文献速递流行病学与生物统计基础与转化研究

三角互证评估生命历程孟德尔随机化研究中的选择偏倚:以早期肥胖与乳腺癌为例的实用框架

Triangulating evidence to evaluate selection bias in lifecourse Mendelian randomization studies: a practical framework illustrated by early-life adiposity and breast cancer.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-08-24

该研究通过三角互证实证分析与模拟,评估选择偏倚能否解释早期肥胖对乳腺癌风险的保护性孟德尔随机化(MR)估计。亲属代理基因型MR、父母生存多变量MR及广泛模拟均显示,合理选择机制不足以复现观察到的保护效应,支持因果解释。

要点

  • 亲属代理基因型MR估计减弱可在无选择偏倚下由模拟复现,不提示选择偏倚。
  • 父母生存多变量MR提示生存差异主要由中晚年而非早期肥胖驱动。
  • 模拟中即使极端选择场景,偏倚幅度不足以复现观察到的保护效应。

核心结论

  • 合理选择机制不太可能实质解释早期肥胖对乳腺癌风险观察到的保护性效应估计。
  • 结果支持早期肥胖对乳腺癌风险强保护效应的因果解释。
  • 三角互证互补方法对评估生命历程MR偏倚有价值。

研究设计与样本

  • 三角互证实证分析与模拟,评估选择诱导偏倚可否解释早期肥胖对乳腺癌的逆效应估计。
  • 第一,亲属乳腺癌代理基因型MR估计及家庭模拟,评估相对估计衰减是否需选择偏倚。
  • 第二,父母生存多变量MR分析,评估生存相关选择机制。
  • 第三,广泛模拟量化合理与极端场景下选择偏倚幅度,包括交互驱动选择。

主要发现

  • 亲属代理基因型MR估计弱于个体自身乳腺癌MR估计,家庭模拟无选择偏倚亦可复现。
  • 父母生存多变量MR显示生存差异主要由中晚年而非早期肥胖驱动。
  • 模拟中加性选择偏倚极小,交互驱动选择扭曲增大但极端场景仍不足以复现保护效应。
  • 选择依赖中晚年而非早期肥胖时,偏倚主要体现于中晚年MR估计,早期MR估计扭曲小。
  • 所有模拟场景下,选择 alone 不能复现实证单变量与多变量MR联合模式。

临床怎么用

  • 解读生命历程MR保护效应时,应系统评估选择偏倚而非默认无效。
  • 可借鉴三角互证框架:代理基因型MR、多变量MR与模拟结合评估偏倚。
  • 亲属代理估计减弱不必然提示选择偏倚,需结合模拟判断。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Higher adiposity in early-life has consistently been associated with a reduced risk of breast cancer in later life, with Mendelian randomization (MR) studies supporting a causal effect. However, concerns have been raised that selection bias, particularly collider stratification due to selective participation or survival, may induce spurious protective MR estimates. METHODS: We triangulated across empirical analyses and simulations to evaluate whether selection-induced bias could plausibly explain the inverse effect estimate of early-life adiposity on breast cancer risk. First, we examined proxy-genotype MR estimates of breast cancer in relatives, in which participant genotype is used as a proxy for relatives' genotype, and conducted family-based simulations to assess whether attenuation in relative-based estimates could arise without selection bias. Second, we performed multivariable MR analyses of parental survival to evaluate survival-related selection mechanisms. Third, we conducted extensive simulations to quantify the magnitude of bias introduced by selection under a range of plausible and extreme scenarios, including interaction-driven selection. RESULTS: The weaker proxy-genotype MR estimates of breast cancer in relatives, compared with MR estimates for an individual's own breast cancer, were reproduced in family-based simulations without selection bias, indicating that this pattern does not provide evidence for selection bias. Multivariable MR analyses of parental survival indicated that survival differences are primarily driven by mid-to-late adulthood, not early-life, adiposity, providing little support for survival-related selection acting through early-life adiposity. In simulation analyses, additive selection produced minimal bias, while interaction-driven selection generated increasing distortion; however, even under extreme scenarios, the magnitude of bias was insufficient to replicate the observed protective effect estimate. In simulations where selection depended on mid-to-late adulthood rather than early-life adiposity, bias was expressed primarily in mid-to-late adulthood MR estimates, with little distortion of early-life MR estimates. Across all simulated scenarios, the combined pattern of empirical univariable and multivariable MR findings was not reproduced by selection alone. CONCLUSION: Although selection bias can influence MR estimates, our findings suggest that plausible selection mechanisms are unlikely to substantively explain the observed inverse effect estimate of early-life adiposity on breast cancer risk. These results support a causal interpretation of the strong protective effect estimate of early-life adiposity on breast cancer risk and highlight the value of triangulating evidence across complementary approaches when evaluating bias in lifecourse MR. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Previous studies have found that having a larger body size in early life is linked to a lower risk of developing breast cancer later in life. MR studies, which use genetic variation to investigate possible causal effects, have supported this finding. However, it has been suggested that the result could be explained by selection bias arising from who survives or participates in the studies analyzed. We used several complementary approaches to evaluate this possibility. Together, the findings provide little evidence that the selection mechanisms examined explain the protective effect estimate of early-life adiposity on breast cancer. This work also provides a practical framework for investigating selection bias in lifecourse MR studies.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Power GM, Sanderson E, Gkatzionis A, et al. Triangulating evidence to evaluate selection bias in lifecourse Mendelian randomization studies: a practical framework illustrated by early-life adiposity and breast cancer. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42636914. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112478

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。