神经性厌食症及其亚型的脑形态学:个体参与者数据的多队列研究
该研究基于ENIGMA进食障碍工作组11个国际站点的个体数据,纳入570例女性神经性厌食症(AN)患者和739例健康对照(HC),采用 mega 分析、规范建模和机器学习比较脑结构。结果证实AN存在广泛灰质缺陷,部分患者偏离极端,机器学习可可靠区分AN与HC(ROC-AUC=0.75-0.81),但AN亚型间无差异。
要点
- AN患者存在广泛灰质缺陷,部分个体偏离达极端水平。
- 机器学习可可靠区分AN与HC,ROC-AUC为0.75-0.81。
- AN限制型与暴食/清除型间脑结构无显著差异。
核心结论
- AN患者存在广泛灰质缺陷,部分个体偏离极端,且机器学习可稳健区分AN与HC。
- AN亚型间无组水平差异或极端z分数频率差异,亚型间无法可靠区分。
研究设计与样本
- 多队列个体参与者数据分析,来自11个国际站点,纳入570例女性AN患者和739例HC。
- 采用mega分析、基于CentileBrain规范模型的极端偏差频率分析及机器学习分类三种方法。
主要发现
- mega分析重复了既往meta分析发现的AN较HC广泛灰质缺陷。
- 规范建模显示AN中低于正常z分数(z<-1.96)的频率在23/68项皮质厚度和13/14项皮质下体积指标上显著高于参考数据。
- 高于正常z分数(z>1.96)的频率在35/68项皮质厚度和17/68项皮质表面积指标上显著高于参考数据。
- 机器学习分类器区分AN与HC的ROC-AUC为0.75-0.81。
- AN亚型间组水平差异和极端z分数频率均无差异,亚型间无法可靠区分。
关键数值与推荐
- 极端偏差定义为z<-1.96或z>1.96,基于CentileBrain倡议的规范参考模型。
- 机器学习分类性能以ROC-AUC=0.75-0.81评估。
- 亚型比较额外校正BMI效应。
临床怎么用
- 脑结构指标辅助区分AN与HC具有较高分类性能,但尚不能区分AN亚型。
- 临床解读AN脑结构改变时需考虑饥饿或低BMI的潜在影响。
局限性
- 观察性设计无法区分AN相关神经生物学差异与饥饿或低BMI效应。
- 亚型间无差异不排除其他模态或分析方法可检测的差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In a recent coordinated meta-analysis of neuroimaging data, we reported gray matter (GM) alterations in acutely underweight patients with anorexia nervosa (AN). Here, we extend these findings by examining individual variation in brain structure within AN, individual-level differentiation between AN and healthy controls (HC), and differences between AN subtypes, with potential relevance for understanding clinical heterogeneity. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We analyzed individual-level data from 11 international sites in the ENIGMA Eating Disorders Working Group, including 570 female participants with AN and 739 HC. We examined cortical thickness, cortical surface area and subcortical volumes in AN versus HC using three complementary approaches: (i) group-level differences in a mega-analysis correcting for age effects, (ii) frequencies of extreme deviations (infra-/supranormal; z < -1.96/z > 1.96) based on normative reference models by the CentileBrain Initiative, and (iii) individual-level classification performance using machine learning. The same analytic framework was applied to compare AN restricting versus binge-eating/purging subtype, additionally correcting for BMI effects. Mega-analyses reinforced previous meta-analytic findings of pronounced and widespread GM deficits in AN compared to HC. Normative modelling revealed that the frequency of infranormal z-scores (23/68 cortical thickness, 13/14 subcortical volume metrics) and supranormal z-scores (35/68 cortical thickness, 17/68 cortical surface area metrics) was significantly higher in AN than expected based on reference data. Individuals with AN could be reliably differentiated from HC using machine-learning classifiers (ROC-AUC = 0.75-0.81). In contrast, neither group-level differences nor frequency of extreme z-scores differed between AN subtypes, and individuals with different subtypes could not be reliably differentiated from each other. Importantly, the observational design cannot distinguish neurobiological differences related to AN from the effects of starvation or low BMI in the AN versus HC analyses. The lack of differences between subtypes does not exclude brain structural differences between AN subtypes that might be detectable with other modalities or analytic approaches. CONCLUSION: Using a mega-analytic approach, we confirm widespread GM deficits in AN, show that these alterations are (in some patients) extreme, and demonstrate that they enable robust classification with superior performance compared to most MRI-based psychiatric classification studies. The absence of differences between AN subtypes may reflect shared neurobiology, though other imaging modalities may reveal distinctions beyond brain structure.
引用
- Bernardoni F, Arold D, Schoppik L, et al. Brain morphology in Anorexia Nervosa and its subtypes: A multi-cohort study of individual participant data. PLoS Med. 2026. PMID: 42160333. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004809
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。