基于两次共识研讨会制定的随机试验中提高保留率策略使用的最佳实践指南
该指南基于两次共识研讨会制定,66名与随机对照试验相关的统计学家、临床医生、协调员、研究科学家、研究助理和数据管理者参加。研讨会评估了激励、沟通、问卷格式、行为、个案管理及方法学保留策略的证据,达成小金额财务激励用于改善邮政问卷应答等最佳实践共识,并识别了实施障碍。
要点
- 共识认为小金额财务激励用于改善随机对照试验邮政问卷应答是最佳实践。
- 使用二等邮政被认为足以用于与随机对照试验参与者的邮政沟通。
- 最相关的已验证问卷被认为是收集随机对照试验数据的最佳实践。
核心结论
- 制定了随机对照试验中保留策略使用的最佳实践指南,并识别了有效策略实施的潜在障碍。
- 当前可用证据的变异性限制了最佳实践共识的程度。
- 该指南将随着新保留策略的开发和评估而需要更新。
研究设计与样本
- 在两家英国临床试验单位举办共识发展研讨会,采用共识发展会议方法。
- 66名与随机对照试验相关的统计学家、临床医生、随机对照试验协调员、研究科学家、研究助理和数据管理者参与。
- 研讨会以Cochrane综述及相关定性研究识别的激励、沟通、问卷格式、行为、个案管理及方法学保留策略证据的展示开始。
- 随后进行三组同时讨论,聚焦参与者对保留策略证据的信任程度、使用有效保留策略的障碍、保留策略可用的随机对照试验随访类型及未来研究策略。
- 各组讨论总结反馈至研讨会,对两次研讨会编码内容进行比较以确定一致与分歧,并确定关于保留最佳实践的共识。
主要发现
- 研讨会参与者就使用小金额财务激励改善随机对照试验邮政问卷应答的最佳实践指南达成一致。
- 认为使用二等邮政足以用于与随机对照试验参与者的邮政沟通。
- 认为最相关的已验证问卷是收集随机对照试验数据的最佳实践。
- 识别出的有效保留策略使用障碍包括:增加货币激励所见的问卷应答改善幅度小,以及试验人员认为某些沟通策略已过时。
- 此外,对改变被认为有效的现有保留实践存在阻力。
关键数值与推荐
- 小金额财务激励用于改善随机对照试验邮政问卷应答被共识为最佳实践。
- 二等邮政被认为足以用于与随机对照试验参与者的邮政沟通。
- 最相关的已验证问卷被认为是收集随机对照试验数据的最佳实践。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 当前可用证据的变异性限制了最佳实践共识的程度。
- 该指南将随着新保留策略的开发和评估而需要更新。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To develop best practice guidance for the use of retention strategies in randomized clinical trials (RCTs). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Consensus development workshops conducted at two UK Clinical Trials Units. Sixty-six statisticians, clinicians, RCT coordinators, research scientists, research assistants, and data managers associated with RCTs participated. The consensus development workshops were based on the consensus development conference method used to develop best practice for treatment of medical conditions. Workshops commenced with a presentation of the evidence for incentives, communication, questionnaire format, behavioral, case management, and methodological retention strategies identified by a Cochrane review and associated qualitative study. Three simultaneous group discussions followed focused on (1) how convinced the workshop participants were by the evidence for retention strategies, (2) barriers to the use of effective retention strategies, (3) types of RCT follow-up that retention strategies could be used for, and (4) strategies for future research. Summaries of each group discussion were fed back to the workshop. Coded content for both workshops was compared for agreement and disagreement. Agreed consensus on best practice guidance for retention was identified. RESULTS: Workshop participants agreed best practice guidance for the use of small financial incentives to improve response to postal questionnaires in RCTs. Use of second-class post was thought to be adequate for postal communication with RCT participants. The most relevant validated questionnaire was considered best practice for collecting RCT data. Barriers identified for the use of effective retention strategies were: the small improvements seen in questionnaire response for the addition of monetary incentives, and perceptions among trialists that some communication strategies are outdated. Furthermore, there was resistance to change existing retention practices thought to be effective. Face-to-face and electronic follow-up technologies were identified as retention strategies for further research. CONCLUSIONS: We developed best practice guidance for the use of retention strategies in RCTs and identified potential barriers to the use of effective strategies. The extent of agreement on best practice is limited by the variability in the currently available evidence. This guidance will need updating as new retention strategies are developed and evaluated.
引用
- Brueton V, Stenning SP, Stevenson F, et al. Best practice guidance for the use of strategies to improve retention in randomized trials developed from two consensus workshops. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28546093. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.05.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。