文献速递医学教育与科研方法

范围综述作为系统综述前驱的类型学与实用指南:基于八个实例

Using scoping reviews as precursors to systematic reviews: a typology and practical guidance derived from eight worked examples.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-09-06

该研究通过方法学分析八个配对范围综述与系统综述的实例,识别出四种结构配置和七项范围综述功能,并提出决策框架与报告建议,以帮助团队明确范围综述作为前驱的具体目的。

要点

  • 范围综述可作为系统综述的前驱,有四种结构配置和七项功能。
  • 七项功能包括可行性评估、问题优先化、概念澄清等。
  • 作者提出决策框架和报告建议以指导团队规划。

核心结论

  • 范围综述可为系统综述提供重要的基础性工作。
  • 基于实例提出决策框架和报告建议,帮助团队明确范围综述作为前驱的具体目的。

研究设计与样本

  • 对八篇当代证据合成论文和方案进行方法学分析,每篇均配对一项范围综述与一项系统综述。
  • 实例涵盖兽医学、动物福利、公共卫生、心理健康、职业健康以及患者与公众参与等领域。

主要发现

  • 识别出四种结构配置:整合式序贯设计、先行独立发表的范围综述、单一母范围综述衍生多个靶向系统综述、与系统综述并行的补充性范围综述。
  • 范围综述交付七项反复出现的功能:可行性与体量评估、可处理问题的优先化、概念与定义澄清、纳入与评估工具决策、检索架构与可复用记录集、缺口识别、概念或逻辑框架以结构化合成。

临床怎么用

  • 团队规划链接或序贯合成时,可参考决策框架明确范围综述的具体目的。
  • 遵循报告建议以提高范围综述作为前驱的透明度和实用性。

局限性

  • 实例通过作者对证据合成文献的知识 purposively 选取,可能未全面覆盖所有领域。
  • 分析基于八个实例,结论的普适性需进一步验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Scoping reviews are often conducted as a precursor to a systematic review (SR), yet guidance on how this relationship should be planned, executed, and reported is limited. We aimed to illustrate, through worked examples, the ways in which scoping reviews can function as precursors to SRs and to derive practical guidance for teams planning linked or sequential syntheses. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We undertook a methodological analysis of eight contemporary evidence synthesis papers and protocols spanning veterinary medicine, animal welfare, public health, mental health, occupational health, and patient and public involvement, identified through the authors' knowledge of the evidence synthesis literature. Each paired a scoping review with an SR. For every example, we charted the structural relationship between the two reviews and the specific functions performed by the scoping stage. RESULTS: Across the eight purposively selected examples, four structural configurations were identified: (i) integrated sequential designs reported within a single project or paper; (ii) an antecedent, separately published scoping review whose search and records are inherited and extended by a later SR; (iii) a single "parent" scoping review that seeds several targeted SRs; and (iv) a complementary scoping review run alongside an SR to contextualize sparse evidence. Across configurations, scoping reviews delivered seven recurring functions: feasibility and volume assessment; prioritization of a tractable question; concept and definition clarification; eligibility and appraisal tool decisions; search architecture and a reusable record set; gap identification; and conceptual or logic frameworks to structure synthesis. CONCLUSION: Scoping reviews can provide important foundational work for SRs. Drawing on these illustrative examples, we propose a decision framework and reporting recommendations to help teams refine the specific purpose of a scoping review used as a precursor.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Khalil H, Munn Z, Godfrey C, et al. Using scoping reviews as precursors to systematic reviews: a typology and practical guidance derived from eight worked examples. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42702311. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112499

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。