低强度脉冲超声治疗胫骨骨折再评估(TRUST):随机临床试验
TRUST 试验在 43 个北美学术创伤中心纳入 501 例髓内钉固定胫骨骨折患者,随机分为每日低强度脉冲超声(LIPUS)组(n=250)与假治疗组(n=251)。结果显示两组 SF-36 生理 Component 摘要评分无差异(均值差 0.55,95%CI -0.75~1.84;P=0.41),影像学愈合时间也无差异(HR 1.07,95%CI 0.86~1.34;P=0.55)。作者认为术后 LIPUS 不加速影像学愈合,也未改善功能恢复。
要点
- LIPUS 组与假治疗组 SF-36 生理 Component 摘要评分无差异(均值差 0.55,95%CI -0.75~1.84;P=0.41)。
- LIPUS 组与假治疗组影像学愈合时间无差异(HR 1.07,95%CI 0.86~1.34;P=0.55)。
- 术后 LIPUS 不加速影像学愈合,也未改善功能恢复。
核心结论
- 胫骨骨折固定术后使用 LIPUS 不加速影像学愈合,也未改善功能恢复。
研究设计与样本
- 采用隐蔽、随机、盲法、假治疗对照的平行组临床试验,纳入 501 例患者,2008 年 10 月至 2012 年 9 月入组,随访一年。
- 研究在 43 个北美学术创伤中心开展,对象为适合髓内钉固定的开放或闭合胫骨骨折的骨骼成熟男女。
- 共评估 3105 例连续接受胫骨骨折髓内钉固定的患者,599 例符合条件,501 例签署知情同意并入组。
- 排除髁部骨折、需复位的延伸至关节的胫骨干骨折、病理性骨折、双侧胫骨骨折、节段性骨折、长度 >7.5 cm 的螺旋形骨折、可能影响功能至少与胫骨骨折等长时间的合并伤,以及术后固定后皮质接触 <25% 且间隙 >1 cm 的胫骨骨折。
- 患者经中央随机分配至每日自我实施 LIPUS(n=250)或使用假装置(n=251),直至胫骨骨折显示影像学愈合或髓内固定后一年。
主要发现
- SF-36 生理 Component 摘要评分数据来自 481/501(96%)例患者,获得 2303/2886(80%)次观察;影像学愈合数据来自 482/501(96%)例患者,其中 82 例删失。
- LIPUS 组与对照组 SF-36 生理 Component 摘要评分无影响(均值差 0.55,95%CI -0.75~1.84;P=0.41),时间与治疗交互作用也无影响(P=0.30);最小重要差异为 3-5 分。
- 其他功能指标也无差异。
- 影像学愈合时间无差异(HR 1.07,95%CI 0.86~1.34;P=0.55)。
- 治疗组间安全性结局无差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether low intensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS), compared with sham treatment, accelerates functional recovery and radiographic healing in patients with operatively managed tibial fractures. DESIGN: A concealed, randomized, blinded, sham controlled clinical trial with a parallel group design of 501 patients, enrolled between October 2008 and September 2012, and followed for one year. SETTING: 43 North American academic trauma centers. PARTICIPANTS: Skeletally mature men or women with an open or closed tibial fracture amenable to intramedullary nail fixation. Exclusions comprised pilon fractures, tibial shaft fractures that extended into the joint and required reduction, pathological fractures, bilateral tibial fractures, segmental fractures, spiral fractures >7.5 cm in length, concomitant injuries that were likely to impair function for at least as long as the patient's tibial fracture, and tibial fractures that showed <25% cortical contact and >1 cm gap after surgical fixation. 3105 consecutive patients who underwent intramedullary nailing for tibial fracture were assessed, 599 were eligible and 501 provided informed consent and were enrolled. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were allocated centrally to self administer daily LIPUS (n=250) or use a sham device (n=251) until their tibial fracture showed radiographic healing or until one year after intramedullary fixation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary registry specified outcome was time to radiographic healing within one year of fixation; secondary outcome was rate of non-union. Additional protocol specified outcomes included short form-36 (SF-36) physical component summary (PCS) scores, return to work, return to household activities, return to ≥80% of function before injury, return to leisure activities, time to full weight bearing, scores on the health utilities index (mark 3), and adverse events related to the device. RESULTS: SF-36 PCS data were acquired from 481/501 (96%) patients, for whom we had 2303/2886 (80%) observations, and radiographic healing data were acquired from 482/501 (96%) patients, of whom 82 were censored. Results showed no impact on SF-36 PCS scores between LIPUS and control groups (mean difference 0.55, 95% confidence interval -0.75 to 1.84; P=0.41) or for the interaction between time and treatment (P=0.30); minimal important difference is 3-5 points) or in other functional measures. There was also no difference in time to radiographic healing (hazard ratio 1.07, 95% confidence interval 0.86 to 1.34; P=0.55). There were no differences in safety outcomes between treatment groups. Patient compliance was moderate; 73% of patients administered ≥50% of all recommended treatments. CONCLUSIONS: Postoperative use of LIPUS after tibial fracture fixation does not accelerate radiographic healing and fails to improve functional recovery.Study registration ClinicalTrialGov Identifier: NCT00667849.
引用
- Busse JW, Bhandari M, Einhorn TA, et al. Re-evaluation of low intensity pulsed ultrasound in treatment of tibial fractures (TRUST): randomized clinical trial. BMJ. 2016. PMID: 27797787. doi:10.1136/bmj.i5351
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。