真实世界证据概念的认识论陷阱
本文是一篇对真实世界证据(RWE)概念进行批判性认识论分析的评论。文章指出RWE缺乏标准化定义且认识论基础薄弱,其术语暗示常规收集数据比受控实验更能捕捉客观真相,实则数据收集本身即为研究者的主动干预,会引入结构性偏倚。作者主张研究者应放弃RWE相关术语,改用精确的研究标签并明确披露数据来源的局限性。
要点
- RWE概念缺乏标准化定义,认识论基础薄弱。
- 数据收集本身是主动干预,会引入结构性偏倚。
- 建议放弃RWE术语,改用精确研究标签并披露局限。
核心结论
- RWE标签是修辞建构,掩盖研究设计并引入客观真相的错觉,应放弃该术语。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为评论性文章,对RWE概念进行批判性认识论分析。
主要发现
- RWE暗示观察性或常规数据收集是被动、中立、无干预的过程,实则数据收集是研究者的主动干预。
- 该干预会修改、过滤并建构所观察的现实,引入结构性偏倚,消除所谓真实真相的证据。
- RCT与观察性研究均无法触及绝对真理,因为观察和控制行为本身已改变现象。
- 追求真实证据造成方法学无政府空间,将缺乏控制误认为真实性,最终产生情境建构而非客观真理。
临床怎么用
- 传统RCT之外收集的数据对决策至关重要,但不应使用真实世界标签。
- 研究者应采用精确的研究标签并明确披露数据来源的局限性,以促进透明度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: 'Real-world' evidence (RWE) and related terms are gaining popularity in the scientific literature, usually in reference to evidence collected outside of traditional randomized controlled trials (RCTs). However, the concept lacks a standardized definition and rests on a poor epistemological foundation. This commentary explores the 'illusion of the real,' arguing that RWE-related terminology undermines scientific transparency by implying that routinely collected data capture an objective truth more effectively than controlled experiments. METHODS: A commentary with critical epistemological analysis of RWE. RESULTS: RWE underpins the epistemological illusion that the collection of observational or routine data is a passive, neutral, or intervention-free process. In fact, collecting data is, in itself, an active intervention by the researcher: an intervention that modifies, filters, and constructs the observed reality. This intervention introduces structural biases that remove any evidence of the supposed 'real truth.' Neither RCTs nor observational studies can perhaps access the absolute truth, since the act of observing and control already alters the phenomenon. The pursuit of 'real' evidence creates an anarchic methodological space where the lack of control is mistaken for authenticity, ultimately producing contextual constructions rather than objective truths. CONCLUSION: Although data collected outside traditional RCTs are essential to decision-making, the 'real-world' label is a rhetorical construct that obscures study design and introduces an illusion of objective truth. Because all scientific inquiries are limited by the observer's methods, 'real-world' claims are essentially fallacious. To promote transparency, researchers should abandon RWE-related terminology in favor of precise study labeling and explicit disclosures of data source limitations.
引用
- Kasputis Zanini LY, Adão D, Martins GC, et al. The epistemological trap from the real-world evidence concept. J Clin Epidemiol. 2026. PMID: 41633476. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2026.112179
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。