减压支撑面:随机评估2(PRESSURE 2)照片验证子研究:一项随机对照试验的研究方案
PRESSURE 2试验评估两种减压床垫预防压力性溃疡的临床与成本效果,主要终点为发生≥2类压力性溃疡的时间,因无法对终点设盲存在偏倚风险。本照片验证子研究旨在通过标准化拍照和中央盲法复核,评估和量化试验终点报告中的潜在偏倚。
要点
- 患者需同意对皮肤部位拍照,首次观察或发生新≥2类压力性溃疡时拍照以评估过度报告。
- 随机抽取10%患者由独立评估者额外拍摄两个皮肤部位(躯干和肢体各一)以评估漏报可能。
- 照片经白平衡校正后中央盲法复核,分析包括漏报和过度报告、患者可接受性、数据安全传输及照片复核质量。
核心结论
- 本验证子研究将利用照片为试验主要结局的判定提供参考,并增进对预防试验中拍照可接受性及照片数据在临床和研究中其他用途可能性的理解。
研究设计与样本
- PRESSURE 2是一项随机评估两种减压床垫预防压力性溃疡的临床与成本效果的研究,主要终点为发生≥2类压力性溃疡的时间。
- 本子研究要求患者同意对皮肤部位拍照,在首次观察或发生新≥2类压力性溃疡时拍照以评估过度报告。
- 随机抽取10%患者由独立评估者额外拍摄两个皮肤部位(躯干和肢体各一,如有压力性溃疡则包含溃疡)以评估漏报可能。
- 工作人员接受标准化相机和拍照技术培训,照片中包含灰阶以校正白平衡,照片安全传输至中央复核。
关键数值与推荐
- PRESSURE 2主要终点为发生≥2类压力性溃疡的时间。
- ≥2类压力性溃疡识别的当前金标准为专家临床评估。
- 随机抽取10%患者进行额外拍照以评估漏报。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: PRESSURE 2 is a randomised evaluation of the clinical and cost effectiveness of two types of pressure relieving mattress for the prevention of pressure ulcers. The primary endpoint is the time to development of a Category ≥2 pressure ulcer. The current 'gold standard' for the identification of a Category ≥2 pressure ulcer is expert clinical assessment. Due to the appearance of the bed, it is not possible to achieve blinding of the endpoint. This therefore poses a risk to the internal validity of the study. A possible approach is to use photographs of skin sites, with central blinded review. However, there are practical and scientific concerns including whether patients would agree to photographs; the burden of data collection; the quality of photographs; the completeness of data; and how the use of photographs compares with the current 'gold standard'. This validation sub-study aims to assess and quantify potential bias in the reporting of the trial endpoint. METHODS/DESIGN: Patients will be specifically asked to consent to photographs being taken of their skin sites. Photographs will be taken at first observation or when patients develop a new Category ≥2 pressure ulcer (to assess over-reporting). A 10% random sample of patients will be identified for additional photographs of two skin sites (one torso and one limb) with and without a pressure ulcer (if present) by an independent assessor (to assess the potential for under-reporting). Staff will be trained to take photographs using a standardised camera and photographic technique. A 'grey scale' will be included in the photo to correct white balance. Photographs will be securely transferred for central review. Photographs will have white balance corrected, and the computer monitor will be calibrated prior to review. Analysis will include assessment of under- and over-reporting, acceptability of photography to patients, secure transfer of data, quality of and confidence in blinded photograph review and sensitivity analysis using photograph assessment of primary outcome. DISCUSSION: This study will use photographs to contribute to the primary outcome of the trial. It will inform our understanding of the acceptability of photography for prevention trials and the possibility of other uses of photographic data in clinical work and research. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN, ISRCTN01151335 . Registered on 14 May 2013.
引用
- McGinnis E, Brown S, Collier H, et al. Pressure RElieving Support SUrfaces: a Randomised Evaluation 2 (PRESSURE 2) photographic validation sub-study: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial. Trials. 2017. PMID: 28320482. doi:10.1186/s13063-017-1851-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。