累积Meta流行病学与试验序贯分析检测可能不必要且浪费的临床试验研究
该研究从当前Cochrane系统评价中抽样13项比较,采用累积Meta分析和试验序贯分析判断证据何时足以得出可靠结论。8/13项比较中检测到可能不必要的研究,涉及12%至89%的受试者;其中3项高比例(69%至89%)在敏感性分析中基本不变。作者认为需更仔细评估额外试验的相关性理由,并制定防止不必要研究的政策。
要点
- 8/13项比较中检测到可能不必要研究,涉及12%至89%的受试者。
- 3项高比例(69%至89%)可能不必要研究在敏感性分析中基本不变。
- 作者认为需更仔细评估额外试验的相关性理由并制定防止不必要研究的政策。
核心结论
- 未来需更仔细评估额外临床试验声称相关性的合理性。
- 累积信息量基础分析可纳入系统评价。
- 需制定防止开展不必要研究的科研政策。
研究设计与样本
- 从当前Cochrane协作网主要医学领域(如心血管疾病、癌症、精神病学)的系统评价中抽样13项不同比较。
- 对每项比较进行累积Meta分析,并应用试验序贯分析确定证据累积过程中何时足以得出可靠结论。
- 此后发表的试验被视为可能不必要;进行敏感性分析以确定发现是否可由规划新试验时对已发表发现的延迟认知解释。
主要发现
- 8/13项比较中检测到可能不必要的研究,涉及可能不需要的试验中12%至89%的受试者。
- 其中3项高比例(69%至89%)可能不必要研究,在仅将足够证据已发表3年或5年后发表的试验视为可能浪费的敏感性分析中,该发现基本不变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective was to estimate the presence and extent to which potentially unnecessary and therefore maybe wasteful clinical trials regarding relevant interventions and outcomes in major clinical areas had been conducted. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: From current Cochrane collaboration systematic reviews in major medical fields (e.g., cardiovascular disease, cancer, psychiatry), 13 different comparisons were sampled. A cumulative meta-analysis was conducted for each and trial sequential analysis applied to determine when in the course of evidence accrual evidence was found sufficient to reach a reliable conclusion. Trials published afterward were considered potentially unnecessary. Sensitivity analysis is performed, for example, to determine if findings could be explained by a delayed perception of published findings when planning new trials. RESULTS: In 8/13 cases, potentially unnecessary research was detected to an extent of between 12% and 89% of all participants in trials that might not have been needed. In three of these cases with high proportions (69-89%) of potentially unnecessary research, this finding was found basically unchanged in sensitivity analysis, when only trials published 3 or 5 years after sufficient evidence had already been published were considered potentially wasteful. CONCLUSIONS: The reasonableness of claims to relevance of additional trials needs to be much more carefully evaluated in the future. Cumulative, information size bases analysis might be included in systematic reviews. Research policies to prevent unnecessary research from being done need to be developed.
引用
- Storz-Pfennig P. Potentially unnecessary and wasteful clinical trial research detected in cumulative meta-epidemiological and trial sequential analysis. J Clin Epidemiol. 2016. PMID: 27865900. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2016.11.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。