篇报告8.4个结局(标准差4.3)。47篇(90%)仅以主要和次要结局命名而未进一步定义,40篇(77%)未说明是否将结局用于研究纳入。
要点
- 52篇Cochrane系统评价中,47篇(90%)仅以主要和次要结局命名,未进一步定义。
- 40篇(77%)未说明是否将结局用于研究纳入。
- 8篇(15%)声明若研究报告主要或次要结局则纳入,1篇(2%)报告结局未用于纳入。
核心结论
- 在Cochrane系统评价样本中,大多数评价未说明是否将结局用于研究纳入。
- 需要更好地解释纳入决策,以理解系统评价中结局报告偏倚的风险。
- 需要对系统评价中使用的不同类型结局的名称和定义制定一致的指南。
研究设计与样本
- 对Cochrane系统评价的调查。
- 共纳入52篇系统评价,平均每篇报告8.4个结局(标准差4.3)。
主要发现
- 52篇评价中,47篇(90%)使用主要和次要结局作为评价结局的名称,但未进一步定义。
- 没有评价报告使用核心结局集。
- 40篇评价(77%)未解释是否将结局用于研究纳入。
- 8篇评价(15%)声明若研究报告主要或次要结局则纳入研究。
- 1篇评价(2%)报告结局未用于纳入,3篇(6%)情况不明确。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to survey how outcomes in recent Cochrane reviews were defined and used for inclusion of studies and how this compares with guidance on preventing outcome reporting bias. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A survey of Cochrane reviews. We extracted data on the outcomes and how the outcomes were used for inclusion of studies in the review. RESULTS: We included 52 reviews with a mean of 8.4 (standard deviation, 4.3) outcomes. Of all reviews, 47 (90%) used primary and secondary outcomes as the names for their review's outcomes but without further definition. None reported using a core outcome set. Forty reviews (77%) did not explain if they used outcomes for inclusion of studies, 8 (15%) stated that studies were included if they reported either primary or secondary outcomes, 1 (2%) reported that outcomes were not used for inclusion, and for 3 (6%), this was unclear. CONCLUSION: In a sample of Cochrane reviews, most reviews did not state if outcomes were used for inclusion of studies. Better explanation of inclusion decisions is needed to be able to understand the risk of outcome reporting bias in a review. Consistent guidance in names and definitions for different types of outcomes used in systematic reviews is needed.
引用
- Verbeek J, Ijaz S, Mischke C, et al. Inclusion criteria for outcomes of studies not clearly reported in Cochrane systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28478083. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.04.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。