大型语言模型辅助复杂心脏病诊疗的随机对照试验
本研究通过随机对照试验评估大型语言模型AMIE辅助全科心脏科医生管理疑似遗传性心肌病复杂病例的效果。九名心脏科医生随机在有或无AMIE辅助下处理病例,由三名盲法亚专科专家按十域评分评估。结果显示亚专科专家更偏好AMIE辅助的评估(46.7% vs 32.7%,P=0.02),且AMIE辅助组临床显著错误更少(13.1% vs 24.3%,P=0.033)、遗漏内容更少(17.8% vs 37.4%,P=0.0021)。
要点
- AMIE辅助评估被亚专科专家偏好比例更高(46.7% vs 32.7%)
- AMIE辅助组临床显著错误率更低(13.1% vs 24.3%)
- AMIE辅助组遗漏内容更少(17.8% vs 37.4%)
核心结论
- 在回顾性患者数据的随机对照试验中,亚专科专家整体更偏好大语言模型辅助的心脏科评估,尤其在管理计划和诊断检查领域。
- AMIE辅助的心脏科医生临床显著错误和遗漏内容均少于单独心脏科医生。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,比较大语言模型辅助诊疗与常规诊疗对疑似遗传性心肌病复杂患者的管理。
- 从亚专科心脏科实践 curated 真实世界复杂病例数据集,九名参与的全科心脏科医生可获取临床文本报告和原始诊断数据。
- 医生被随机分配在有或无AMIE辅助下管理病例,由三名盲法亚专科专家使用十域评估 rubric 评价分诊、诊断和管理质量。
主要发现
- 亚专科专家整体偏好AMIE辅助评估的比例为46.7%,单独心脏科医生为32.7%,平局为20.6%(P=0.02)。
- 单独心脏科医生临床显著错误率为24.3%,AMIE辅助组为13.1%(P=0.033)。
- 单独心脏科医生遗漏内容率为37.4%,AMIE辅助组为17.8%(P=0.0021)。
- 使用AMIE的心脏科医生报告AMIE在超过一半时间(57.0%)帮助其评估,并在50.5%的病例中节省时间。
临床怎么用
- 在复杂心脏病病例管理中,大语言模型辅助可能减少临床显著错误和遗漏内容,并节省时间。
- 亚专科专家对AMIE辅助的管理计划和诊断检查评估更优,可考虑作为决策支持工具。
局限性
- 研究使用回顾性患者数据,非前瞻性实时临床环境。
- 样本量较小,仅九名全科心脏科医生参与。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The scarcity of subspecialist medical expertise poses a considerable challenge for healthcare delivery. This issue is particularly acute in cardiology, where timely, accurate management determines outcomes. We explored the potential of Articulate Medical Intelligence Explorer (AMIE), a large language model-based experimental medical artificial intelligence system, to augment clinical decision-making in this challenging context. We conducted a randomized controlled trial comparing large language model-assisted care with the usual care of complex patients suspected of having a genetic cardiomyopathy, and we curated a real-world dataset of complex cases from a subspecialist cardiology practice. Nine participating general cardiologists were provided with access to both clinical text reports and raw diagnostic data-including electrocardiograms, echocardiograms, cardiac magnetic resonance imaging scans and cardiopulmonary exercise testing-and were randomized to manage these cases, either with or without assistance from AMIE. We developed a ten-domain evaluation rubric used by three blinded subspecialists to evaluate the quality of triage, diagnosis and management. In our randomized controlled trial with retrospective patient data, subspecialists favored large language model-assisted responses overall, and for the management plan and diagnostic testing domains, with the remaining domains considered a tie. Overall, subspecialists preferred AMIE-assisted cardiology assessments 46.7% of the time, compared with 32.7% for cardiologists alone (P = 0.02), with 20.6% rated as a tie. Subspecialists also quantified errors, extra and missing content, reasoning and potential bias. Cardiologists alone had more clinically significant errors (24.3% versus 13.1%, P = 0.033) and more missing content (37.4% versus 17.8%, P = 0.0021) than cardiologists assisted by AMIE. Lastly, cardiologists who used AMIE reported that AMIE helped their assessment more than half the time (57.0%) and saved time in 50.5% of cases.
引用
- O'Sullivan JW, Palepu A, Saab K, et al. A large language model for complex cardiology care. Nat Med. 2026. PMID: 41652123. doi:10.1038/s41591-025-04190-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。