公平分层变量定义方法的系统综述:验证研究的现状与挑战
该系统综述检索了5个数据库至2024年,纳入116项验证研究,评估PROGRESS-Plus框架下公平分层变量在行政健康数据、登记系统或电子健康记录中的定义与验证方法。多数研究集中于种族/族裔定义,各性能指标差异较大,提示需进一步严格验证。
要点
- 公平分层变量的定义与验证方法高度异质,性能指标差异大。
- 种族/族裔类别验证研究最多,敏感性、PPV和Kappa变异最大。
- 职业验证研究的敏感性和PPV变异最小,宗教变量无研究涉及。
核心结论
- 公平分层变量的验证研究增多,但性能指标差异广泛,定义和方法异质性大,需进一步严格验证。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Medline、EMBASE、CINAHL、Web of Science和Google Scholar至2024年,纳入116项使用行政健康数据、登记系统或EHR的成人公平分层变量验证研究。
主要发现
- 共筛选9099条独特引文,188篇全文评估,最终纳入116项研究。
- 64项(55%)发表于2019–2024年,66项(57%)为种族/族裔定义验证,使用编码或姓氏列表算法。
- 无研究涉及宗教变量。
- 种族/族裔/文化/语言类别的敏感性、PPV和Cohen's Kappa变异最大。
- 职业验证研究的敏感性和PPV变异最小。
临床怎么用
- 使用行政或临床健康数据定义公平分层变量时,需注意验证性能差异大,结果可能不可靠或不可比。
局限性
- 研究设计、变量定义和性能指标异质性大,无法进行Meta分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Disease burden is often disproportionally higher among those who are socially disadvantaged by factors defined in the PROGRESS-Plus framework (ie, Place of residence, Race/ethnicity/culture/language, Occupation, Gender/sex, Religion, Education, Socioeconomic status, and Social capital, with "Plus" covering features like age and disability). The accuracy and applicability of case definitions to identify these variables from administrative and clinical health data are unknown. We conducted a systematic review to explore how equity-stratifying variables, as categorized by the PROGRESS-Plus framework, have been defined and validated in epidemiologic studies using administrative health, population-level, or electronic health record (EHR) data. METHODS: Medline, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, and Google Scholar were searched from the inception of the databases to 2024 for validation studies of equity-stratifying variables in adults using administrative health datasets, health registries, or EHR data. Titles and abstracts, followed by relevant full-text articles, were screened in duplicate by two reviewers for eligibility. The data sources utilized, algorithms employed, and their associated performance measures were extracted and synthesized from included studies. Given substantial heterogeneity in study design, equity-stratifying variable definition, and performance metrics, meta-analysis was not possible. RESULTS: Of the 9099 unique citations screened, 188 full texts were reviewed and 116 were included in this review. Most studies were published between 2019 and 2024 (n = 64, 55%) and were validation studies of race/ethnicity definitions that used race/ethnicity codes or surname list algorithms (n = 66, 57%). No studies examined religion. Regarding the reported performance measure estimates, the race/ethnicity/culture/language equity-stratifying variables category had the largest variability across sensitivity, positive predictive value (PPV), and Cohen's Kappa. Occupation validation studies had the lowest variation in sensitivity and PPV. CONCLUSION: Despite an increasing number of publications reporting on the validation of equity-stratifying variables relevant to the PROGRESS-Plus framework, performance measures varied widely across studies. The significant heterogeneity in equity-stratifying variable definitions and methods used to validate them support the need for further rigorous validation of equity-stratifying variables in administrative and clinical health data. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Disease burden is often higher in people who experience financial hardships, lower level of education, discrimination due to race/ethnicity, and unstable housing. These social factors can be considered health equity factors and are important for understanding health inequalities. Health researchers often use large datasets, such as hospital or electronic health records (EHRs), to study these health equity factors. However, it is not clear how accurately these data sources capture information about people's social circumstances and how these factors are defined. In this study, we reviewed existing research to understand how health equity factors have been defined across health data sources and how accurate they are at measuring aspects of health equity and social disadvantage. Of the more than 9000 studies we identified, we included 116 that met our criteria for this systematic review. Most included studies focused on identifying race and ethnicity, often using codes or surname-based methods. We found that the accuracy of these methods varied widely across studies, meaning results may not always be reliable or comparable. Overall, our findings show that there are inconsistencies in how social factors are defined and measured in health data. This makes it difficult to fully understand and address health inequalities using routinely collected health data. More work is needed to develop and validate better quality and more consistent methods for capturing these important social factors.
引用
- Osman H, Hecker T, Hossain Z, et al. Methods for defining equity-stratifying variables: a systematic review of validation studies. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42456901. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112420
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。