在缺乏研究特异方差信息时估计荟萃分析均值差的统计方法学
针对仅报告各治疗组样本均值和样本量、缺少标准误或置信区间的荟萃分析,提出两种估计研究特异方差的方法,并推导用于检验两组方差齐性的似然比检验。通过模拟研究评估总体均值差的偏倚和标准误,并与仅分析完整研究和部分方差信息两种现有方法比较,同时在先天性肺畸形胸腔镜与开放手术比较及肾捐献后肾功能变化两个荟萃分析中示例应用。
要点
- 提出两种仅用样本均值和样本量估计研究特异方差的方法。
- 推导出检验两组方差相等的似然比检验并通过模拟评估I类错误。
- 在先天性肺畸形手术和肾捐献后肾功能两个荟萃分析中示例应用。
核心结论
- 提出两种在仅报告样本均值和样本量时估计研究特异方差的方法,并用于荟萃分析均值差的推断。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,以先天性肺畸形胸腔镜与开放手术比较的荟萃分析为动机,并通过模拟研究评估方法性能。
主要发现
- 通过模拟研究评估两种方法所得总体均值差的偏倚和估计标准误,并与仅分析完整研究和部分方差信息两种现有方法比较。
- 通过模拟研究以I类错误评估所推导似然比检验的性能。
- 在先天性肺畸形胸腔镜与开放手术比较的荟萃分析及肾捐献后肾功能变化的荟萃分析中示例应用所提方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Statistical inference for analyzing the results from several independent studies on the same quantity of interest has been investigated frequently in recent decades. Typically, any meta-analytic inference requires that the quantity of interest is available from each study together with an estimate of its variability. The current work is motivated by a meta-analysis on comparing two treatments (thoracoscopic and open) of congenital lung malformations in young children. Quantities of interest include continuous end-points such as length of operation or number of chest tube days. As studies only report mean values (and no standard errors or confidence intervals), the question arises how meta-analytic inference can be developed. We suggest two methods to estimate study-specific variances in such a meta-analysis, where only sample means and sample sizes are available in the treatment arms. A general likelihood ratio test is derived for testing equality of variances in two groups. By means of simulation studies, the bias and estimated standard error of the overall mean difference from both methodologies are evaluated and compared with two existing approaches: complete study analysis only and partial variance information. The performance of the test is evaluated in terms of type I error. Additionally, we illustrate these methods in the meta-analysis on comparing thoracoscopic and open surgery for congenital lung malformations and in a meta-analysis on the change in renal function after kidney donation. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
引用
- Sangnawakij P, Böhning D, Adams S, et al. Statistical methodology for estimating the mean difference in a meta-analysis without study-specific variance information. Stat Med. 2017. PMID: 28168731. doi:10.1002/sim.7232
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。