增加疫苗接种率的干预措施有效性:组件网络Meta分析
结果显示,延长接种机会、预约协助、经济激励、费用补贴和动机性访谈是有效的干预内容组件,人际互动和社区成员与医护人员共同递送是有效的递送组件,但有效组件因年龄组、弱势人群和新冠疫情影响而异。
要点
- 延长接种机会、预约协助、经济激励、费用补贴和动机性访谈是提高接种率的有效内容组件。
- 人际互动和社区成员与医护人员共同递送是有效的递送组件。
- 有效组件因年龄组、弱势人群和新冠疫情影响而异,需针对性设计干预。
核心结论
- 总体而言,延长接种机会、预约协助、经济激励、费用补贴和动机性访谈是增加疫苗接种率的有效干预内容组件。
- 有效的递送组件为面对面人际互动以及社区成员与医护人员共同递送。
- 有效组件因年龄组、弱势人群和新冠疫情影响而异,对设计、优化和实施针对性干预有重要意义。
研究设计与样本
- 组件网络Meta分析,系统检索高收入和中高收入国家的随机对照试验。
- 使用与利益相关者共同开发的编码框架识别干预的关键内容和递送特征,采用贝叶斯组件水平Meta回归估计比值比之比及95%可信区间。
主要发现
- 儿童:费用补贴的比值比之比为3.01(95% CrI 1.49至6.06),决策辅助为2.73(1.14至7.06),延长接种机会为1.37(0.98至1.95),社会因素为1.27(0.99至1.65)。
- 青少年和年轻成人:个人递送形式为2.13(1.09至4.40),社区成员与医护人员共同递送为6.42(1.94至25.62),社会因素为2.62(1.45至5.04);决策辅助为0.43(0.18至0.98),人际互动相对于非人际互动为0.47(0.21至1.02)。
- 成人:人际互动为1.86(1.42至2.45),延长接种机会为1.63(1.35至2.00),预约协助为1.38(1.06至1.78),费用补贴为1.47(1.03至2.16),动机性访谈为1.79(1.21至2.64);经济激励为1.15(0.99至1.35),疫苗安全性和/或有效性信息为1.15(0.99至1.32);非人际互动相对于无互动为0.72(0.57至0.92)。
- 亚组分析显示有效组件在弱势人群和新冠疫情前后(2020年前和2020年起)存在差异。
临床怎么用
- 针对儿童可优先考虑费用补贴、决策辅助、延长接种机会和社会因素支持。
- 针对青少年和年轻成人可采用个人递送、社区成员与医护人员共同递送及社会因素干预,慎用决策辅助。
- 针对成人可采用人际互动、延长接种机会、预约协助、费用补贴和动机性访谈,并考虑经济激励和疫苗信息。
- 设计干预时应考虑年龄组、弱势人群和新冠疫情背景的差异,并结合经济数据支持资源决策。
局限性
- 仅纳入高收入和中高收入国家的随机对照试验,结论外推需谨慎。
- 31项研究存在高偏倚风险,96项有一些担忧。
- 有效组件在弱势人群和新冠疫情前后的分析中存在差异,需进一步研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To identify the effective components of interventions to increase vaccine uptake and to explore variations in effectiveness by population group and in relation to the covid-19 pandemic. DESIGN: Component network meta-analysis. SETTING: Systematic review of randomised controlled trials in high and upper middle income countries. PARTICIPANTS: 237 studies with 570 intervention arms and 4 361 717 participants. INTERVENTIONS: Any intervention targeting vaccine recipients or their caregivers aiming to increase demand for, or access to, vaccinations on the UK immunisation schedule. Key content and delivery features of interventions were identified using a bespoke coding framework co-developed with stakeholders. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The outcome of interest was vaccine uptake. Bayesian component level meta-regression estimated relative effects of intervention components as ratios of odds ratios with 95% credible intervals (CrIs). RESULTS: Of the included studies, 110 were at low risk of bias, 96 had some concerns, and 31 were at high risk. 40% (n=1 744 686) of the participants were male. For children, there was evidence of beneficial effects for payments to cover costs (ratio of odds ratios 3.01, 95% CrI 1.49 to 6.06) and decision aids (2.73, 1.14 to 7.06), and some evidence for extended opportunities (1.37, 0.98 to 1.95) and social factors (1.27, 0.99 to 1.65). For adolescents and young adults, there were beneficial effects for personal delivery formats (2.13, 1.09 to 4.40), delivery by community members alongside healthcare professionals (6.42, 1.94 to 25.62), and social factors (2.62, 1.45 to 5.04), and negative effects for decision aids (0.43, 0.18 to 0.98) and human versus non-human interaction (0.47, 0.21 to 1.02). For adults, beneficial effects were shown for human interaction (1.86, 1.42 to 2.45), extended opportunities (1.63, 1.35 to 2.00), help with appointment scheduling (1.38, 1.06 to 1.78), payments to cover costs (1.47, 1.03 to 2.16), and motivational interviewing (1.79, 1.21 to 2.64), and there was some evidence for financial incentives (1.15, 0.99 to 1.35) and information on vaccine safety and/or efficacy (1.15, 0.99 to 1.32). For adults, evidence also showed a negative effect of non-human interaction versus no interaction (0.72, 0.57 to 0.92). Subgroup analyses showed variation for underserved populations and in relation to the covid-19 pandemic (before 2020 and 2020 onwards). CONCLUSION: Overall, extended opportunities, appointment scheduling help, financial incentives, payments to cover costs, and motivational interviewing were effective content components of interventions to increase vaccine uptake. Effective delivery components overall were human interaction and delivery by community members alongside healthcare professionals. However, effective components varied by age group, for underserved populations, and in analyses investigating the impact of the covid-19 pandemic. These findings have important implications for designing, optimising, and implementing targeted interventions, highlighting which components are effective across different populations and contexts. Consideration of the economic data on interventions should further support resource informed decision making.
引用
- Davies SR, Davies AL, Higgins JPT, et al. Effectiveness of interventions to increase vaccine uptake: component network meta-analysis. BMJ. 2026. PMID: 41985976. doi:10.1136/bmj-2025-087578
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。