纵向潜在暴露模型的估计量:检验测量模型假设
纵向潜在暴露模型在环境流行病学中用于汇总多次测量的多变量暴露。研究以产前铅暴露与智力发育研究为动机,检验测量模型假设被违背时最大似然估计量的偏倚,并将工具变量估计量适配于纵向暴露情形,提出其作为替代方法;模拟显示工具变量估计量在广泛数据生成模型下保持无偏且均方误差有优势。
要点
- 测量模型假设(如条件独立、时间不变性)对铅暴露健康效应推断有实质影响。
- 工具变量估计量在纵向暴露情形下对多种数据生成模型保持无偏并改善均方误差。
- 对重复多变量暴露施加纵向潜在变量结构可提高暴露-疾病关联的估计效率。
核心结论
- 工具变量估计量在广泛的数据生成模型下保持无偏,并在均方误差方面具有优势,可作为估计时变潜在预测因子健康效应的替代方法。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,以产前铅暴露与智力发育研究为动机,考察测量模型假设违背时最大似然估计量的偏倚,并将现有工具变量估计量适配于纵向暴露情形。
主要发现
- 在产前铅暴露与智力发育研究中,时变纵向暴露的测量模型假设对铅暴露健康效应的最大似然推断有 appreciable 影响。
- 对重复多变量暴露测量施加纵向潜在变量结构可带来暴露-疾病关联的高效率增益。
- 工具变量估计量在广泛的数据生成模型下保持无偏,并在均方误差方面具有优势。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Latent variable (LV) models are increasingly being used in environmental epidemiology as a way to summarize multiple environmental exposures and thus minimize statistical concerns that arise in multiple regression. LV models may be especially useful when multivariate exposures are collected repeatedly over time. LV models can accommodate a variety of assumptions but, at the same time, present the user with many choices for model specification particularly in the case of exposure data collected repeatedly over time. For instance, the user could assume conditional independence of observed exposure biomarkers given the latent exposure and, in the case of longitudinal latent exposure variables, time invariance of the measurement model. Choosing which assumptions to relax is not always straightforward. We were motivated by a study of prenatal lead exposure and mental development, where assumptions of the measurement model for the time-changing longitudinal exposure have appreciable impact on (maximum-likelihood) inferences about the health effects of lead exposure. Although we were not particularly interested in characterizing the change of the LV itself, imposing a longitudinal LV structure on the repeated multivariate exposure measures could result in high efficiency gains for the exposure-disease association. We examine the biases of maximum likelihood estimators when assumptions about the measurement model for the longitudinal latent exposure variable are violated. We adapt existing instrumental variable estimators to the case of longitudinal exposures and propose them as an alternative to estimate the health effects of a time-changing latent predictor. We show that instrumental variable estimators remain unbiased for a wide range of data generating models and have advantages in terms of mean squared error. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
引用
- Sánchez BN, Kim S, Sammel MD, et al. Estimators for longitudinal latent exposure models: examining measurement model assumptions. Stat Med. 2017. PMID: 28239905. doi:10.1002/sim.7268
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。