诊断准确性研究的传播度与方法学质量无关:一项系统综述与元流行病学分析
该研究通过预注册系统综述纳入782项评估SARS-CoV-2血清学检测诊断性能的研究,采用QUADAS-2评估偏倚风险,并用多变量回归分析传播指标与方法学特征的关系。结果显示传播度主要与期刊影响因子、发表年份、极端诊断准确性估计和作者H指数相关,而与低偏倚风险领域数量无关。
要点
- 诊断准确性研究的传播度与QUADAS-2方法学质量评级无正相关。
- 传播度主要与期刊影响因子、发表时间、作者H指数等结构性因素相关。
- 报告极端诊断准确性估计的研究获得更多传播。
核心结论
- 诊断准确性研究的传播度主要与结构性和作者特征相关,而非QUADAS-2评级。
- 传播度与研究质量关联较弱,提示需加强诊断性研究的证据评价方法。
研究设计与样本
- 预注册系统综述(PROSPERO CRD42023343656),检索Medline、Embase和iSearch Portfolio。
- 筛查18,092条记录,最终纳入782项评估SARS-CoV-2血清学检测诊断性能的研究。
- 使用QUADAS-2评估偏倚风险与适用性,采用多变量回归模型分析传播指标与方法学特征的关联。
主要发现
- 782项研究中,772项(98.7%)在至少一个领域存在高或不明确的偏倚风险。
- 传播指标与期刊影响因子、更早的发表年份、报告极端诊断准确性估计及更高的末位作者H指数呈正相关。
- 低偏倚风险或高适用性领域数量与引用次数、网络科学影响力或政策引用无正相关。
临床怎么用
- 解读诊断准确性研究时不应以传播度或引用量作为质量替代指标。
- 应重视QUADAS-2等工具对诊断研究的方法学评价。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate associations between methodological characteristics and dissemination measures in diagnostic accuracy studies. The COVID-19 pandemic generated a large body of studies addressing a single diagnostic question, allowing assessment of how study characteristics relate to dissemination. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Using a preregistered systematic review (PROSPERO CRD42023343656), we identified studies evaluating the diagnostic performance of SARS-CoV-2 serological tests through Medline, Embase, and the iSearch Portfolio. Risk of bias and applicability were assessed using QUADAS-2. Study characteristics were linked to dissemination measures, including journal impact factor, citation counts, network-based scientific influence (PageRank), and policy and guideline citations, using multivariable regression models. RESULTS: Among 18,092 screened records, 782 studies met the inclusion criteria. QUADAS-2 assessments varied substantially, with 772 of 782 studies (98.7%) exhibiting high or unclear risk of bias in at least one domain. Dissemination measures were positively associated with journal impact factor, earlier publication year, reporting of extreme diagnostic accuracy estimates, and higher last author H-index. In contrast, the number of domains rated as low risk of bias or high applicability was not positively associated with citation counts, network-based scientific influence, or policy citations. CONCLUSION: Dissemination was primarily associated with structural and authorship characteristics rather than QUADAS-2 ratings. These findings suggest that dissemination in diagnostic research is more closely linked to structural factors than assessed methodological quality and support strengthening diagnostic-specific approaches to evidence appraisal. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: We examined whether high-quality diagnostic studies receive more attention in science and clinical practice. Using a large set of studies on COVID-19 antibody tests, we found that attention was mainly linked to factors such as the journal, publication timing, and authorship, rather than to methodological quality. Studies reporting very high accuracy also received more attention. This suggests that widely cited or highly visible studies are not necessarily the most reliable. Our findings highlight the need for careful evaluation of diagnostic studies and stronger emphasis on study quality when interpreting and using research results.
引用
- Nilius H, Kuster L, Boss R, et al. Dissemination in diagnostic accuracy studies is not associated with methodological quality: a systematic review and meta-epidemiological analysis. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 42001977. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112270
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。