活证据与缺口图:44个数字界面及其文档中自动化与活模式参数的范围综述
该范围综述评估了44个持续更新的活证据与缺口图(L-EGM)数字界面,分析其更新计划、退役计划、活状态、自动化使用及方法学指南引用情况。多数L-EGM未明确报告活状态与退役计划,70%报告使用自动化,但仅25%报告自动化性能指标或验证方法。作者呼吁制定针对L-EGM的专门指南以提升透明度和可靠性。
要点
- 仅14%报告退役计划,39%说明是否仍处于活状态,25%报告自动化性能指标或验证方法。
核心结论
- 数字活证据与缺口图日益增多且多使用自动化(尤其机器学习),但活模式参数与自动化方法报告不足,亟需针对地图的专门指南。
研究设计与样本
- 跨部门范围综述,针对具有在线界面的活证据与缺口图(L-EGM),检索Google(2022年6月及2025年4月/9月)、Web of Science核心合集与MEDLINE(2026年1月),并补充方法学综述记录及纳入地图的支持文档。
主要发现
- 仅14%报告退役计划,39%说明L-EGM是否仍处于活状态。
- 25%的L-EGM报告了上下文特定的自动化性能指标或验证方法。
临床怎么用
- 在专门指南建立前,活证据与缺口图作者可遵循现有关于负责任自动化、活系统综述及其他活证据合成的建议。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To examine how continually updated, living evidence and gap maps (L-EGMs) with an online presence report planned update schedules, retirement plans, living status, use of automation across review stages, and the methodological guidance cited to support their conduct and reporting. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A cross-sectoral scoping review of digital L-EGM interfaces, which act as foundational support tools for decision-makers by providing a visual and interactive summary of all available evidence, as well as evidence gaps. Targeted searches were conducted in Google search engine (June 2022 and April/September 2025), Web of Science Core Collection and MEDLINE (January 2026), supplemented by records from a methodology review and additional EGMs found through supporting documentation of included maps, or known to the research team. RESULTS: Forty-four L-EGMs, predominantly health sector-related, met the eligibility criteria. Half of the digital interfaces cited big picture review guidance in their associated documentation, 11% cited (living) systematic review guidance, and 39% did not cite any overarching synthesis typology or living evidence synthesis guidance. Fifty-seven percent reported a fixed update schedule with planned update frequencies varying from daily to every 2 years (median: 1 month), but most did not clarify whether schedules differed across update stages. Only 14% reported retirement plans and 39% indicated whether the L-EGM is still living. Automation or semiautomation was reported in 70% of L-EGMs. Fifty-nine percent used it for searching, 45% for screening and 34% for coding, with many reporting automation across multiple stages. In addition, three L-EGMs used a natural language processing-based risk of bias assessment tool. Twenty-five percent of L-EGMs reported context-specific automation performance metrics or validation approaches. CONCLUSIONS: We identified a growing body of digital, living EGMs that use automation-especially machine learning-that could be systematically reviewed. Reviewers and methodologists should further assess the potential for automating EGMs, their actual living mode parameters, methodological changes, and how these are reported across web-based versus conventional outputs, working toward a consensus on map-specific guidance. Until such guidance is established, authors of living EGMs can follow existing recommendations for responsible automation, living systematic reviews, and other living evidence syntheses PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: This study examined 'living' evidence and gap maps. These maps are online tools that show where research evidence exists and where important gaps remain. They are meant to be updated regularly as new research is published. The authors identified 44 living evidence and gap maps (L-EGMs) and looked at how they are updated, whether they use automated methods, and how clearly these methods are described. They found that L-EGMs are becoming more common, especially in health research, and are often built using specialised software platforms. Most maps claimed they are updated at regular intervals, but few clearly reported whether they are still being updated, how often key steps (like incorporating new studies) are repeated, or whether there is a plan to stop updating them in the future. About 70% of the maps used some form of automated method, most often to find new studies and help decide whether they were relevant to include. Over half used machine learning (ML), of which a small number used newer artificial intelligence methods. However, authors rarely explained how these tools were used or tested, and there was very little evidence on whether these automated methods were efficient and accurate. The study also found that many L-EGMs do not follow existing guidance. The authors conclude that tailored guidance is urgently needed to ensure that L-EGMs are transparent and reliable. This is important if they are used to help allocate limited research resources, for example, in health care.
引用
- Kozakiewicz T, Wong R, Ghouze Z, et al. Living evidence and gap maps: a scoping review of automation and living mode parameters reported in 44 digital interfaces and their documentation. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 41796756. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112211
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。