文献速递流行病学与生物统计

贝叶斯与蒙特卡洛敏感性分析对未测量混杂的比较

A comparison of Bayesian and Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis for unmeasured confounding.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2017-04-06

本文比较了贝叶斯敏感性分析(BSA)与蒙特卡洛敏感性分析(MCSA)在未测量混杂敏感性分析中的表现。通过流行病学数据实例与模拟研究,发现BSA与MCSA可给出非常不同的结果,MCSA可给出不准确的不确定性评估(如95%区间),其95%区间可能过宽或过窄且不具备95%频率学覆盖概率。基于此,作者推荐分析者使用BSA进行概率敏感性分析。

要点

  • BSA与MCSA虽使用相似模型和相同先验分布,但结果可非常不同。
  • MCSA可给出不准确的95%区间,不具备95%频率学覆盖概率。
  • 作者推荐使用BSA进行概率敏感性分析。

核心结论

  • BSA与MCSA可给出非常不同的结果,MCSA可给出不准确的不确定性评估(如95%区间),基于此作者推荐分析者使用BSA进行概率敏感性分析。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学比较研究,使用一个流行病学数据实例与模拟研究比较BSA与MCSA。

主要发现

  • BSA与MCSA可给出非常不同的结果,MCSA可给出不准确的不确定性评估(如95%区间),不能反映数据对未测量混杂不确定性的影响。
  • 某些数据与先验分布的组合可导致关于偏倚参数的不确定性从先验到后验发生剧烈变化,原因是贝叶斯定理在不可识别模型中的应用有时可排除某些与数据不相容的未测量混杂模式。
  • MCSA方法可给出过宽或过窄的95%区间,且不具备95%频率学覆盖概率。

临床怎么用

  • 作者推荐分析者使用BSA进行概率敏感性分析。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Bias from unmeasured confounding is a persistent concern in observational studies, and sensitivity analysis has been proposed as a solution. In the recent years, probabilistic sensitivity analysis using either Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis (MCSA) or Bayesian sensitivity analysis (BSA) has emerged as a practical analytic strategy when there are multiple bias parameters inputs. BSA uses Bayes theorem to formally combine evidence from the prior distribution and the data. In contrast, MCSA samples bias parameters directly from the prior distribution. Intuitively, one would think that BSA and MCSA ought to give similar results. Both methods use similar models and the same (prior) probability distributions for the bias parameters. In this paper, we illustrate the surprising finding that BSA and MCSA can give very different results. Specifically, we demonstrate that MCSA can give inaccurate uncertainty assessments (e.g. 95% intervals) that do not reflect the data's influence on uncertainty about unmeasured confounding. Using a data example from epidemiology and simulation studies, we show that certain combinations of data and prior distributions can result in dramatic prior-to-posterior changes in uncertainty about the bias parameters. This occurs because the application of Bayes theorem in a non-identifiable model can sometimes rule out certain patterns of unmeasured confounding that are not compatible with the data. Consequently, the MCSA approach may give 95% intervals that are either too wide or too narrow and that do not have 95% frequentist coverage probability. Based on our findings, we recommend that analysts use BSA for probabilistic sensitivity analysis. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. McCandless LC, Gustafson P. A comparison of Bayesian and Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis for unmeasured confounding. Stat Med. 2017. PMID: 28386994. doi:10.1002/sim.7298

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。