摘要中的spin对医学生结果解读的影响:一项随机研究
该多中心双臂随机试验纳入两所法国医学院五年级医学生476名,随机分配阅读含或不含spin的RCT与观察性研究摘要,评估感知治疗获益与感知研究严谨性(0-10分)。spin与更高的感知治疗获益相关(β=1.8;95%CI 1.4-2.1;P<.001),且在RCT摘要中效应更强(额外β=2.7;95%CI 2.1-3.4;P<.001),但spin与感知研究严谨性无关(β=0.01;95%CI -0.29-0.30;P=.97)。
要点
- 摘要中的spin会提高医学生对治疗获益的感知,尤其在RCT摘要中。
- spin不影响医学生对研究严谨性的感知。
- 仅靠结构化批判性评价培训可能无法完全消除spin的影响。
核心结论
- 摘要中的spin影响医学生对治疗获益的感知,尤其对RCT,尽管学生接受过批判性评价培训。
- 感知的方法学严谨性未受影响。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、双臂随机试验,于2023-2024学年在法国两所医学院的五年级医学生中进行。
- 学生被个体随机分配阅读含或不含spin的摘要,摘要来自一项RCT和一项观察性研究。
- 结局为感知治疗获益和感知研究严谨性,均采用0-10分量表测量。
主要发现
- 476名学生提供了1161次感知治疗获益评价和1160次感知严谨性评价。
- spin与更高的感知治疗获益相关(β=1.8;95%CI 1.4-2.1;P<.001)。
- spin与研究类型存在显著交互作用,RCT摘要中效应更强(额外β=2.7;95%CI 2.1-3.4;P<.001)。
- spin与感知研究严谨性无关(β=0.01;95%CI -0.29-0.30;P=.97)。
- 敏感性分析结果一致。
临床怎么用
- 在批判性评价培训中应加入识别spin的教学策略,以帮助医学生准确解读研究结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Spin in research abstracts may influence readers' interpretation of study findings. We aimed to assess the impact of spin on medical students' interpretation of treatment benefit and study rigor and to examine whether this effect differed according to study design. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We conducted a multicenter, two-arm randomized trial among fifth year medical students from two French medical schools during the 2023-2024 academic year. Students were individually randomized to receive abstracts with or without spin from one randomized controlled trial (RCT) and one observational study. The outcomes assessed were perceived treatment benefit and perceived study rigor, both measured on a 0-10 scale. Analyses used multivariable linear mixed-effects models with a random intercept for student, including spin, study type, center, and their interaction. Generalized estimating equations were used for sensitivity analyses. RESULTS: A total of 476 students provided 1161 evaluations of perceived treatment benefit and 1160 evaluations of perceived rigor. Spin was associated with higher perceived treatment benefit (β = 1.8; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.4-2.1; P < .001). A significant interaction between spin and study type indicated a stronger effect in RCT abstracts (additional β = 2.7; 95% CI: 2.1-3.4; P < .001). Spin was not associated with perceived study rigor (β = 0.01; 95% CI: -0.29 to 0.30; P = .97). Results were consistent in sensitivity analyses. CONCLUSION: Spin in abstracts influenced medical students' perception of treatment benefit, particularly for RCTs, despite formal training in critical appraisal. Perceived methodological rigor was unaffected. These findings suggest that structured training alone may not fully mitigate the interpretative impact of spin and support the development of targeted educational strategies. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: When researchers describe their results in a way that makes a treatment look better than the data show, this is called "spin". We wanted to know if spin changes how future doctors interpret study results. During a mock national exam, 476 fifth year medical students in two French medical schools were randomly given either the original abstract of a study, which contained spin, or a rewritten version without spin. Students who read the version with spin believed that the treatment was more beneficial for patients, especially when the study was a randomized trial. However, spin did not change how rigorous they judged the study to be. Teaching students to recognize spin should therefore be added to training in critical appraisal.
引用
- Fournier J, Khouri C, Bellier A, et al. Influence of spin in abstracts on medical students' interpretation of the results: a randomized study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42790714. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112536
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。