复杂神经外科临床试验(GDNF试验)设计中的公众参与及配套支持方案:反思与建议
该文基于一项神经外科试验规划阶段由14人组成的患者与公众参与(PPI)小组的反思性评估,采用混合方法数据,遵循英国公众参与标准框架,提出涵盖包容性机会、协作、支持与学习、治理、沟通和影响的建议,并共同设计覆盖试验前、中、后的参与者支持方案。作者认为支持方案需在试验中测试以确定其可行性和有效性。
要点
- 建议为所有公众贡献者提供易联系的对接人,并制定明确的评估计划。
- 建议确保共同创造的任务有清晰定义和 tangible 成果。
- 支持方案涵盖试验前、中、后的医疗、社会和心理支持,需在试验中测试。
核心结论
- 作者提出的实用、可推广的建议及新颖的参与者支持方案旨在加强公众参与并提升神经外科试验中的照护。
- 作者认为支持方案需要在试验中测试以确定其可行性和有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 在神经外科试验规划期间,14人组成PPI小组,包括帕金森病患者、照护伙伴和慈善机构工作人员。
- 采用混合方法数据进行反思性评估,数据通过PIRIT追踪工具、会议投票/反思和反思日记收集。
- 支持方案通过两次在线工作坊共同设计,有12名参与者,包括帕金森病患者和照护伙伴。
主要发现
- PPI建议涵盖包容性机会、协作、支持与学习、治理、沟通和影响。
- 支持方案涵盖试验前(心理评估与支持、试验伙伴、来自类似试验参与者的视频和书面案例研究)、试验中(医疗建议与支持、患者联络、心理支持)和试验后(医疗、社会和心理支持)的支持。
关键数值与推荐
- 建议为所有公众贡献者提供易联系的对接人。
- 建议制定明确的评估计划并解决评估中发现的关切。
- 建议确保共同创造的任务有清晰定义和 tangible 成果。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 支持方案需要在试验中测试以确定其可行性和有效性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Neurosurgical trials have a high burden on participants, which underscores the need to involve patients, carers, and the public in trial design to ensure their needs and expectations are met. However, there is currently limited guidance on the establishment, retention, and role of patient and public involvement (PPI) groups in neurosurgical trials, beyond generic guidance, which may contribute to the very low use of PPI in surgical trials. To promote meaningful public involvement in neurosurgical trials based on lived experience, we evaluated our public involvement and developed actionable recommendations. We also co-created a novel support package for neurosurgical trial participants. METHODS: During the planning of a neurosurgical trial, 14 individuals formed a PPI group, including people with Parkinson's, care partners, and charity staff. This reflective evaluation of the group used mixed-methods data collected using the PIRIT Tracking Tool, meeting polls/reflections, and reflective diaries. Our PPI group co-created the resulting reflections and recommendations, which follow the UK Standards for Public Involvement framework. The support package was co-designed in two online workshops, with 12 participants, including people with Parkinson's and care partners. RESULTS: Our recommendations for meaningful PPI cover inclusive opportunities, working together, support and learning, governance, communications, and impact. For example, we recommend providing all public contributors with an approachable point of contact, defining a clear plan for evaluation and addressing concerns identified through evaluation, and ensuring co-created tasks have clearly defined, tangible outcomes. The support package for neurosurgical trial participants spans before (psychological assessment and support; trial buddies; videos and written case studies from participants in similar trials), during (medical advice and support; Patient Liaison; psychological support), and after (medical, social, and psychological support) trial support. CONCLUSIONS: Our practical, generalisable recommendations and novel participant support package aim to strengthen public involvement and enhance care in neurosurgical trials. The support package needs testing within a trial to determine its feasibility and effectiveness.
引用
- Bakshi N, Bale C, Binu T, et al. Public involvement in the design of a complex neurosurgical clinical trial (the GDNF trial) and an associated support package: reflections and recommendations. Trials. 2026. PMID: 41703652. doi:10.1186/s13063-026-09529-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。