指南与共识医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

专家对方法学研究设计、实施、分析或报告的意见共识有限:一项调查研究

Limited consensus in expert opinions on studies evaluating the design, conduct, analysis, or reporting of health research: a survey study.
指南 / 共识 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2026-03-20

该调查研究向499名方法学研究专家发放问卷,119人完成(应答率23%)。13个拟议术语均未达到适当性阈值,4个研究分类中2个被保留,23个报告条目中15个获认可进一步评估。专家在术语方面分歧显著,提示需协作共识流程制定报告指南。

要点

  • 方法学研究尚无专属报告规范,影响其可见性、可重复性和实用性。
  • 专家对方法学研究术语共识不足,13个拟议术语均未达适当性阈值。
  • 研究分类和报告条目部分获认可,但需进一步共识以制定实用报告指南。

核心结论

  • 专家对方法学研究的关键方面存在显著分歧,尤其是术语方面。
  • 部分研究分类和报告条目获得一定共识,但观点多样且有时冲突,凸显标准化的复杂性。
  • 需要协作共识流程以制定既实用又能适应领域细微差别的报告指南。

研究设计与样本

  • 对具有方法学研究设计与实施专长的研究人员进行问卷调查。
  • 共邀请499人,119人完成调查,应答率23%。
  • 定量数据采用描述性分析,并应用内容效度比判定适当性;定性回答采用归纳内容分析。

主要发现

  • 13个拟议术语均未达到适当性阈值。
  • 4个拟议研究分类中,2个(研究目的和研究设计)基于专家评分被保留。
  • 23个拟议报告条目中,15个被认可需进一步评估。
  • 定性回答经浓缩归类,识别出术语灵活性的重要性及对分类的担忧。

关键数值与推荐

  • 13个拟议术语均未达到适当性阈值。
  • 4个拟议研究分类中2个(研究目的和研究设计)被保留。
  • 23个拟议报告条目中15个被认可进一步评估。

临床怎么用

  • 方法学研究报告暂缺乏专属规范,研究者应关注术语和分类的灵活性。
  • 可参考获认可的研究分类(研究目的和研究设计)和15个报告条目进行报告。
  • 参与协作共识进程,推动制定实用且可适应的报告指南。

局限性

  • 应答率23%,可能存在无应答偏倚。
  • 专家意见分歧较大,部分结果仅基于内容效度比阈值判定。
  • 调查结果反映专家观点,尚未形成正式报告指南。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Methodological studies critically evaluate how health research is designed, conducted, analyzed, and reported. Despite their growing importance, currently, there is no reporting tailored to this type of research, which hampers the visibility, reproducibility, and overall utility of the findings of methodological studies. METHODS: We administered a survey to researchers with expertise in designing and performing methodological studies to gather their opinions on appropriate terminology, how they should be categorized, and key reporting elements. Quantitative data were analyzed descriptively, with a content validity ratio applied to determine appropriateness. Qualitative survey responses were analyzed using inductive content analysis. RESULT: Of 499 invited, a total of 119 participants completed the survey (response rate 23%). None of the 13 proposed nomenclatures met the threshold for appropriateness. Of the four proposed study categories, two (study aim and study design) were retained based on expert ratings. Among 23 proposed reporting items, 15 were endorsed for further evaluation. Qualitative responses were condensed and categorized, identifying the importance of flexibility in terminology and concerns about categorization. CONCLUSION: There is substantial disagreement among experts regarding key aspects of methodological studies, particularly related to terminology. While some agreement was observed around study categories and reporting elements, diverse and sometimes conflicting perspectives underscore the complexity of standardizing methodological studies. These findings reinforce the need for a collaborative consensus process to develop reporting guidance that is both practical and adaptable to the nuances of this field.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Silva JM, Lima JP, Lawson DO, et al. Limited consensus in expert opinions on studies evaluating the design, conduct, analysis, or reporting of health research: a survey study. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 41865805. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112245

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。