RADIAL概念验证试验:三种去中心化程度下参与者满意度
RADIAL是一项在六个欧洲国家开展的三臂低干预IV期概念验证试验,评估全去中心化、混合和传统三种试验方式下2型糖尿病患者的满意度。结果显示各臂72%至100%的参与者对整体试验参与满意,但混合臂满意度随时间下降且低于传统臂,主要与技术问题有关;远程臂仅7人无法得出有意义的满意度结论。
要点
- 各试验臂72%至100%的参与者对整体试验参与表示满意
- 混合臂满意度随时间下降且低于传统臂,与技术问题相关
- 远程臂仅7名参与者,无法得出有意义的满意度结论
核心结论
- 去中心化试验方式对参与者似乎可接受,试验活动可负责任地从研究中心转移至参与者家中而不实质性影响满意度。
- 混合臂的技术问题对满意度产生负面影响,提示需使用适用技术和妥善应对数字挑战。
研究设计与样本
- RADIAL为三臂、低干预、IV期概念验证试验,在六个欧洲国家开展。
- 试验设全去中心化臂、混合臂和传统臂,对象为2型糖尿病患者。
- 参与者满意度在基線(第0周)、第12周和第24周通过数字问卷测量。
主要发现
- 所有臂中72%至100%的参与者对整体试验参与表示满意。
- 混合臂满意度随时间下降,且低于传统臂。
- 混合臂参与者报告试验技术问题是不满意的原因,并对特定数字试验组件不满意。
- 混合臂对时间投入和数据收集的满意度也低于传统臂。
- 两臂参与者对试验前信息可理解性、安全感、与试验人员互动及预约时间的满意度为92%至100%。
临床怎么用
- 在试验中纳入参与者满意度测量有助于理解参与者对不同去中心化试验活动的体验。
- 未来试验设计应使用适用技术并妥善应对潜在数字挑战,以贴合参与者需求。
局限性
- 远程臂仅7名参与者,无法就该臂满意度得出有意义的结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: As clinical trials increasingly adopt decentralised elements to potentially reduce burden and enhance participant inclusion, data on participant experience and satisfaction becomes essential to inform future decentralised trial designs. This study investigated participant satisfaction in three trial arms: a fully decentralised arm, a hybrid arm and a conventional arm in individuals with type 2 diabetes mellitus. METHODS: RADIAL, a three-arm, low-intervention, phase IV proof-of-concept trial, was set up in six European countries and aimed to evaluate the scientific and operational quality as well as the feasibility of trial approaches with different levels of decentralisation. Participant satisfaction was measured at three time points: at start (week 0), during (week 12), and at the end of the trial (week 24), using digital questionnaires. RESULTS: In all arms, 72% to 100% of participants were satisfied with overall trial participation, but satisfaction decreased over time in the hybrid arm compared to the conventional arm. Participants reported issues with trial technologies as reasons for their dissatisfaction in the hybrid arm, which was further substantiated by dissatisfaction with specific digital trial components. Satisfaction with the time commitments and data collection was also lower in the hybrid arm than in the conventional arm. Nevertheless, participants in both arms were very satisfied with the comprehensibility of the information before trial start, feeling of safety, interaction with trial staff, and timing of trial appointments, ranging from 92% to 100%. Due to the small number of seven participants in the remote arm, no meaningful conclusions on satisfaction could be drawn in this arm. CONCLUSIONS: Decentralisation seems to be acceptable to trial participants, as trial activities can be responsibly shifted from the research site to participants' homes, e.g. decentralised, without materially impacting participant satisfaction. However, technological issues negatively affected satisfaction in the hybrid arm, highlighting the need to utilise fit-for-purpose technologies and adequately address potential digital challenges in trials. Including participant satisfaction measures in trials deepens the understanding of how participants experience different (decentralised) trial activities, which can help to tailor future trials to their needs. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT05780151 (2023-03-08) and CTIS 2022-500,449-26-00 (2022-03-28).
引用
- Kopanz J, Zuidgeest MGP, Rutgrink L, et al. Participant satisfaction across three trial arms with varying degrees of decentralisation in the RADIAL proof-of-concept trial. Trials. 2026. PMID: 41814361. doi:10.1186/s13063-026-09616-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。