指南与共识流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

ESIC系列论文4:证据合成中的数据共享与复用——ESIC工作组2的建议

ESIC series, Paper 4: Data sharing and reuse in evidence synthesis: Recommendations from the Evidence Synthesis Infrastructure Collaborative (ESIC) Working Group 2.
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-09-21

该评论性文章由证据合成基础设施协作组(ESIC)工作组2(WG2)采用映射双钻框架的规划流程,通过咨询、访谈、成熟度评估、研讨会与调查等步骤,识别出五项高优先级解决方案以加强证据合成数据的共享与复用。这些方案旨在减少重复工作、提高可发现性、促进公平复用,并辅以可持续资金与激励对齐的跨领域策略。

要点

  • 证据合成数据流程碎片化,导致数据提取、质量评估与确定性评价频繁重复。
  • WG2提出五项高优先级解决方案:连接的数据存储库系统、可互操作数据标准、元数据标准、开放获取标准、可扩展质量保证机制。
  • 跨领域策略包括可持续资金与激励对齐,以确保长期可行性。

核心结论

  • WG2提供了一个结构化框架,将数据共享与复用转变为可复用的全球公共产品,通过促进互操作性、包容性和可持续性来减少重复、加强公平,并确保全球决策者受益于及时、可信和相关的证据。

研究设计与样本

  • WG2遵循ESIC规划流程并映射至双钻框架,阶段1通过咨询、访谈和文档审查映射现有能力;阶段2评估16项核心能力的成熟度并识别关键差距;阶段3通过研讨会、调查和反馈生成潜在策略;阶段4通过影响-努力-可行性分析优先排序解决方案,并辅以策略捆绑、联盟咨询和指示性成本核算。

主要发现

  • WG2识别出五项高优先级解决方案,旨在基于现有存储库、标准、平台和质量保证实践(在已有成功模式之处)构建:连接的数据存储库系统、可互操作的数据标准、用于可发现性的元数据标准、用于公平复用的开放获取标准、可扩展的质量保证机制。
  • 这些解决方案旨在减少重复、提高可发现性并加强透明度,同时辅以关于可持续资金和激励对齐的跨领域策略以确保长期可行性。

关键数值与推荐

  • 评估了16项核心能力的成熟度。
  • 通过影响-努力-可行性分析优先排序出五项高优先级解决方案。

临床怎么用

  • 采用连接的数据存储库系统、可互操作数据标准、元数据标准、开放获取标准和可扩展质量保证机制,以减少重复的数据提取和质量评估工作。
  • 利用元数据标准提高证据合成数据的可发现性,促进跨情境复用。
  • 实施开放获取标准以促进公平复用,特别是来自非英语和低收入与中等收入国家情境的证据。
  • 建立可扩展的质量保证机制以加强透明度。
  • 通过可持续资金和激励对齐策略确保数据共享与复用实践的长期可行性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Evidence synthesis data processes remain fragmented, with frequent duplication of data extraction, study-quality assessment, and certainty appraisal. These inefficiencies occur within a broader evidence ecosystem shaped by inequities in access, publication practices, language, infrastructure, technology, and representation, which can affect the visibility and reuse of evidence from non-English and low- and middle-income country contexts. The objective of this commentary was to identify practical solutions for strengthening data sharing and reuse so that evidence produced for one synthesis can be reused across multiple contexts. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Working Group 2 (WG2) followed the ESIC planning process mapped to the Double Diamond framework. Stage 1 mapped existing capabilities through consultations, interviews, and document review. Stage 2 assessed maturity across 16 core capabilities and identified critical gaps. Stage 3 generated potential strategies through workshops, surveys, and feedback from the Global SDG Synthesis Coalition and other ESIC working groups. Stage 4 prioritized solutions via impact-effort-feasibility analysis, supplemented with strategy bundling, coalition consultation, and indicative costing. RESULTS: WG2 identified five high-priority solutions, designed to build on existing repositories, standards, platforms, and quality assurance practices where successful models already exist: a connected system of synthesis data repositories, interoperable data standards, metadata standards for discoverability, open access standards for equitable reuse, and scalable quality assurance mechanisms. These solutions aim to reduce duplication, improve discoverability, and strengthen transparency, with a cross-cutting strategy on sustainable funding and incentive alignment to ensure long-term viability. CONCLUSION: WG2 provides a structured framework for transforming data sharing and reuse into a reusable global public good. By fostering interoperability, inclusivity, and sustainability, these solutions will reduce duplication, strengthen equity, and ensure that decision makers worldwide benefit from timely, trustworthy, and relevant evidence. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Evidence reviews often repeat work that has already been done, such as extracting data from the same studies or assessing study quality again. This wastes time and resources and can make it harder to include evidence from non-English and lower-resource settings. This paper identifies five practical ways to make evidence synthesis data easier to find, share, check, and reuse: connected data repositories, common data standards, better metadata for discoverability, open access standards, and quality assurance processes. These changes could make evidence synthesis faster, fairer, and more reliable for decision makers.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pandalaneni KK. ESIC series, Paper 4: Data sharing and reuse in evidence synthesis: Recommendations from the Evidence Synthesis Infrastructure Collaborative (ESIC) Working Group 2. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42767577. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112526

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。