文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

GRADE框架中阈值使用情况:系统综述的系统调查

Use of thresholds for rating certainty of evidence with the GRADE framework: a systematic survey of systematic reviews.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-08-11

本研究系统抽样了2018年至2024年发表的200篇Cochrane和200篇非Cochrane系统综述,调查其使用GRADE框架时是否及如何设定阈值。结果显示59%的Cochrane综述和31.5%的非Cochrane综述使用了阈值;在使用可识别阈值类型的综述中,约半数选择无效值,约半数选择最小重要差异(MID),极少同时使用多个阈值形成效应范围。

要点

  • Cochrane系统综述中59%使用GRADE阈值,非Cochrane仅31.5%。
  • 使用阈值的综述中,无效值与MID的选择比例相近(约各占一半)。
  • 同时使用MID、中效应和大效应阈值形成范围者极少(Cochrane 1.8%,非Cochrane 5.5%)。

核心结论

  • 系统综述中GRADE阈值的应用仍不理想,非Cochrane综述尤为明显。
  • 使用阈值的综述对无效值和MID的选择频率相当,且极少使用多个阈值。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统调查,抽样200篇最新发表的Cochrane系统综述和200篇非Cochrane系统综述,均使用GRADE。
  • Cochrane综述来自Cochrane系统综述数据库(2018年至2024年7月),非Cochrane综述来自MEDLINE(2018年至2024年12月)。
  • 记录综述作者是否使用阈值及所选择的阈值类型。

主要发现

  • 200篇Cochrane综述中118篇(59%)使用阈值,200篇非Cochrane综述中63篇(31.5%)使用阈值。
  • 在可识别阈值类型的综述中,Cochrane有55/112篇(49.1%)使用无效值,非Cochrane有26/55篇(47.3%)使用无效值。
  • Cochrane有54/112篇(48.2%)使用MID,非Cochrane有24/55篇(43.6%)使用MID。
  • 同时使用MID、中效应和大效应阈值形成效应范围的综述极少:Cochrane 2/112篇(1.8%),非Cochrane 3/55篇(5.5%)。

临床怎么用

  • 系统综述作者在应用GRADE评级时应明确设定并报告阈值,尤其是非Cochrane综述。
  • 选择阈值时应考虑无效值和MID的适用场景,必要时可组合多个阈值形成效应范围。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Current guidance regarding applying the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) framework mandates establishing thresholds to assess certainty of evidence. These thresholds include the null, the minimally important difference (MID), and moderate and large effect thresholds. GRADE experts offer a rationale for use of each particular threshold. However, GRADE methodologists continue to debate the optimal choice of threshold, particularly whether to use the null threshold. We aimed to describe how systematic review authors used thresholds and in doing so to provide insight into the perceived utility of the available thresholds and to inform ongoing debate regarding the optimal choice of threshold. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We conducted a systematic survey sampling the 200 most recently published Cochrane and 200 non-Cochrane systematic reviews that used GRADE, which we identified from the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2018-July 2024) and MEDLINE (2018-December 2024). We documented whether review authors used thresholds and the thresholds they chose. RESULTS: Among the sampled reviews, 118 of 200 (59%) Cochrane and 63 of 200 (31.5%) non-Cochrane reviews used thresholds. Among the reviews with an identifiable threshold type, 55 of 112 (49.1%) Cochrane and 26 of 55 (47.3%) non-Cochrane reviews used the null, whereas 54 of 112 (48.2%) Cochrane and 24 of 55 (43.6%) non-Cochrane reviews used the MID. Few reviews used the MID, moderate, and large effect thresholds together to form ranges of effects (two of 112 [1.8%] Cochrane; three of 55 [5.5%] non-Cochrane). CONCLUSION: Use of thresholds in systematic reviews using the GRADE framework remains suboptimal, particularly in non-Cochrane reviews. For systematic reviews that do use thresholds, reviewers choose the null and the MID equally and very seldom use multiple thresholds, suggesting the perceived utility of the available options. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Systematic reviews of interventions provide evidence to support health decisions by summarizing findings from available studies. Review authors assess their confidence in the evidence using a system called GRADE (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation). A key part of GRADE is setting thresholds that guide certainty ratings. A common threshold is the null, which addresses the question of whether or not there is any effect at all. Another is the minimally important difference (MID), which considers whether the effect is important to patients. We analyzed 400 systematic reviews to examine how their authors used these thresholds. Over half of the reviews did not use thresholds. Among those that did, approximately equal numbers used the null threshold and the MID. Our findings establish that review authors who use thresholds choose the null and the MID equally often when rating GRADE certainty.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Movahed H, Mirza RD, Brignardello-Petersen R, et al. Use of thresholds for rating certainty of evidence with the GRADE framework: a systematic survey of systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42580369. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112459

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。