基于理论域框架的临床试验中医护人员行为改变的障碍与促进因素:个体化降温血液透析试验的案例研究
本研究基于理论域框架(TDF),对加拿大安大略省11个血液透析中心的9名医生和9名护士进行访谈,识别其在开具和设置个体化透析温度(IDT)时的障碍与促进因素,归纳出七个主题,以优化MyTEMP试验中IDT的实施。
要点
- 基于TDF访谈9名医生和9名护士,识别出IDT实施的七个障碍与促进因素主题。
- 主题涵盖知识、信念、角色认同、环境资源、工作负荷、患者舒适度和记忆决策等。
- 行为改变框架可系统识别障碍,以优化试验干预实施并提高内部真实性。
核心结论
- 改变医护人员行为以在随机临床试验中有效实施干预存在可预见的障碍,行为改变框架有助于系统识别这些障碍,从而优化干预实施与评估,可能提高干预保真度并增加试验内部真实性。
研究设计与样本
- 采用理论域框架(TDF)制定两份主题指南,从安大略省各地目的性抽样招募血液透析医生和护士进行面对面或电话访谈,采用定向内容分析将转录语句双编码至TDF域,并采用归纳主题分析形成主题。
- 访谈了来自11个安大略省血液透析中心的9名医生和9名护士。
主要发现
- 识别出七个潜在障碍与促进因素主题:对临床指南的认知及IDT与当地政策的契合(知识;目标);使用IDT的获益与动机(后果信念;乐观;强化;意图;目标);IDT与常规实践及角色的一致性(社会/专业角色与身份;行为性质;能力信念);体温计可用性/准确性及透析机特征(环境背景与资源);对工作负荷的影响(后果信念;能力信念);患者舒适度(行为调节;后果信念;情绪);忘记开具或设置IDT(记忆、注意力、决策过程;情绪)。
临床怎么用
- 这些发现将用于优化MyTEMP试验中IDT的实施,并展示该方法如何用于规划其他临床试验的干预实施。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Implementing the treatment arm of a clinical trial often requires changes to healthcare practices. Barriers to such changes may undermine the delivery of the treatment making it more likely that the trial will demonstrate no treatment effect. The 'Major outcomes with personalized dialysate temperature' (MyTEMP) is a cluster-randomised trial to be conducted in 84 haemodialysis centres across Ontario, Canada to investigate whether there is a difference in major outcomes with an individualized dialysis temperature (IDT) of 0.5 °C below a patient's body temperature measured at the beginning of each haemodialysis session, compared to a standard dialysis temperature of 36.5 °C. To inform how to deploy the IDT across many haemodialysis centres, we assessed haemodialysis physicians' and nurses' perceived barriers and enablers to IDT use. METHODS: We developed two topic guides using the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) to assess perceived barriers and enablers to IDT ordering and IDT setting (physician and nurse behaviours, respectively). We recruited a purposive sample of haemodialysis physicians and nurses from across Ontario and conducted in-person or telephone interviews. We used directed content analysis to double-code transcribed utterances into TDF domains, and inductive thematic analysis to develop themes. RESULTS: We interviewed nine physicians and nine nurses from 11 Ontario haemodialysis centres. We identified seven themes of potential barriers and facilitators to implementing IDTs: (1) awareness of clinical guidelines and how IDT fits with local policies (knowledge; goals), (2) benefits and motivation to use IDT (beliefs about consequences; optimism; reinforcement; intention; goals), (3) alignment of IDTs with usual practice and roles (social/professional role and identity; nature of the behaviour; beliefs about capabilities), (4) thermometer availability/accuracy and dialysis machine characteristics (environmental context and resources), (5) impact on workload (beliefs about consequences; beliefs about capabilities), (6) patient comfort (behavioural regulation; beliefs about consequences; emotion), and (7) forgetting to prescribe or set IDT (memory, attention, decision making processes; emotion). CONCLUSIONS: There are anticipatable barriers to changing healthcare professionals' behaviours to effectively deliver an intervention within a randomised clinical trial. A behaviour change framework can help to systematically identify such barriers to inform better delivery and evaluation of the treatment, therefore potentially increasing the fidelity of the intervention to increase the internal validity of the trial. These findings will be used to optimise the delivery of IDT in the MyTEMP trial and demonstrate how this approach can be used to plan intervention delivery in other clinical trials. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02628366 . Registered November 16 2015.
引用
- Presseau J, Mutsaers B, Al-Jaishi AA, et al. Barriers and facilitators to healthcare professional behaviour change in clinical trials using the Theoretical Domains Framework: a case study of a trial of individualized temperature-reduced haemodialysis. Trials. 2017. PMID: 28532509. doi:10.1186/s13063-017-1965-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。