急性脊髓损伤中通过脑脊液引流靶向脊髓灌注压的多中心前瞻性临床试验
结果显示该方案未能显著改变ITP和SCPP,神经功能恢复无差异(p=0.897),且各中心方案依从性不一致导致试验提前终止。
要点
- 脑脊液引流维持SCPP≥65 mmHg未改善急性SCI患者6个月神经功能恢复。
- 方案实际引流脑脊液量少(495cc,95%CI 350-641),7例未引流,ITP/SCPP无显著变化。
- SCPP组ITP波形 dampened/搏动性记录更多(p=0.006),升压药使用小时数更少(p=0.004)。
核心结论
- 通过脑脊液引流管理SCPP的方案未能显著改变ITP和SCPP,对神经功能恢复无影响。
- 脑脊液引流在创伤性SCI中比在TAAA手术中更复杂,引流体积与ITP变化关系不明确。
研究设计与样本
- 历史对照为86例仅置入鞘内导管测量SCPP并按传统MAP目标85-90 mmHg管理的患者(44±19岁,72M/14F)。
主要发现
- 干预组鞘内导管留置138小时(95%CI 129-147),引流脑脊液495cc(95%CI 350-641),7例未引流。
- 两组ITP和SCPP等血流动力学指标无显著差异,神经功能恢复无差异(p=0.897)。
- SCPP组ITP波形 dampened或完全搏动性记录更多(p=0.006),升压药使用小时数更少(p=0.004)。
- 6例不良事件可能与干预相关。
关键数值与推荐
- SCPP管理方案目标为SCPP≥65 mmHg,通过腰穿鞘内导管引流脑脊液。
- 传统MAP管理目标为MAP 85-90 mmHg。
临床怎么用
- 当前证据不支持通过脑脊液引流常规管理SCPP以改善急性SCI神经功能恢复。
- 未来降低ITP的努力可能需要结合积极手术减压解决损伤部位蛛网膜下腔闭塞。
局限性
- 单臂设计,与历史队列比较,非随机对照。
- 方案依从性在各中心不一致,试验提前终止。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The hemodynamic management of acute spinal cord injury (SCI) aims to improve perfusion and mitigate ischemic secondary injury to the injured spinal cord, traditionally through the augmentation of mean arterial pressure (MAP). Recently, there has been interest in managing spinal cord perfusion pressure (SCPP)-the difference between MAP and intrathecal pressure (ITP) -after acute SCI. SCPP may be more physiologically relevant than MAP for neurologic recovery after traumatic SCI. Drainage of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) through a lumbar intrathecal catheter to reduce ITP and increase SCPP is commonly performed to reduce the risk of ischemic paralysis in thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm (TAAA) surgery. We investigated a protocol for CSF drainage through intrathecal catheters to maintain SCPP ≥65 mmHg in participants with acute traumatic SCI. We sought to determine if managing SCPP was associated with better neurologic recovery compared to traditional MAP targets. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Fifty-eight participants with acute SCI (51 ± 19 years, 46M/12F) were enrolled across eight North American sites between August 2019 and May 2024 into this prospective single-arm multi-center clinical trial of CSF drainage for SCPP management (NCT03911492). Data were compared to data from a historical cohort of 86 participants (44 ± 19 years, 72M/14F) who had intrathecal catheters inserted for SCPP measurement only; these participants were managed according to conventional MAP guidelines with a target MAP of 85-90 mmHg (NCT01279811). MAP, ITP, SCPP, intrathecal waveform morphology, vasopressor use, and CSF drainage volume were reported for up to 7 days following SCI. Fifteen participants in the intervention group were lost to follow-up. Neurological assessments at enrollment and 6-months post-SCI were compared. The investigator team ended the trial when it was clear that adherence to the protocol was inconsistent across study sites. Participants managed according to the SCPP management protocol had an intrathecal catheter in place 138 hours (95% CI [129,147]) and 495cc (95% CI [350,641]) of CSF drained. No CSF was drained from seven participants. There were no significant differences in hemodynamic measures such as ITP and SCPP between groups, indicating that the SCPP management protocol did not alter the hemodynamic management. Subsequently, there were no differences in measures of neurological recovery between participants managed according to SCPP management protocol and conventional MAP guidelines (p = 0.897). Participants managed according to an SCPP target had more ITP waveform recordings noted as dampened or fully pulsatile suggesting a patent subarachnoid space (p = 0.006) and were administered vasopressors on fewer hourly observations (p = 0.004). Six reported adverse events were probably related to the intervention. Adherence to a protocol for managing SCPP through CSF drainage across multiple sites was challenging. CONCLUSIONS: Ultimately, our protocol resulted in little CSF being drained, limited modification of ITP and SCPP, and no effect on neurological recovery. The relationship between CSF drainage volume and change in ITP was surprisingly unclear. This study revealed that draining CSF is more complex in traumatic SCI than in TAAA surgery patients. Future efforts to reduce ITP through CSF drainage likely need to address the occlusion of the subarachnoid space at the injury site through aggressive surgical decompression techniques.
引用
- Gee CM, Tsang A, McKenzie M, et al. Targeting spinal cord perfusion pressure in acute spinal cord injury through cerebrospinal fluid drainage: A prospective multi-center clinical trial. PLoS Med. 2026. PMID: 41642932. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004925
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。