文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

活证综合实践:方法学、标准、传播与发表挑战——第一篇:引言——活证综合真的“活”吗?

Living evidence syntheses in practice: methodology, standards, dissemination, and publication challenges. Paper 1: introduction-are living evidence syntheses truly "living"?
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-09-25

该研究对活证综合(LES)进行了方法学调查,追踪2022年3月至2025年1月间119项LES的更新情况。结果显示仅41.2%的LES在随访期间产生至少一次更新,多数针对干预问题,但维持更新和报告仍面临挑战。

要点

  • 仅41.2%的活证综合在2年随访期内产生更新。
  • 多数活证综合针对干预问题(64.7%)。
  • 仅26.9%的活证综合引用了支持其活证方法的参考文献。

核心结论

  • 活证方法应用日益增多,尤其针对干预问题,但维持和一致报告仍具挑战,需更强的方法学和报告标准。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于文献的方法学调查,通过Epistemonikos数据库、灰色文献和组织库全面检索,前瞻性追踪2022年3月至2025年1月。

主要发现

  • 最终纳入119项基线综合报告、160份更新报告和41份证据监测报告。
  • 49项LES(41.2%)在随访期间产生至少1份更新或证据监测报告。
  • 更新报告数中位数为1(四分位距1-4),证据监测报告数中位数为3(四分位距2-8),仅3项LES(2.5%)同时产生两者。
  • 基线综合中干预问题占64.7%,预后和流行病学各占12.6%,诊断占9.2%。
  • 86.6%的LES被标记为活系统评价或活Meta分析,但仅32项(26.9%)引用了支持活证方法的参考文献。

临床怎么用

  • 临床决策者应关注LES的更新状态,优先使用有明确更新记录和活证方法学支持的证据综合。

局限性

  • 仅追踪2年,可能低估长期更新行为;数据依赖报告和数据库收录,可能存在遗漏。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: The Living Evidence Synthesis in Practice series is based on a comprehensive literature-based survey that examines how living evidence syntheses (LESs) have been defined, implemented, reported, and updated over time. This introductory paper aims to introduce key concepts of living evidence and describe the characteristics of baseline syntheses and subsequent updates, focusing on question types, methodological features, and update trends. METHODS: We conducted a methodological survey of LES, defined as evidence synthesis products (eg, systematic reviews, meta-analyses, network meta-analyses, rapid reviews, and overviews of reviews) that explicitly adopted a living evidence approach. An LES was defined as comprising a baseline synthesis report (BSR) and subsequent update reports (UDRs) and/or evidence surveillance reports (ESRs). Eligible LES were identified through comprehensive searches of the Epistemonikos database, gray literature, and organizational repositories. Identified LES were prospectively tracked from March 2022 to January 2025. Data were extracted independently in duplicate using a standardized form and analyzed descriptively to characterize baseline features, update patterns, and methodological practices over time. RESULTS: Searches conducted up to March 2022 identified 1730 records, with 28 additional records located through manual searches. After screening and linking related references, 119 LES were included. All LES were monitored for 2 years to identify further updates. By January 2025, 123 additional reports had been identified, yielding a final dataset of 119 BSRs, 160 UDRs, and 41 ESRs. Overall, 49 LES (41.2%) produced at least 1 UDR or ESR during follow-up. The median number of updates per LES was 1 for UDRs (inter quartil range 1-4) and 3 for ESRs (inter quartile range 2-8); only three LESs (2.5%) produced both. Most baseline syntheses addressed intervention questions (64.7%), followed by prognosis (12.6%), epidemiology (12.6%), and diagnosis (9.2%). Most were labeled as living systematic reviews or living meta-analyses (86.6%), but only 32 (26.9%) cited references supporting the living approach. CONCLUSION: The living evidence approach is increasingly used, particularly for intervention questions. However, maintaining and consistently reporting these reviews remains challenging, as fewer than half were updated over 2 years. Stronger methodological and reporting standards are needed to ensure LES remain current, credible, and useful for decision-making. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: LESs are secondary research studies designed to stay continuously up to date as new information becomes available. This type of review became especially popular during the COVID-19 pandemic, when health recommendations needed to change quickly based on new research. To better understand how LES are developed and maintained in the real world, we carried out a methodological study that tracked these reviews over a 2-year period. We started by identifying all available LES published up to March 2022 using Epistemonikos database, as well as additional manual searches and author contacts. After we found the eligible LES, we carefully followed each one to see if, how, and when they were updated. In total, we included 119 baseline reviews and 201 related updates, forming a sample of 320 references. Most of these were standard systematic reviews, and nearly three-quarters were published in peer-reviewed journals. However, we found that less than half of the reviews were actually updated after they were first published. Many reviews that were meant to be "living" eventually stopped updating, sometimes without explanation. Our findings show that while the idea of living evidence is promising, putting it into practice is not always easy. There are clear benefits to keeping reviews current, but researchers need better tools, clearer guidelines, and more consistent publishing practices to help them maintain truly "living" reviews. This would ensure that health professionals and policymakers always have access to the most up-to-date and reliable information.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Auladell-Rispau A, Gempeler A, Bendersky J, et al. Living evidence syntheses in practice: methodology, standards, dissemination, and publication challenges. Paper 1: introduction-are living evidence syntheses truly "living"? J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42790716. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112531

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。