多中心随机实用性试验招募美国退伍军人慢性腰痛患者
本研究基于VERDICT实用性临床试验,比较VA医疗系统中三种招募策略的参与度、效率与代表性。2021年2月至2024年5月在4个VA机构筛查3667名退伍军人,39个月内入组随机766人。现有转诊策略最有效,邮件邀请响应更快,EHR预筛女性比例最高。
要点
- 现有转诊是最有效招募策略,通知至随机中位时间23天。
- 邮件邀请中位响应16天,仅邮寄为30天。
- EHR预筛招募女性退伍军人比例最高达79%。
核心结论
- 实用性临床试验可通过可调整的多方面策略克服招募挑战,并改善参与度和多样性。
研究设计与样本
- 基于VERDICT实用性临床试验,在美国4个VA机构招募慢性腰痛退伍军人,2021年2月至2024年5月。
- 采用3种招募策略:现有脊椎推拿转诊、电子健康记录预筛、自我转诊。
- 采用5步序贯筛查:识别通知、电话筛查、知情同意、资格问题、脊椎推拿咨询。
主要发现
- 共筛查3667名退伍军人:91%经现有转诊识别,7%经EHR预筛,2%经自我转诊。
- 62%仅收到邮寄材料,38%收到邮寄加电子邮件材料,83%接受虚拟基线访视。
- 39个月内766人入组并随机;因VA脊椎推拿门诊容量有限,19%合格退伍军人未入组。
- 所有筛查步骤中45%不感兴趣,35%不符合条件。
- 现有转诊策略招募种族和族裔少数群体比例最高为33%;EHR预筛女性比例最高为79%。
关键数值与推荐
- 现有转诊从通知到随机的中位时间为23天。
- 电子邮件邀请的中位响应时间为16天,仅邮寄邀请为30天。
临床怎么用
- 在VA实用性试验中可优先利用现有转诊渠道以提高招募效率。
- 结合电子邮件和虚拟访视策略可提升招募参与度和多样性。
- 需关注VA脊椎推拿门诊容量限制对合格者入组的影响。
局限性
- 研究仅在美国4个VA机构开展,招募策略效果可能受机构容量和人群特征影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Evidence on recruitment strategies for Veterans Health Administration (VA) pragmatic clinical trials (PCTs) is scarce. This study compares multiple approaches and evaluates engagement, efficiency, and representativeness in the integrated care setting of VA. METHODS: We examined recruitment and screening processes used in the Veterans Response to Dosage in Chiropractic Therapy (VERDICT) PCT. Veterans with chronic low back pain were recruited and enrolled in 4 US VA facilities from February 2021 to May 2024. We used 3 recruitment strategies: existing referrals for chiropractic services, electronic health record (EHR) prescreen, and self-referral. Pre-enrollment contacts occurred through postal mail, email, and in-person or virtual baseline visits. We used 5 sequential screening steps leading to final eligibility determination: (1) identify and notify, (2) phone screen, (3) consent, (4) eligibility questions, and (5) chiropractic consultation. RESULTS: We screened 3667 veterans: 91% were identified through existing referrals, 7% through EHR prescreen, and 2% through self-referral; 62% received postal-only recruitment materials, 38% received a combination of postal + email materials, and 83% had a virtual baseline visit. Over 39 months, 766 individuals were enrolled and randomized. Due to limited VA chiropractic clinic capacity, 19% of eligible veterans were not enrolled. Across all steps of the screening process, 45% were not interested, and 35% were ineligible. Using existing referrals was the most efficient strategy, with a median time from notification to randomization of 23 days. Those emailed invitations had a median response time of 16 days, compared with 30 days for postal-only invitations. The existing referrals strategy was the most effective for recruiting racial and ethnic minorities (33%). EHR prescreen resulted in the highest proportion of female veterans (79%). CONCLUSIONS: This study is among the few to compare multiple recruitment strategies in a VA PCT while assessing engagement, efficiency, and representativeness. VERDICT shows that PCTs can overcome recruitment challenges through adaptable, multifaceted approaches. By addressing systemic barriers and implementing email and virtual strategies, we improved recruitment engagement and diversity. These methods can inform recruitment for trials in other VA-based and real-world settings. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinical trial registration number: NCT04087291. Participant enrollment began on February 22, 2021, and ended on May 10, 2024. Registered on August 27, 2019.
引用
- Steward A, Salsbury SA, Vining RD, et al. Recruiting US veterans with chronic low back pain in a multisite randomized pragmatic trial. Trials. 2026. PMID: 41857686. doi:10.1186/s13063-026-09637-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。