快速扩张的论文与问题研究对健康及生物医学文献诚信的新威胁
该文采用科学计量学分析,考察36个开放获取健康数据集的论文发表趋势是否偏离既往轨迹,并结合作者地理来源变化与公式化标题增加进行判断。共识别9个数据集呈现论文工厂利用特征,其2025年发文量合计23005篇,较自回归整合移动平均预测趋势超出11577篇,为2022年7655篇的3.0倍。
要点
- 9个数据集呈现论文工厂利用特征,2025年合计发文23005篇,超出预测趋势11577篇。
- 上述9个数据集2025年发文量为2022年7655篇的3.0倍,提示发表量异常膨胀。
- 中国作者相关倍数变化为4.2倍,世界其他地区为1.9倍,且公式化标题增多。
核心结论
- 快速扩张的出版物与问题研究对健康及生物医学文献诚信构成新威胁,涉及公共卫生与药物安全等领域。
研究设计与样本
- 科学计量学分析,覆盖36个开放获取健康数据集,考察发表率是否偏离既往趋势,并分析作者地理来源变化与公式化标题。
主要发现
- 9个数据集呈现论文工厂利用特征:FDA不良事件报告系统、美国国家健康与营养调查、英国生物样本库、FinnGen、全球疾病负担研究、MIMIC、中国健康与养老追踪调查、CDC WONDER与TriNetX。
- 上述9个数据集2025年在OpenAlex数据库索引的发表量为23005篇,超出ARIMA预测趋势11577篇。
- 该合计发表量是2022年7655篇的3.0倍。
- 中国作者相关倍数变化为4.2倍,世界其他地区为1.9倍,同时公式化标题增加。
临床怎么用
- 在利用开放获取健康数据集开展研究及审稿时,应警惕发表量异常激增、作者来源突变与公式化标题等论文工厂信号。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: The last 3 years have seen an explosion in published manuscripts analyzing open-access health datasets, in many cases presenting misleading or biologically implausible findings. There is a growing evidence base to suggest that this is due in part to artificial intelligence-assisted and formulaic workflows, and publishers are responding by discouraging submissions employing open-access health datasets. METHODS: Here we use a scientometric analysis to investigate which datasets have seen publication rates deviate from previous trends, especially where this coincides with changes to author geographical origins and increases in formulaic titles. RESULTS: Across 36 datasets, we identify nine showing hallmarks of paper mill exploitation (FDA Adverse Event Reporting System, National Health And Nutrition Examination Survey, UK Biobank, FinnGen, the Global Burden of Disease Study, Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care, China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Wide-ranging Online Data for Epidemiologic Research, and TriNetX). These nine datasets had, in 2025, a combined publication count of 23,005 indexed in the OpenAlex database. This represents an excess of 11,577 publications above the AutoRegressive Integrated Moving Average forecast trend, and is a 3.0×-fold change on the 7655 publication count for these nine datasets in 2022. We also identified a notable difference in the fold change for China (4.2×) vs. the rest of the world (1.9×) and an increase in formulaic titles. CONCLUSION: These findings highlight potential risks to research integrity in areas such as public health and drug safety, and especially to the accessibility and interoperability principles central to Open Science and Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Reusable data practices. We argue that permissive open-access data policies naturally facilitate exploitative workflows and that these findings add to the case for the safeguarding mechanisms to preserve the goals of Open Science.
引用
- Spick M, Onoja A, Harrison C, et al. Quantifying new threats to health and biomedical literature integrity from rapidly scaled publications and problematic research. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 41740900. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112203
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。