文献速递医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

活体证据合成实践:方法学合规性与报告标准评估

SERIES: living evidence syntheses in practice: methodology, standards, dissemination, and publication challenges. Paper 2: evaluating methodological compliance and reporting standards.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-10-06

该研究对明确采用活体证据方法的证据合成进行方法学文献调查,前瞻监测2年以捕获更新。基线报告对通用系统评价条目合规性可接受(>70%),但活体特异性报告有限:52%报告监测计划,<30%报告多数关键要素,仅5%明确终止标准。PRISMA-LSR合规章从基线57.5%降至后续更新40.7%和42.3%。

要点

  • 活体证据合成中活体特异性报告要素普遍不足,仅5%明确终止标准。
  • 更新报告中先前更新和监测变化报告率低,版本控制信息缺失。
  • PRISMA-LSR合规性在后续更新中下降,提示报告质量随更新递减。

核心结论

  • 尽管活体证据方法日益普及,活体特异性标准的实施和报告仍存在显著差距。
  • 更新触发、监测策略、终止标准和版本控制常报告不足,PRISMA-LSR合规性随更新下降。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学文献调查,纳入明确声明使用活体证据方法的任何类型证据合成。
  • 所有合格活体证据合成前瞻监测2年以捕获全部更新;使用Bendersky清单评估合规性,事后用PRISMA-LSR扩展评估子样本。

主要发现

  • 119份基线报告和最多3份后续更新或监测报告(93份)评估Bendersky清单合规性。
  • 基线报告通用系统评价条目合规性>70%,但52%报告监测计划,<30%报告多数关键要素,仅5%明确终止标准。
  • 73份更新中<50%报告先前更新,35.6%报告监测变化,全部报告筛查或选择频率变化。
  • 20份监测报告中20.0%报告先前更新,无报告监测变化。
  • 20项活体证据合成用PRISMA-LSR评估,基线合规57.5%,中间更新40.7%,最终更新42.3%。

关键数值与推荐

  • Bendersky清单合规性:基线报告通用系统评价条目>70%,活体特异性报告有限。
  • PRISMA-LSR合规性:基线57.5%,中间更新40.7%,最终更新42.3%。

临床怎么用

  • 临床决策中使用活体证据合成时,需注意其活体特异性报告可能不完整,应谨慎评估更新状态和终止标准。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: This is the second paper in a 3-part series assessing how living evidence synthesis (LES) products (systematic reviews, rapid reviews, network meta-analyses, overviews of reviews, and scoping reviews) are defined, implemented, reported, and updated over time. Here, we evaluate compliance to methodological and reporting standards and the consistency of application of key living review principles across updates. METHODS: We conducted a methodological literature-based survey of any type of evidence syntheses that explicitly stated the use of a living evidence approach. All eligible LES were prospectively monitored by 2 years to capture all updates to achieve our assessment objectives. Adherence to conduction and reporting standards was assessed using the Bendersky's checklist, which compiles previously described living review requirements. In a post hoc analysis, we used a subsample of LES to assess compliance with the reporting elements included in the PRISMA 2024 extension for Living Systematic Reviews (PRISMA-LSR) extension. RESULTS: Compliance with the Bendersky checklist was assessed in 119 baseline reports and up to 3 subsequent updates or surveillance reports per LES (93 reports). Baseline report compliance with general systematic review items was acceptable (>70%), but living-specific reporting was limited: 52% reported a monitoring plan but <30% reported most key elements, and only 5% specified discontinuation criteria. Among 73 updates, <50% reported previous updates and 35.6% reported changes in monitoring; all reported changes in screening or selection frequency. Among 20 surveillance reports, 20.0% reported previous updates and none reported changes in monitoring. In 20 LES assessed using new PRISMA-LSR extension, compliance was 57.5% at baseline, declining to 40.7% and 42.3% in intermediate and final updates, respectively. CONCLUSION: Despite growing adoption of the living evidence approach, substantial gaps remain in implementing and reporting living-specific standards. Update triggers, surveillance strategies, discontinuation criteria, and version control were frequently underreported, with PRISMA-LSR compliance declining over successive updates. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: A systematic review is a structured method of research that identifies, evaluates, and summarizes all relevant studies addressing a specific question. Its goal is to synthesize evidence transparently and rigorously to produce a clear overall conclusion. Living systematic reviews (LSRs) are a type of systematic review designed to be continuously updated as new evidence emerges. This approach is used to generate a broader set of products, known as living evidence synthesis (LES), intended to support timely clinical and policy decisions based on the most up-to-date evidence. However, the "living" label does not always ensure that a review follows the methodological principles required for continuous updating and currency. This study assessed a large sample of published LES to determine their adherence to methodological standards, including systematic searching for new evidence, predefined update procedures, and transparent documentation of changes over time, as described in the literature and operationalized in the Bendersky checklist. We also evaluated compliance with PRISMA-LSR, which defines reporting standards for living reviews. The results show that many reviews do not fully meet these standards. Fewer than one-third clearly reported update frequency or stopping criteria. Many updates lacked clear version identification or justification for discontinuation of living status, and communication of update dissemination strategies was often absent or unclear. This lack of transparency and planning limits the usability and trustworthiness of living reviews. The findings highlight the need for more consistent methods and standardized reporting practices, including clearer update procedures and communication strategies. In summary, although LES have strong potential, many do not fully meet the requirements of truly "living" evidence. Improving methodological rigor and reporting will enhance their reliability and usefulness for health decision-making.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Auladell-Rispau A, Gempeler A, Gutiérrez-Gómez E, et al. SERIES: living evidence syntheses in practice: methodology, standards, dissemination, and publication challenges. Paper 2: evaluating methodological compliance and reporting standards. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42838152. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112546

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。