文献速递临床试验与 GCP流行病学与生物统计

临床试验招募干预的理论与行为改变技术:随机评估的系统综述

Theory and behaviour change techniques informing strategies to improve recruitment to clinical trials: a systematic review of randomised evaluations.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2026-03-25

该系统综述纳入122项招募干预随机评估研究,评估其理论报告及行为改变技术(BCT)可识别程度。仅19%明确报告使用理论,29%未报告可编码BCT,常见BCT包括健康后果信息、社会环境影响信息和提示/线索。

要点

  • 仅19%的招募干预研究明确报告使用理论、模型或框架。
  • 29%的研究未报告任何可编码的行为改变技术。
  • 常见BCT为健康后果信息、社会环境影响信息和提示/线索。

核心结论

  • 评估招募干预的研究常未报告理论、模型或框架的使用,且许多行为改变技术未被报告。
  • 将临床试验参与视为行为可能拓宽基于实证的招募策略范围。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,纳入来自Cochrane综述和临床试验研究在线资源数据库的122项招募干预随机评估研究。
  • 纳入标准为报告招募或参与意愿结局的研究。

主要发现

  • 122项研究中仅23项(19%)明确报告使用理论、模型或框架。
  • 理论最常用于干预设计(n=15,12%)或论证(n=14,11%)。
  • 最常引用的理论为计划行为理论(n=7,6%)和前景理论(n=3,3%)。
  • 研究包含1个可识别BCT者43项(35%),最多7个者2项(2%)。
  • 常见BCT包括健康后果信息(n=25,21%)、社会和环境后果信息(n=30,25%)及提示/线索(n=25,21%);35项(29%)未报告可编码BCT。

临床怎么用

  • 设计招募干预时可考虑明确应用行为改变理论及BCT分类,以提升策略可复制性。
  • 优先报告所使用的BCT,便于同行识别和复用有效成分。

局限性

  • 仅基于现有随机评估的报告内容评估理论与BCT使用,可能低估实际应用。
  • BCT编码受报告完整性限制,未报告不等于未使用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Efficiently meeting recruitment targets is foundational to clinical trial success. Past reviews on improving recruitment efficiency have highlighted only a few evidence-supported strategies; some of which may be context-specific, infeasible, or unsustainable. Re-framing research participation as a behaviour subject to the same forces as other human behaviours allows us to consider whether knowledge about behaviour change in other contexts can be applied to trial recruitment, potentially leading to more efficient theory-informed strategies. This study assessed randomised evaluations of recruitment interventions regarding (1) whether and how they reported using theory and (2) the extent behaviour change techniques (BCTs) were identifiable within recruitment methods and interventions. METHODS: We examined reports of randomised evaluations of recruitment interventions from a Cochrane review of trials evaluating strategies to improve recruitment, and the online resource for research in clinical trials database. To be eligible, studies had to include recruitment or willingness-to-participate outcomes. First, we assessed how and to what extent authors reported using theories, models, or frameworks in any part of their trial. Second, we extracted use of BCTs from study recruitment methods guided by the BCT taxonomy. RESULTS: We included 122 recruitment intervention studies. Few (n = 23, 19%) explicitly reported theory, model, or framework use; most often, theory was used to inform the intervention design (n = 15, 12%) or justification (n = 14, 11%). The most frequently cited theories included the theory of planned behaviour (n = 7, 6%) and prospect theory (n = 3, 3%). Studies contained anywhere from one identifiable BCT (n = 43, 35%) up to seven (n = 2, 2%); these typically included providing information about health consequences (e.g. side effects; n = 25, 21%), information about social and environmental consequences (e.g. helping society; n = 30, 25%), and prompts/cues (e.g. reminders; n = 25, 21%). Many studies did not report any codable BCTs (n = 35, 29%). CONCLUSIONS: Studies evaluating recruitment interventions often fail to report any consideration of theories, models, or frameworks, and many well-understood behaviour change techniques are generally not reported. Future research that frames clinical trial participation as one or more behaviours may broaden the range of empirically based strategies available to support participation and lead to more productive evaluations of theory-guided, elemental, and empirically supported recruitment strategies.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hudek N, Carroll K, Semchishen SN, et al. Theory and behaviour change techniques informing strategies to improve recruitment to clinical trials: a systematic review of randomised evaluations. Trials. 2026. PMID: 41882775. doi:10.1186/s13063-026-09664-w

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。