推广肥皂洗手干预的成本效果与效益成本分析:一项系统综述
该系统综述检索了1980年至2025年多个数据库及灰色文献,纳入15项完整经济学评价,评估在家庭、教育和托育场所推广肥皂洗手的成本效果与效益成本。仅3项中高质量研究报告了每避免一个伤残调整生命年的成本,范围为37至937美元(2024年价格),其中2项相对于各自国家的合理阈值具有成本效果。唯一一项中高质量效益成本研究的平均效益成本比为2.1。
要点
- 推广肥皂洗手在成功提高并维持采纳率时很可能具有成本效果。
- 中高质量研究中每避免一个伤残调整生命年的成本为37至937美元(2024年价格)。
- 亟需更多实证研究,尤其是比较多种推广方案并同时评估呼吸道感染价值。
核心结论
- 推广肥皂洗手在成功提高并维持洗手行为采纳时很可能具有成本效果。
- 需要更多实证研究,特别是比较多种推广选项并同时评估呼吸道感染和腹泻减少价值的研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索Medline、Embase、Global Health、EconLit和Web of Science从1980年1月1日至2025年9月3日发表的研究及灰色文献(PROSPERO CRD42021288727)。
- 纳入比较两种或以上干预成本与结果的完整经济学评价,干预为在家庭、教育和托育场所推广肥皂洗手实践。
- 共纳入15项研究,其中3项在高收入国家;5项使用实证数据收集评估实际实施的干预,10项仅基于二手数据建模。
- 使用 Consolidated Health Economic Evaluation Reporting Standards 对报告质量进行评分。
主要发现
- 在3项报告每避免一个伤残调整生命年成本的中或高质量研究中,估计范围为37至937美元(2024年价格)。
- 上述3项估计中,2项相对于各自国家的合理阈值具有成本效果。
- 唯一一项中或高质量效益成本研究中,在洗手采纳率40%和采纳者依从率50%的「中等」水平下,平均效益成本比为2.1。
- 很少研究测量或建模洗手采纳随时间的变化,且没有聚焦腹泻的研究同时评估呼吸道感染的价值。
临床怎么用
- 在资源分配决策中,推广肥皂洗手可视为在成功提高并维持采纳率时很可能具有成本效果的干预。
- 参考中高质量研究中每避免一个伤残调整生命年37至937美元(2024年价格)的成本范围及效益成本比2.1进行本地化评估。
局限性
- 本综述排除了含醇手消毒剂干预。
- 成本效果阈值存在高度不确定性。
- 仅3项研究在高收入国家,且多数研究为基于二手数据的模型分析。
- 很少研究测量或建模洗手采纳随时间的变化,且无聚焦腹泻的研究同时评估呼吸道感染价值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Promoting handwashing with soap reduces risk of diarrhoea by 30% and respiratory infections by 17%. Handwashing promotion in nonhealthcare settings is widely considered cost-effective, but there is no systematic review on this topic. To inform resource allocation decisions, we reviewed the state and quality of evidence regarding cost-effectiveness and benefit-cost of interventions promoting handwashing with soap in domestic, educational, and childcare settings globally. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We searched Medline, Embase, Global Health, EconLit, and Web of Science for studies published from January 1, 1980 to September 3, 2025, as well as grey literature (PROSPERO CRD42021288727). We included full economic evaluations comparing the cost of two or more interventions with their outcomes. We included interventions promoting the practice of handwashing with soap, including those providing information, motivational campaigns, and/or handwashing facilities. We scored quality of reporting using the Consolidated Health Economic Evaluation Reporting Standards. We identified 15 studies of which 3 were in high-income countries. Five used empirical data collection to evaluate interventions actually implemented and 10 modelled from secondary data only. Amongst the 3 medium- or high-quality studies reporting cost per disability-adjusted life-year averted, estimates ranged from US$ 37 to 937 (2024 prices). Of these 3 estimates, 2 were cost-effective compared to plausible thresholds for the respective country. In the only medium- or high-quality benefit-cost study, the mean benefit-cost ratio was 2.1 with "medium" levels of handwashing adoption (40% of population) and adherence (50% of those adopting). Few studies measured or modelled adoption of handwashing over time, and none which focussed on diarrhoea also valued respiratory infections. Limitations of our review include that we excluded alcohol-based handrub interventions, and that there is high uncertainty about cost-effectiveness thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: Promoting handwashing with soap is very likely to be cost-effective for interventions that successfully increase and sustain adoption of handwashing behaviours. More empirical studies are needed, especially those comparing multiple promotion options and valuing reductions in respiratory infections as well as diarrhoea.
引用
- Ross I, Bath D, Wells J, et al. Cost-effectiveness and benefit-cost analyses of promoting handwashing with soap: A systematic review. PLoS Med. 2026. PMID: 41931475. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004982
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。