美国医学生需要学习哪些临床实践指南知识:美国学生与全球指南制定者的定性研究
该定性研究通过焦点小组访谈20名美国三、四年级医学生和28名全球临床实践指南制定专家,探讨指南教育应包含的内容、实施障碍及现状。双方一致认为教育应涵盖指南目的、质量评价及将推荐应用于个体患者,但专家认为应在 preclinical 阶段引入,学生持不同意见。结论支持开发结构化教育模块并整合入现有课程。
要点
- 指南教育应涵盖指南目的、质量评价及推荐意见的个体化应用
- 课程时间紧张和教师对课程改革抵触是主要实施障碍
- 专家建议在 preclinical 阶段引入指南教育,但与学生观点不一致
核心结论
- 美国医学生认为其临床实践指南教育需要加强。
- 双方一致认为教育应包含指南目的、质量评价和推荐应用,但引入时机存在分歧。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,于2022年9月至2024年8月开展焦点小组访谈。
- 纳入20名美国三、四年级医学生(3个焦点小组)和28名全球临床实践指南制定专家(2个焦点小组)。
- 采用归纳主题分析法分析录音资料。
主要发现
- 专家强调通过动手学习活动教授指南目的。
- 学生和专家均认为教育材料应包括指南目的、质量评价及将推荐应用于个体患者场景。
- 双方均认为课程时间紧张和讲师及课程开发者对改变传统课程的抵触可能是实施障碍。
- 专家认为指南教育应在 preclinical 学年引入,但学生对此未达成一致。
临床怎么用
- 可开发结构化、扩展性的指南教育模块,整合入美国医学院 preclinical 和临床阶段现有课程。
局限性
- 研究仅反映美国医学生和全球部分指南制定专家的观点,需进一步研究非美国学生和教师的看法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Undergraduate United States (US) medical education may not provide adequate education on clinical practice guidelines (CPGs). OBJECTIVES: To identify types of information about CPG development and usage that US medical students and a global subset of CPG development experts considered important to teach students, to detect potential barriers that may limit the implementation of improved and comprehensive CPG education, and to understand the current education regarding CPGs. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Third- and fourth-year US medical students and CPG development experts participated in focus groups between September 2022 and August 2024. Verbal consent for audio recordings was obtained, with analysis via an inductive thematic approach. RESULTS: Three focus groups of US medical students (n = 20) and two focus groups of experts (n = 28) were convened. Experts emphasized the need to teach students the purpose of CPGs through hands-on learning activities. Both students and experts agreed that educational materials on CPGs should include the purpose of CPGs, how to evaluate the quality of CPGs and apply CPG recommendations to individual patient scenarios, and that time constraints for students within an already busy US medical school curriculum and resistance among lecturers and curriculum developers to altering traditional curricula may be barriers to implementing CPG education. Students and experts did not agree on when this education should be delivered in medical schools, with experts believing that education should be introduced during the students' preclinical years. CONCLUSION: US medical students believe that their CPG education needs to be bolstered. These findings support the development of new, structured, and expanded educational modules on various crucial aspects of CPG development and application able to be integrated into existing US medical school curricula in both the preclinical and clinical years. Further work should examine the perspectives of non-US medical students and instructors to inform globally adaptable educational approaches.
引用
- Yi MD, Shi V, Christensen RE, et al. What US medical students need to learn about clinical practice guidelines: a qualitative study of US students and a global subset of guidelines developers. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42176999. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112340
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。