二分类结局临床预测模型变量选择方法系统综述
该系统综述纳入2024年10月1日至21日PubMed发表的141项采用逻辑回归开发二分类健康结局预测模型的研究,提取变量选择方法信息。结果显示140/141项研究使用数据驱动变量选择,单变量筛选最常用(78%),LASSO仅25%,且报告细节普遍不足。
要点
- 几乎所有预测模型研究均使用数据驱动变量选择,与指南建议相悖。
- 单变量筛选(78%)和后退法(43%)等受批评方法仍广泛使用。
- LASSO等惩罚方法使用较少(25%),报告细节常不完整。
核心结论
- 尽管临床预测建模通常不鼓励数据驱动变量选择,但综述中几乎所有研究(140/141)至少使用一种此类方法,许多研究使用两种。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述聚焦2024年10月1日至21日PubMed发表、使用逻辑回归开发二分类健康结局预测模型的研究,共纳入141项。
主要发现
- 140/141项研究使用数据驱动变量选择,单变量筛选用于78%(110/141)的研究。
- 后退法用于60/141(43%)的研究,从单一多变量模型中批量移除变量用于58/141(41%)的研究。
- LASSO用于35/141(25%)的研究。
- 常见两步组合为单变量筛选后续后退法(45/139,32%)和单变量筛选后续批量移除(43/139,31%)。
- 许多研究报告不充分,常见问题包括候选预测变量报告不完整和变量选择方法描述不清晰。
关键数值与推荐
- 单变量筛选使用率78%(110/141),后退法43%(60/141),批量移除41%(58/141),LASSO 25%(35/141)。
临床怎么用
- 开发二分类结局临床预测模型时,应避免单变量筛选和后退法等受批评方法,优先考虑LASSO等惩罚方法。
- 报告时应完整列出候选预测变量并清晰描述变量选择方法。
局限性
- 仅检索2024年10月1日至21日PubMed发表的文献,样本时间窗口窄。
- 仅纳入使用逻辑回归开发二分类结局预测模型的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Clinical prediction models are valuable tools that can support medical decision-making. Concise and interpretable models are more likely to be adopted in clinical practice; therefore, appropriate selection of predictor variables is often considered essential in model development. Typically, researchers specify a list of candidate predictors based on literature reviews and expert knowledge. Data-driven variable selection methods are then often used to further reduce the number of variables in the final model. However, many commonly used approaches, such as univariable selection, have been generally discouraged in prediction modeling. This systematic review aims to examine current practice regarding the use of data-driven variable selection when developing clinical prediction models for binary outcomes using logistic regression. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We focused on published articles in PubMed between October 1 and October 21, 2024, that developed prediction models for binary health outcomes using logistic regression. We extracted information on the study characteristics and, if applicable, the methodology used for variable selection. RESULTS: In total, 141 studies were included in the review. We found that nearly all studies (140/141) used data-driven variable selection. Univariable selection was by far the most used method; it was used in 78% (110/141) of studies. Other frequently used methods included backward elimination (BE) (60/141, 43%), "bulk removal" of variables (BR) from a single multivariable model (58/141, 41%), and Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator (LASSO) (35/141, 25%). Many studies applied a sequential application of variable selection methods; the most common two-step combinations were univariable selection followed by BE (45/139, 32%) and univariable selection followed by BR (43/139, 31%). In addition, many studies lacked sufficient detail in their reporting. Common problems included incomplete reporting of candidate predictors, and unclear specification of variable selection methods. CONCLUSION: Although data-driven variable selection is generally discouraged in clinical prediction modeling, nearly all studies in our review employed at least one such method, with many studies using two methods. Some of the most frequently criticized methods such as univariable selection and BE were commonly used. Modern penalized methods such as LASSO, which directly aim to optimize out-of-sample predictive performance while also removing redundant variables, were used less frequently.
引用
- Su X, Ambler G, Green N, et al. The use of variable selection in clinical prediction modeling for binary outcomes: a systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42276177. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112371
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。