德尔菲研究的样本量与共识方法异质性:一项元研究
该元研究分析PubMed开放获取的1875篇文章(1904项德尔菲研究),发现仅19%报告计划样本量,仅16%说明样本量依据;共识阈值以80%百分比最常见;样本量与共识方法差异显著,亟需制定共识指南。
要点
- 仅19%德尔菲研究报告计划样本量,仅16%说明样本量依据。
- 共识阈值最常用80%百分比,但定义方法多样。
- 德尔菲研究样本量与共识方法异质性大,需统一报告规范。
核心结论
- 使用德尔菲法的研究在样本量和共识方法上差异显著,需要制定关于样本量的共识指南和一致的共识标准报告建议。
研究设计与样本
- 这是一项元研究,分析从PubMed检索的开放获取英文全文文章,这些文章报告了使用德尔菲法的原始研究结果。
- 分析共纳入1875篇文章,描述了1904项德尔菲研究。
- 分析内容包括计划与实际实施的轮数、计划样本量及依据、每轮邀请和纳入的参与者数量以及达成共识的方法。
主要发现
- 仅19%的研究报告了计划样本量,总体样本量范围为5至420名参与者(中位数19-25)。
- 仅16%的研究描述了样本量依据。
- 第一轮邀请参与者数量通常有报告,总体范围为3至7468人(中位数20-37)。
- 第一轮纳入参与者数量最常被报告,总体范围为3至2295人(中位数14-27.5);其他轮次参与者数量递减。
- 大多数研究(66%)使用Likert量表,最常见的是单一五点量表;大多数研究使用百分比阈值定义共识,80%最常见;其他数值定义包括中位数、均值和重要性排序。
关键数值与推荐
- 仅19%的研究报告计划样本量,范围5-420人(中位数19-25)。
- 仅16%的研究描述样本量依据。
- 第一轮邀请参与者范围3-7468人(中位数20-37),纳入参与者范围3-2295人(中位数14-27.5)。
- 66%的研究使用Likert量表,最常见为单一五点量表。
- 大多数研究使用百分比阈值定义共识,80%最常见;其他定义包括中位数、均值和重要性排序。
临床怎么用
- 临床研究者设计德尔菲研究时应报告计划样本量及其依据。
- 应明确报告每轮邀请和纳入的参与者数量及共识定义方法。
- 建议参考未来制定的德尔菲研究样本量和共识标准报告指南。
局限性
- 仅分析了开放获取的英文全文文章,可能遗漏非开放获取或非英文发表的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Few studies have examined sample size and consensus methods in Delphi studies, leaving limited knowledge in the field of biomedicine. We aimed to analyze these methodological aspects in published articles in which the Delphi method was used. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: This was a meta-research study. We analyzed open-access full-text articles in English, retrieved from PubMed, that reported results of primary studies that used a Delphi method. The analysis included the number of planned and conducted rounds, the planned sample size and justification for the sample size, the number of invited and included participants in each round, and the methods used to achieve consensus. RESULTS: Analysis included 1875 articles describing 1904 Delphi studies. The description of the study design was provided in most articles (N = 1157; 62%). The word Delphi was mentioned in the title of 636 articles (34%), and the word consensus appeared in the title of 502 articles (27%). Only 19% of studies reported planned sample size, ranging in the overall sample from 5 to 420 participants (median 19-25). The rationale for their size was described in only 16% of the studies. Invited participants were usually reported for the first round, ranging in the overall sample from 3 to 7468 (median 20-37). The number of participants included was also most often stated for the first round, and in the overall sample, it ranged from 3 to 2295 (median 14-27.5). For all other Delphi rounds used in the studies, a decreasing number of participants was reported. Likert point scales were used in most studies (66%), most often as a single five-point scale. A percentage threshold for consensus was used in most studies, with 80% being the most common. Other numerical definitions most often used were the median, mean, and importance ranking. CONCLUSION: Sample sizes and consensus methods vary significantly in studies using the Delphi method. Therefore, consensus guidelines on sample sizes and recommendations for consistent reporting of consensus criteria need to be developed. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Researchers often use the Delphi method to collect and combine opinions from experts, usually through several rounds of questionnaires, to reach agreement on important topics such as clinical guidelines or research priorities. However, there is little clear guidance on how many experts should take part in these studies or how consensus should be defined. In this study, we examined 1904 Delphi studies published in biomedical journals. We looked at how many participants the authors planned to include, how many they actually invited and retained in each round, and how they defined when experts had reached agreement. We found large differences between studies. Only about one in five studies reported how many participants they planned to include, and even fewer explained why they chose that number. The number of participants ranged from just a few to several hundred. Definitions of consensus also varied widely, with thresholds ranging from 50% to 100% agreement, most often 80%. These findings show that Delphi studies are conducted and reported in very different ways. To make Delphi research more transparent, comparable, and reliable, there is a need for consensus-based guidelines on how to plan, conduct, and report Delphi studies, including how to choose the number of participants and how to define consensus.
引用
- Škrinjar I, Vučić K, Puljak L, et al. Sample size and consensus methods used in Delphi studies are heterogeneous: meta-research study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 41921829. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112262
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。