文献速递医学教育与科研方法临床试验与 GCP

乌干达小学「知情健康选择」干预对儿童评估治疗效应声明可靠性能力的影响:整群随机对照试验

Effects of the Informed Health Choices primary school intervention on the ability of children in Uganda to assess the reliability of claims about treatment effects: a cluster-randomised controlled trial.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet · 2017-05-22

在乌干达中部地区开展整群随机对照试验,120所小学随机分为干预组(60所,76名教师,6383名儿童)和对照组(60所,67名教师,4430名儿童)。干预组使用「知情健康选择」小学资源,教师参加2天工作坊并教授九节80分钟课程,覆盖评估治疗效应声明的12个概念。结果显示干预组多选题平均分62.4%(SD 18.8) vs 对照组43.1%(15.2),校正均差20.0%(95%CI 17.3-22.7;p<0.00001);干预组69%(3967/5753)儿童达到预定及格分(≥13/24正确) vs 对照组27%(1186/4430),校正差异50%(95%CI 44-55)。

要点

  • 干预组儿童评估治疗效应声明可靠性的平均分62.4%,对照组为43.1%,校正均差20.0%(95%CI 17.3-22.7)。
  • 干预组69%(3967/5753)儿童达到及格分(≥13/24正确),对照组27%(1186/4430),校正差异50%(95%CI 44-55)。
  • 干预对不同阅读水平儿童均有效,但对阅读能力较好的儿童效果更大。

核心结论

  • 在教师参加入门工作坊后使用「知情健康选择」小学学习资源,大幅提高了儿童评估治疗效应声明可靠性的能力。
  • 结果表明,在学生与教师比例高、资源少的学校中教会小学生批判性思维是可能的。

研究设计与样本

  • 整群随机对照试验,纳入乌干达中部地区教授五年级儿童(10-12岁)的小学。
  • 排除国际学校、针对听视觉障碍儿童的特殊需求学校、曾参与资源用户测试和试点的学校、婴幼儿和幼儿园、成人教育学校以及因旅行时间难以到达的学校。
  • 从符合条件的学校中随机抽取代表性样本,随机分配至干预组或对照组。
  • 干预学校接受「知情健康选择」小学资源(教科书、练习册和教师指南),教师参加2天入门工作坊,并在一个学期内教授九节80分钟课程,课程涵盖评估治疗效应声明和做出知情健康选择所需的12个概念。
  • 对照学校不进行干预。

主要发现

  • 2016年4月11日至2016年6月8日期间,评估了2960所学校的资格;2029所符合条件,随机抽取170所邀请参加招募会议。
  • 招募会议后,120所符合条件的学校同意并随机分配至干预组(n=60,76名教师,6383名儿童)或对照组(n=60,67名教师,4430名儿童)。
  • 干预学校多选题测试平均分为62.4%(SD 18.8),对照学校为43.1%(15.2),校正均差20.0%(95%CI 17.3-22.7;p<0.00001)。
  • 干预学校中3967/5753名儿童(69%)达到预定及格分数(≥13/24正确),对照学校中1186/4430名儿童(27%)达到,校正差异50%(95%CI 44-55)。
  • 干预对不同阅读技能水平的儿童均有效,但对阅读技能较好的儿童更有效。

关键数值与推荐

  • 主要结局测试包含12个概念,每个概念两道多选题,共24题;预定及格分数为≥13/24正确。
  • 干预学校平均分62.4%(SD 18.8) vs 对照学校43.1%(15.2),校正均差20.0%(95%CI 17.3-22.7;p<0.00001)。
  • 干预学校69%(3967/5753)儿童达到及格分 vs 对照学校27%(1186/4430),校正差异50%(95%CI 44-55)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 未来研究应解决如何扩大资源使用规模、长期效果(包括对实际健康选择的影响)、可转移至其他国家以及如何在此基础上增加中小学学习资源。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Claims about what improves or harms our health are ubiquitous. People need to be able to assess the reliability of these claims. We aimed to evaluate an intervention designed to teach primary school children to assess claims about the effects of treatments (ie, any action intended to maintain or improve health). METHODS: In this cluster-randomised controlled trial, we included primary schools in the central region of Uganda that taught year-5 children (aged 10-12 years). We excluded international schools, special needs schools for children with auditory and visual impairments, schools that had participated in user-testing and piloting of the resources, infant and nursery schools, adult education schools, and schools that were difficult for us to access in terms of travel time. We randomly allocated a representative sample of eligible schools to either an intervention or control group. Intervention schools received the Informed Health Choices primary school resources (textbooks, exercise books, and a teachers' guide). Teachers attended a 2 day introductory workshop and gave nine 80 min lessons during one school term. The lessons addressed 12 concepts essential to assessing claims about treatment effects and making informed health choices. We did not intervene in the control schools. The primary outcome, measured at the end of the school term, was the mean score on a test with two multiple-choice questions for each of the 12 concepts and the proportion of children with passing scores on the same test. This trial is registered with the Pan African Clinical Trial Registry, number PACTR201606001679337. FINDINGS: Between April 11, 2016, and June 8, 2016, 2960 schools were assessed for eligibility; 2029 were eligible, and a random sample of 170 were invited to recruitment meetings. After recruitment meetings, 120 eligible schools consented and were randomly assigned to either the intervention group (n=60, 76 teachers and 6383 children) or control group (n=60, 67 teachers and 4430 children). The mean score in the multiple-choice test for the intervention schools was 62·4% (SD 18·8) compared with 43·1% (15·2) for the control schools (adjusted mean difference 20·0%, 95% CI 17·3-22·7; p<0·00001). In the intervention schools, 3967 (69%) of 5753 children achieved a predetermined passing score (≥13 of 24 correct answers) compared with 1186 (27%) of 4430 children in the control schools (adjusted difference 50%, 95% CI 44-55). The intervention was effective for children with different levels of reading skills, but was more effective for children with better reading skills. INTERPRETATION: The use of the Informed Health Choices primary school learning resources, after an introductory workshop for the teachers, led to a large improvement in the ability of children to assess claims about the effects of treatments. The results show that it is possible to teach primary school children to think critically in schools with large student to teacher ratios and few resources. Future studies should address how to scale up use of the resources, long-term effects, including effects on actual health choices, transferability to other countries, and how to build on this programme with additional primary and secondary school learning resources. FUNDING: Research Council of Norway.

来源:Lancet,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nsangi A, Semakula D, Oxman AD, et al. Effects of the Informed Health Choices primary school intervention on the ability of children in Uganda to assess the reliability of claims about treatment effects: a cluster-randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2017. PMID: 28539194. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)31226-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。