中年期预后因素预测后续衰弱:一项系统文献综述
未发现高质量证据的预后因素,8个因素获中等质量证据,包括年龄较大、单身、吸烟、抑郁、未满足的医疗需求、地区剥夺、较低职业水平和较低财富。
要点
- 中年期吸烟、抑郁和未满足的医疗需求是可改变因素,可考虑作为未来预测模型的候选预测因子。
- 未发现高质量证据的衰弱预后因素,多数研究(28/35)至少一个QUIPS领域为高偏倚风险。
- 唯一预测模型显示肌肉骨骼因素占预测风险的显著比例,但该模型评为高偏倚风险。
核心结论
- 需要稳健研究以更好理解晚年衰弱高风险人群,为预防干预提供潜在靶点。
- 识别出8个中等质量证据的预后因素;吸烟、抑郁和未满足的医疗需求为可改变因素,应考虑纳入未来预测模型。
- 公众参与顾问组强调需研究本综述未涵盖的其他预后因素作为未来研究优先事项。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Medline、Embase、PsycINFO、CINAHL、Web of Science、LILACS和HTA数据库,截至2025年1月。
- 纳入中年期(人群平均年龄40-64岁)无衰弱人群、随访≥5年、评估衰弱发生预后因素的研究。
- 使用QUIPS工具和预测模型偏倚风险评估工具评估偏倚风险,采用 adapted GRADE框架进行定性证据合成。
- 公众成员通过患者与公众参与(PPI)顾问组参与本综述。
主要发现
- 共识别52个预后因素,涵盖人口学、生活方式、总体健康、社会网络或支持、心理、工作相关和环境六大类。
- 28项研究在至少一个QUIPS领域评为高偏倚风险。
- 未发现高质量证据的衰弱发生预后因素。
- 中等质量证据支持年龄较大、单身、吸烟、抑郁、感知未满足的医疗需求、地区剥夺、较低职业水平和较低财富与衰弱发生相关。
- 唯一预测模型显示肌肉骨骼因素占预测衰弱风险的显著比例,但该模型评为高偏倚风险;PPI贡献者建议18个额外因素供未来研究。
关键数值与推荐
- 中年期定义为人群平均年龄40-64岁。
- 纳入研究要求随访≥5年。
- 52个预后因素分为六大类;28项研究至少一个QUIPS领域高偏倚风险。
- 8个因素获中等质量证据:年龄较大、单身、吸烟、抑郁、未满足的医疗需求、地区剥夺、较低职业水平、较低财富。
临床怎么用
- 吸烟、抑郁和未满足的医疗需求为可改变因素,可考虑作为未来衰弱预测模型的候选预测因子。
- 目前证据质量有限,尚不能推荐用于临床常规预测衰弱发生。
- 需更多高质量研究以识别高风险个体并早期支持预防衰弱。
局限性
- 未发现高质量证据的预后因素,多数研究存在高偏倚风险。
- 仅纳入1项预测模型研究且评为高偏倚风险。
- 本综述未涵盖PPI贡献者提出的18个额外因素,需未来研究探索。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This systematic review aimed to identify, describe, and critically appraise the evidence for prognostic factors and models in midlife (defined as a mean population age of 40-64 years) associated with frailty onset in later life. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Medline, Embase, PsycINFO, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Web of Science, Latin American and Caribbean Health Science Information, and the Health Technology Assessment databases were searched for eligible studies involving midlife populations without frailty that assessed prognostic factors for incident frailty with ≥5 years of follow-up (up to January 2025). Studies reporting the development or validation of a prediction model to be used in midlife for predicting frailty were also included. Risk of bias was assessed using the Quality In Prognosis Studies (QUIPS) tool and Prediction model Risk of Bias Assessment Tool. A qualitative synthesis of the evidence was conducted, using an adapted version of the grading of recommendations, assessment, development, and evaluation framework. Members from the public contributed to this review through a patient and public involvement (PPI) advisory group. RESULTS: Thirty-five prognostic factor studies (including >2.3 million individuals) and one prediction model (n = 287) were included. Fifty-two prognostic factors were identified across six categories: demographic, lifestyle, general health, social networks or support, psychological, work-related, and environmental. Twenty-eight studies were rated at high risk of bias in at least one QUIPS domain. No prognostic factors for frailty onset with high-quality evidence were identified. Moderate-quality evidence was found for older age, being single, smoking, depression, perceived unmet health-care needs, area deprivation, lower occupational level, and lower wealth. The sole prediction model showed that musculoskeletal factors accounted for a significant proportion of the predicted risk of frailty, but it was rated at high risk of bias. Eighteen additional factors were suggested by PPI contributors for future investigation. CONCLUSION: Robust studies are needed to improve our understanding of those at higher risk of developing frailty later in life to inform potential targets for preventive interventions. We identified eight prognostic factors with moderate-quality evidence. Smoking, depression, and unmet health-care needs are modifiable and should be considered as candidate predictors for inclusion in future prediction models. Members of the PPI advisory group emphasized the importance of investigating additional prognostic factors not captured in this review as priorities for future research. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: As our population gets older, more people will become frail. People who are frail are at greater risk of adverse health events. Understanding what contributes to frailty can help identify people at higher risk early in life. We wanted to find out whether characteristics in midlife (defined as a mean population age of 40-64 years) could predict frailty later in life. We also looked for tools used in midlife to predict who might become frail. We searched for studies that examined factors linked to frailty and tools used to detect people at higher risk. We included studies that followed community-dwelling midlife populations for at least 5 years. We explored which characteristics predicted frailty and investigated how well prediction tools worked. We critically evaluated study quality, summarized the findings, and judged the strength of the evidence for each factor. We found 35 studies that looked at factors linked to frailty and one study that developed a prediction tool. Across these studies, 52 potential factors were identified. Most studies (80%) were rated as poor quality. We found moderate-quality evidence that older age, being divorced or widowed, smoking, depression, unmet health-care needs, living in more deprived neighborhoods, lower occupational level, and lower wealth were associated with developing frailty later in life. Members of the public contributed to this review and identified 18 additional factors, beyond this review. More high-quality research is needed to better understand who is most likely to develop frailty so people at high risk can be identified earlier and supported to help prevent frailty. Some of the strongest factors we identified, including smoking, depression, and unmet health-care needs, can potentially be changed or treated and may help identify people at higher risk of frailty. Public contributors also highlighted important factors not covered by the existing research that should be explored in future studies.
引用
- Sanchez-Santos MT, Bezer JH, Shrestha R, et al. Prognostic factors in midlife for predicting subsequent frailty: a systematic literature review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42744032. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112506
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。