何时开展新系统评价或继续更新现有动态系统评价:理由与考量
动态系统评价(LSR)持续纳入新证据更新,但何时应启动新评价而非继续更新缺乏指导。本文提出判断框架,涵盖范围、纳入标准、研究问题变化、概念框架重构、方法学大修、原评价根本性疑虑及实际发表考量,并讨论混合模式。
要点
- LSR持续更新中若范围、纳入标准或研究问题发生实质变化,应考虑启动新评价。
- 概念框架重构、方法学大修或原评价存在根本性缺陷时,继续更新可能不恰当。
- 实际与发表考量也影响决策,有时可采取持续更新与 complementary 新评价并行的混合模式。
核心结论
- 当累积变化涉及范围、纳入标准、研究问题、概念框架或方法学重大调整时,启动新系统评价比继续更新现有LSR更合适。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学指导文章,基于动态系统评价更新实践提出决策理由与考量框架,未报告系统检索或样本量。
主要发现
- 需考虑的变化包括范围、纳入标准或研究问题改变,概念框架重构,方法学大修,原评价根本性疑虑,以及实际、后勤或发表考量。
- 在某些情况下,可采取持续更新现有评价与开发补充性新评价并行的混合方法。
临床怎么用
- 研究者决定是否触发LSR全面更新时,应系统评估范围、纳入标准、研究问题、概念框架和方法学是否发生实质变化。
- 当累积变化达到需启动新评价的程度时,应明确区分继续更新、重启或分支新评价,以维护动态证据合成的完整性、透明性和可用性。
局限性
- 原文指出关于累积变化何时足以 warrant 新评价而非继续更新的指导有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Living systematic reviews (LSRs) aim to synthesize all available evidence meeting prespecified eligibility criteria to answer a research question and to continually update the review by incorporating new evidence as it becomes available. Once the initial version of an LSR is published, researchers determine whether a full update should be triggered. Over periodic iterations, modifications may be needed. Emerging evidence, external factors, methodological developments, and other considerations may necessitate adjustments to the original eligibility criteria, scope, or methods. However, guidance is limited on when cumulative changes warrant a new review rather than a continued update. In this article, we provide rationale and guidance for deciding when updating an existing LSR is appropriate and when initiating a new, separate review is more appropriate. Several considerations should be considered, including changes in scope, eligibility criteria, or research question, reformulation of the conceptual framework, major methodological overhauls, foundational concerns with the original review, and practical, logistical, or publication considerations. In some circumstances, a hybrid approach involving continual updating of an existing review alongside development of a complementary new review may also be appropriate. Clear guidance on when to continue, restart, or branch into a new review will support the integrity, transparency, and usability of living evidence synthesis.
引用
- Glick M, Verdugo-Paiva F, Booth HA, et al. When to conduct a new systematic review or continue updating an existing living systematic review: rationale and considerations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42722172. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112504
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。