三维证据网络图系统:一种探索网络Meta分析中协变量失衡与效应的新软件工具
研究开发了基于网页的三维交互式证据网络图系统,用于可视化网络Meta分析中各研究及治疗比较间协变量的分布与失衡。通过两个已知存在潜在重要协变量效应的网络Meta分析实例展示该工具,可直观识别可能违背网络Meta分析常规假设的研究间差异,辅助可行性、有效性评估及结果解读。
要点
- 三维证据网络图系统是首个专门用于三维可视化证据网络中协变量分布与失衡的工具。
- 该工具通过Excel模板输入数据,在AngularJS环境利用Three.js创建三维元素。
- 两个网络Meta分析实例展示了工具可识别研究间协变量差异以供进一步审查。
核心结论
- 三维证据网络图系统是首个专门设计用于三维可视化证据网络中协变量分布与失衡的工具。
- 该工具有助于网络Meta分析的可行性/有效性评估并辅助解读网络Meta分析结果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在AngularJS环境中利用第三方JavaScript库Three.js开发三维证据网络图系统。
- 数据通过专门格式化的Microsoft Excel模板电子表格输入以创建特定主题的三维元素。
- 应用该工具于两个考虑多个协变量的网络Meta分析实例进行展示与讨论。
主要发现
- 三维证据网络图系统提供即时、直观且易用的方式评估证据网络中各治疗比较内及比较间单个研究协变量值的相似性与差异。
- 两个实例此前已被识别具有潜在重要协变量效应,用于记录工具各项功能并说明其用法。
- 研究间差异可被识别以供进一步审查,这些差异可能使网络Meta分析的常规假设失效。
临床怎么用
- 该工具主要面向系统评价与Meta分析研究者,以及更广泛地评估网络Meta分析有效性及稳健性以支持报销决策的人员。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study was to develop the three-dimensional (3D) evidence network plot system-a novel web-based interactive 3D tool to facilitate the visualization and exploration of covariate distributions and imbalances across evidence networks for network meta-analysis (NMA). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We developed the 3D evidence network plot system within an AngularJS environment using a third party JavaScript library (Three.js) to create the 3D element of the application. Data used to enable the creation of the 3D element for a particular topic are inputted via a Microsoft Excel template spreadsheet that has been specifically formatted to hold these data. We display and discuss the findings of applying the tool to two NMA examples considering multiple covariates. These two examples have been previously identified as having potentially important covariate effects and allow us to document the various features of the tool while illustrating how it can be used. RESULTS: The 3D evidence network plot system provides an immediate, intuitive, and accessible way to assess the similarity and differences between the values of covariates for individual studies within and between each treatment contrast in an evidence network. In this way, differences between the studies, which may invalidate the usual assumptions of an NMA, can be identified for further scrutiny. Hence, the tool facilitates NMA feasibility/validity assessments and aids in the interpretation of NMA results. CONCLUSION: The 3D evidence network plot system is the first tool designed specifically to visualize covariate distributions and imbalances across evidence networks in 3D. This will be of primary interest to systematic review and meta-analysis researchers and, more generally, those assessing the validity and robustness of an NMA to inform reimbursement decisions.
引用
- Batson S, Score R, Sutton AJ, et al. Three-dimensional evidence network plot system: covariate imbalances and effects in network meta-analysis explored using a new software tool. J Clin Epidemiol. 2017. PMID: 28344122. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2017.03.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。