产科远程超声:系统综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入71项研究,评估产科远程超声的可行性、可接受性、诊断准确性与成本效益。汇总分析显示远程超声在识别20种解剖结构方面不劣于参考标准(RR 1.02,95%CI [1.00,1.03]),诊断准确性AUC为0.93,但敏感性中等(0.70)。患者与提供者接受度高,但高质量研究不足。
要点
- 远程超声在识别胎儿和胎盘大体结构方面可行性高,心脏和神经等特殊解剖结构可视化率较低。
- 汇总诊断准确性AUC为0.93,敏感性0.70,假阳性率低至0.03。
- 患者操作远程超声进行基本胎儿评估可行且接受度高,尤其适用于农村和中低收入地区。
核心结论
- 产科远程超声具有潜在适用性和价值,但需要更多高质量证据,尤其是临床情境下的应用研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,检索MEDLINE、Embase、CENTRAL、Web of Science和PubMed从建库至2025年12月。
- 共筛选6561篇论文,纳入71项研究:60项临床观察性研究、5项定性研究、4项经济学评价研究和2项随机对照试验。
主要发现
- 同步和异步远程超声图像传输在广泛场景下均可行,足够的技术基础设施(带宽和帧率)对图像质量和减少传输延迟至关重要。
- 20种解剖结构的总体荟萃分析显示远程超声识别不劣于参考标准,RR 1.02(95%CI [1.00,1.03];n=4项研究)。
- 汇总诊断准确性AUC为0.93(n=8项研究),总体敏感性为0.70(95%CI [0.44,0.84]),假阳性率为0.03(95%CI [0.01,0.12])。
- 患者操作远程超声进行基本胎儿评估可行且接受度高;三维、四维和机器人远程超声未显示优于二维扫描。
- 患者和提供者接受度高,满意度和信心提升,经济节省,有助于平衡医疗公平。
关键数值与推荐
- 远程超声识别20种解剖结构不劣于参考标准:RR 1.02(95%CI [1.00,1.03];n=4项研究)。
- 汇总诊断准确性AUC 0.93(n=8项研究);敏感性0.70(95%CI [0.44,0.84]);假阳性率0.03(95%CI [0.01,0.12])。
临床怎么用
- 远程超声可用于产科基本胎儿评估,尤其适合农村和中低收入地区改善医疗可及性。
- 实施时需确保足够带宽和帧率等技术基础设施以保障图像质量。
- 患者操作的远程超声可用于基本胎儿评估,接受度高。
局限性
- 高质量研究代表性不足,需要进一步研究。
- 远程超声系统的方法学和技术能力报告不清晰,难以充分重复研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Ultrasound is a common diagnostic modality in obstetrics to evaluate the fetal condition, frequently used in pregnant women classifying as high-risk. Modifications to guidelines, implementation of national initiatives, combined with an aging obstetric population has led to an increased number of high-risk patients. This places a substantial strain on outpatient obstetric services to accommodate the increased demand for serial antenatal ultrasound scans. Recent advancements in digital technology have enabled the swift innovation of teleultrasound development. The recent pandemic has also substantially influenced technological development, as obstetric services considered alternative solutions to healthcare provision standards. This review aims to assess whether teleultrasound is feasible, acceptable, diagnostically accurate, and cost-effective for antenatal care. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane Database of Clinical Trials (CENTRAL), Web of Science, and PubMed databases from inception to December 2025. Primary research studies evaluating the feasibility, diagnostic accuracy, clinical utility, educational utility, acceptability, and economic viability of antenatal teleultrasound usage were included. Random effects meta-analysis was used, and results were reported as pooled proportions or risk ratio (RR) with 95% confidence interval (CI). Diagnostic accuracy was further assessed using a hierarchical summary receiver operating characteristic model. Of the 6,561 papers screened, 71 studies (60 clinical observational studies, five qualitative studies, four economic evaluation studies, and two randomized controlled trials) were included. Image transfer was feasible for both synchronous and asynchronous teleultrasound transmission, in a wide range of settings. Adequate technological infrastructure, including appropriate bandwidth and framerate requirements were vital factors for sufficient image quality and minimizing transmission delays. Visualizing gross fetal and placental structures using teleultrasound was frequently high; however, more specialized anatomy such as cardiac and neurological demonstrated lower visualization rates. Overall meta-analysis of 20 anatomical structures demonstrated teleultrasound is non-inferior at identification versus the reference standard RR 1.02 (95% CI [1.00,1.03]; n = 4 studies). Pooled diagnostic accuracy demonstrated excellent performance, with an AUC of 0.93 (n = 8 studies). The overall sensitivity was moderate at 0.70 (95% CI [0.44,0.84]), with a low false positive rate of 0.03 (95% CI [0.01,0.12]). There was evidence of educational and clinical utility for obstetric teleultrasound, particularly with novice users, demonstrating improved access to care in rural areas and low- and middle-income countries. Patient-operated telesonography demonstrated feasibility and high acceptability for performing basic fetal assessments. Three-dimensional, four-dimensional, and robotic teleultrasound did not highlight superiority to two-dimensional scanning. Patients and provider acceptability was high, citing benefits in relation to satisfaction, confidence, economic savings, and balancing healthcare equity. Teleultrasound implementation costs can be high, but were frequently accrued due to monthly savings. High-quality studies were underrepresented, suggesting a need for further research. The reporting of clear methodological and technological capabilities of the teleultrasound systems represent the main limitations, proving difficulty to replicate studies adequately. CONCLUSION: This review demonstrated the potential applicability and value of obstetric teleultrasound. This novel care model is everchanging and new devices/systems capable of telesonography are of clinical and scientific relevance. Presently, additional high-quality evidence is required, particularly using teleultrasound in a clinical context, whilst ensuring sufficient methodological detail and consistent outcome reporting.
引用
- Le Vance J, Vaughan M, Bhatia T, et al. Teleultrasound in obstetrics: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Med. 2026. PMID: 41650130. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004922
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。