流行病学研究中贝叶斯分析的报告应更加透明
该系统综述检索了2005至2015年五种主要流行病学期刊的完整卷期,利用专用Java应用进行稿内检索,考察以贝叶斯分析为主要数据分析的原创论文的报告质量。贝叶斯技术用于主要数据分析的研究数量历年保持恒定,部分报告的方法部分和结果部分不完整,尤其缺少先验 elicitation、设定与评价的信息。作者认为现有报告指南未获充分使用,应更新频率学派分析报告指南以涵盖贝叶斯分析的重要问题。
要点
- 2005至2015年五种主要流行病学期刊中,以贝叶斯分析为主要数据分析的研究数量历年保持恒定。
- 许多作者对分析方法和结果做了详尽描述,但部分报告的方法部分和结果部分不完整。
- 先验 elicitation、设定与评价的信息常缺失,现有报告指南未获充分使用。
核心结论
- 尽管现有关于贝叶斯分析报告的用户指南强调透明先验设定的重要性,但该系统综述显示这些指南常未被使用。
- 应进一步努力提升对这些清单存在与重要性的认识,以克服关于贝叶斯技术使用的争议。
- 可通过更新现有频率学派分析报告指南来涵盖对贝叶斯数据分析重要的问题,从而改善流行病学文献的报告质量。
研究设计与样本
- 该系统综述通过PubMed检索2005至2015年五种主要流行病学期刊的完整卷期。
- 此外使用专用Java应用在稿内进行广泛检索。
- 在采用贝叶斯分析作为主要数据分析的原创研究论文中检查贝叶斯统计的报告细节。
主要发现
- 以贝叶斯技术进行主要数据分析的研究数量历年保持恒定。
- 许多作者对所执行分析和所获结果提供了详尽描述,但若干报告的方法部分不完整,甚至部分结果部分也不完整。
- 尤其常缺乏关于先验 elicitation、设定和评价过程的信息。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论未据此给出具体临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this systematic review is to investigate the use of Bayesian data analysis in epidemiology in the past decade and particularly to evaluate the quality of research papers reporting the results of these analyses. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Complete volumes of five major epidemiological journals in the period 2005-2015 were searched via PubMed. In addition, we performed an extensive within-manuscript search using a specialized Java application. Details of reporting on Bayesian statistics were examined in the original research papers with primary Bayesian data analyses. RESULTS: The number of studies in which Bayesian techniques were used for primary data analysis remains constant over the years. Though many authors presented thorough descriptions of the analyses they performed and the results they obtained, several reports presented incomplete method sections and even some incomplete result sections. Especially, information on the process of prior elicitation, specification, and evaluation was often lacking. CONCLUSION: Though available guidance papers concerned with reporting of Bayesian analyses emphasize the importance of transparent prior specification, the results obtained in this systematic review show that these guidance papers are often not used. Additional efforts should be made to increase the awareness of the existence and importance of these checklists to overcome the controversy with respect to the use of Bayesian techniques. The reporting quality in epidemiological literature could be improved by updating existing guidelines on the reporting of frequentist analyses to address issues that are important for Bayesian data analyses.
引用
- Rietbergen C, Debray TPA, Klugkist I, et al. Reporting of Bayesian analysis in epidemiologic research should become more transparent. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28428139. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.04.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。