重症监护室患者中视频喉镜与直接喉镜对首次经口气管插管成功率的影响:一项随机临床试验
在法国7个重症监护室(ICU)纳入371例需插管的成人患者,随机分为视频喉镜组(n=186)与直接喉镜组(n=185)。两组首次插管成功率无显著差异(67.7% vs 70.3%;绝对差-2.5%[95%CI,-11.9%至6.9%];P=0.60),视频喉镜组严重危及生命的并发症发生率更高(事后分析:9.5% vs 2.8%;绝对差6.7%[95%CI,1.8%至11.6%];P=0.01)。
要点
- ICU需插管患者中,视频喉镜与直接喉镜首次插管成功率无显著差异(67.7% vs 70.3%;P=0.60)。
- 事后分析显示视频喉镜组严重危及生命的并发症发生率高于直接喉镜组(9.5% vs 2.8%;P=0.01)。
- 两组插管成功中位时间均为3分钟(范围2至4分钟;P=0.95)。
核心结论
- 在ICU需插管患者中,与直接喉镜相比,视频喉镜未提高首次经口气管插管成功率,且与更高的严重危及生命的并发症发生率相关。
- 需进一步研究评估这两种策略在不同临床环境和不同技能水平操作者中的比较效果。
研究设计与样本
- 随机临床试验,2015年5月至2016年1月在法国7个ICU纳入371例需插管的成人患者,随访28天。
- 视频喉镜组186例,直接喉镜组185例;全部患者接受全身麻醉。
主要发现
- 视频喉镜组与直接喉镜组首次插管成功率分别为67.7%与70.3%(绝对差-2.5%[95%CI,-11.9%至6.9%];P=0.60),无显著差异。
- 由非专家(主要为住院医师,n=290)实施的首次尝试插管比例在视频喉镜组为84.4%,直接喉镜组为83.2%(绝对差1.2%[95%CI,-6.3%至8.6%];P=0.76)。
- 两组插管成功中位时间均为3分钟(范围2至4分钟;绝对差0[95%CI,0至0];P=0.95)。
- 视频喉镜组危及生命的并发症为24/180(13.3%),直接喉镜组为17/179(9.5%)(绝对差3.8%[95%CI,-2.7%至10.4%];P=0.25)。
- 事后分析:视频喉镜组严重危及生命的并发症为17/179(9.5%),直接喉镜组为5/179(2.8%)(绝对差6.7%[95%CI,1.8%至11.6%];P=0.01);轻度至中度危及生命的并发症分别为10/181(5.4%)与14/181(7.7%)(绝对差-2.3%[95%CI,-7.4%至2.8%];P=0.37)。
局限性
- 严重危及生命的并发症结果来自事后分析。
- 需进一步研究评估这两种策略在不同临床环境和不同技能水平操作者中的比较效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: In the intensive care unit (ICU), orotracheal intubation can be associated with increased risk of complications because the patient may be acutely unstable, requiring prompt intervention, often by a practitioner with nonexpert skills. Video laryngoscopy may decrease this risk by improving glottis visualization. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether video laryngoscopy increases the frequency of successful first-pass orotracheal intubation compared with direct laryngoscopy in ICU patients. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Randomized clinical trial of 371 adults requiring intubation while being treated at 7 ICUs in France between May 2015 and January 2016; there was 28 days of follow-up. INTERVENTIONS: Intubation using a video laryngoscope (n = 186) or direct laryngoscopy (n = 185). All patients received general anesthesia. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome was the proportion of patients with successful first-pass intubation. The secondary outcomes included time to successful intubation and mild to moderate and severe life-threatening complications. RESULTS: Among 371 randomized patients (mean [SD] age, 62.8 [15.8] years; 136 [36.7%] women), 371 completed the trial. The proportion of patients with successful first-pass intubation did not differ significantly between the video laryngoscopy and direct laryngoscopy groups (67.7% vs 70.3%; absolute difference, -2.5% [95% CI, -11.9% to 6.9%]; P = .60). The proportion of first-attempt intubations performed by nonexperts (primarily residents, n = 290) did not differ between the groups (84.4% with video laryngoscopy vs 83.2% with direct laryngoscopy; absolute difference 1.2% [95% CI, -6.3% to 8.6%]; P = .76). The median time to successful intubation was 3 minutes (range, 2 to 4 minutes) for both video laryngoscopy and direct laryngoscopy (absolute difference, 0 [95% CI, 0 to 0]; P = .95). Video laryngoscopy was not associated with life-threatening complications (24/180 [13.3%] vs 17/179 [9.5%] for direct laryngoscopy; absolute difference, 3.8% [95% CI, -2.7% to 10.4%]; P = .25). In post hoc analysis, video laryngoscopy was associated with severe life-threatening complications (17/179 [9.5%] vs 5/179 [2.8%] for direct laryngoscopy; absolute difference, 6.7% [95% CI, 1.8% to 11.6%]; P = .01) but not with mild to moderate life-threatening complications (10/181 [5.4%] vs 14/181 [7.7%]; absolute difference, -2.3% [95% CI, -7.4% to 2.8%]; P = .37). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Among patients in the ICU requiring intubation, video laryngoscopy compared with direct laryngoscopy did not improve first-pass orotracheal intubation rates and was associated with higher rates of severe life-threatening complications. Further studies are needed to assess the comparative effectiveness of these 2 strategies in different clinical settings and among operators with diverse skill levels. TRIAL REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT02413723.
引用
- Lascarrou JB, Boisrame-Helms J, Bailly A, et al. Video Laryngoscopy vs Direct Laryngoscopy on Successful First-Pass Orotracheal Intubation Among ICU Patients: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2017. PMID: 28118659. doi:10.1001/jama.2016.20603
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。