脊柱手法治疗与急性下背痛临床获益及危害的关联:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析检索2011年1月1日至2017年2月6日的MEDLINE、Cochrane系统综述数据库、EMBASE及Current Nursing and Allied Health Literature,纳入26项随机临床试验及观察性研究,评估脊柱手法治疗对急性(≤6周)下背痛的有效性与危害。15项随机临床试验(1711例患者)提供中等质量证据表明脊柱手法治疗与疼痛改善有统计学显著关联(100毫米视觉模拟疼痛量表合并平均改善-9.95,95%CI -15.6至-4.3);12项随机临床试验(1381例患者)提供中等质量证据表明与功能改善有统计学显著关联(合并平均效应量-0.39,95%CI -0.71至-0.07)。无随机临床试验报告严重不良事件;大型病例系列中50%至67%的患者报告轻微一过性不良事件如疼痛加重、肌肉僵硬和头痛。作者结论认为脊柱手法治疗与至多6周时疼痛和功能的适度改善相关,伴一过性轻微肌肉骨骼危害,但研究结果异质性大。
要点
- 15项随机临床试验(1711例)中等质量证据:脊柱手法治疗与疼痛改善相关(合并平均改善-9.95,95%CI -15.6至-4.3)。
- 12项随机临床试验(1381例)中等质量证据:脊柱手法治疗与功能改善相关(合并平均效应量-0.39,95%CI -0.71至-0.07)。
- 无随机临床试验报告严重不良事件;大型病例系列中50%至67%报告轻微一过性不良事件。
核心结论
- 在急性下背痛患者中,脊柱手法治疗与至多6周时疼痛和功能的适度改善相关,伴一过性轻微肌肉骨骼危害,但研究结果异质性大。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索MEDLINE、Cochrane系统综述数据库、EMBASE及Current Nursing and Allied Health Literature自2011年1月1日至2017年2月6日,纳入26项符合条件的随机临床试验(成人下背痛、门诊环境、脊柱手法治疗对比假治疗或替代治疗、测量至多6周疼痛或功能结局),并纳入观察性研究评估危害。
- 数据提取由双人完成,使用Cochrane Back and Neck(CBN)偏倚风险工具评估研究质量,该工具含11个条目,既往研究显示汇总评分阈值5或6可识别偏倚风险增加的研究;证据使用GRADE标准评估。
主要发现
- 15项随机临床试验(1711例患者)提供中等质量证据表明脊柱手法治疗与疼痛改善有统计学显著关联(100毫米视觉模拟疼痛量表合并平均改善-9.95,95%CI -15.6至-4.3)。
- 12项随机临床试验(1381例患者)提供中等质量证据表明脊柱手法治疗与功能改善有统计学显著关联(合并平均效应量-0.39,95%CI -0.71至-0.07)。
- 异质性未能由实施脊柱手法治疗的临床医生类型、手法类型、研究质量或脊柱手法治疗单独或作为综合治疗一部分来解释。
- 无随机临床试验报告任何严重不良事件;大型病例系列中50%至67%的患者报告轻微一过性不良事件如疼痛加重、肌肉僵硬和头痛。
关键数值与推荐
- 疼痛改善:15项随机临床试验(1711例患者)合并平均改善-9.95(95%CI -15.6至-4.3),中等质量证据。
- 功能改善:12项随机临床试验(1381例患者)合并平均效应量-0.39(95%CI -0.71至-0.07),中等质量证据。
- 不良事件:无随机临床试验报告严重不良事件;大型病例系列中50%至67%报告轻微一过性不良事件。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 研究结果异质性大,且异质性未能由实施脊柱手法治疗的临床医生类型、手法类型、研究质量或脊柱手法治疗单独或作为综合治疗一部分来解释。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Acute low back pain is common and spinal manipulative therapy (SMT) is a treatment option. Randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and meta-analyses have reported different conclusions about the effectiveness of SMT. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review studies of the effectiveness and harms of SMT for acute (≤6 weeks) low back pain. DATA SOURCES: Search of MEDLINE, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, EMBASE, and Current Nursing and Allied Health Literature from January 1, 2011, through February 6, 2017, as well as identified systematic reviews and RCTs, for RCTs of adults with low back pain treated in ambulatory settings with SMT compared with sham or alternative treatments, and that measured pain or function outcomes for up to 6 weeks. Observational studies were included to assess harms. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Data extraction was done in duplicate. Study quality was assessed using the Cochrane Back and Neck (CBN) Risk of Bias tool. This tool has 11 items in the following domains: randomization, concealment, baseline differences, blinding (patient), blinding (care provider [care provider is a specific quality metric used by the CBN Risk of Bias tool]), blinding (outcome), co-interventions, compliance, dropouts, timing, and intention to treat. Prior research has shown the CBN Risk of Bias tool identifies studies at an increased risk of bias using a threshold of 5 or 6 as a summary score. The evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) criteria. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Pain (measured by either the 100-mm visual analog scale, 11-point numeric rating scale, or other numeric pain scale), function (measured by the 24-point Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire or Oswestry Disability Index [range, 0-100]), or any harms measured within 6 weeks. FINDINGS: Of 26 eligible RCTs identified, 15 RCTs (1711 patients) provided moderate-quality evidence that SMT has a statistically significant association with improvements in pain (pooled mean improvement in the 100-mm visual analog pain scale, -9.95 [95% CI, -15.6 to -4.3]). Twelve RCTs (1381 patients) produced moderate-quality evidence that SMT has a statistically significant association with improvements in function (pooled mean effect size, -0.39 [95% CI, -0.71 to -0.07]). Heterogeneity was not explained by type of clinician performing SMT, type of manipulation, study quality, or whether SMT was given alone or as part of a package of therapies. No RCT reported any serious adverse event. Minor transient adverse events such as increased pain, muscle stiffness, and headache were reported 50% to 67% of the time in large case series of patients treated with SMT. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Among patients with acute low back pain, spinal manipulative therapy was associated with modest improvements in pain and function at up to 6 weeks, with transient minor musculoskeletal harms. However, heterogeneity in study results was large.
引用
- Paige NM, Miake-Lye IM, Booth MS, et al. Association of Spinal Manipulative Therapy With Clinical Benefit and Harm for Acute Low Back Pain: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA. 2017. PMID: 28399251. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.3086
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。